Sea of Charms by Sarah Beth Durst
This was, well, charming! It’s the third installment within the world of The Spellshop, the first two of which were also the perfect cozy fantasy. This one focuses on Marin the supply runner, who wants nothing more than to sail the open sea with not a single emotional attachment to anyone. This is, of course, following a bad breakup. She’s over love, over romance, over being beholden to anyone.
But then the capital city goes up in flames, and she takes on an unexpected crew member—Dax, a master musician. Oh and did I mention the talking wax myrtle, Ree? He’s on the boat too, as a sort of apprentice to Marin. As a key focus of her character, Marin is about freedom, especially the freedom for a person to choose what they want to do with their life. Which is a very awesome hill to fight for, except that the minute Dax shows romantic interest in Marin, and the minute she starts to feel like she might reciprocate, she immediately abandons that virtue and describes in great detail, at great length, MULTIPLE TIMES, how Dax is better suited for the music conservatory. He belongs there, guys—even when Dax is describing how much he loves sailing with Marin, seeing the world, how he felt as though the conservatory felt too constrictive. Even when the talking plant calls her on her double standard, Marin will not let it go.
It got to the point that I was just—over it. Of course it ends happily, as cozy fantasies are wont to do, but getting there?? There were quite a few “oh, he’ll never want to stay with me, he belongs in the capital, entertaining the elite!” passages that were completely unnecessary. Like, girl—we get it.
I will say that I adored how the previous characters from the Spellshop world were woven into the story. I love familiar faces, I love seeing outsider perspectives to the stories and characters we know. There was *one* aspect of the previous character interactions that almost sent me into an absolute rage, but I can’t say much more than that without spoiling the damn thing, so ye be warned.
Still, it was a light-hearted, important yet relatively low stakes fantasy. The author does a good job introducing diverse couples into her worldbuilding, but I’m still waiting for her to feature some wlw protagonists. Where are the gays, Sarah Beth?? On a more serious note, there’s a bit more of a content warning in describing the impact of the revolution in the capital city, whereas the first two novels were fairly removed from the aftermath, but it’s not graphic or particularly angsty.
Overall, you liked the previous two installments, you’ll likely enjoy this one. I do recommend reading the others first, due to the interwoven characters, but it could technically serve as a standalone.
Publish Date: July 28, 2026
















