I saw this tiktok of an ACOTAR reader asking the fandom if they'd still read the next book if it wasn't about their preferred ship and it got me thinking...
An Elucien book? I'd be disappointed, but I could read it. After all, it would still be Elain's story and as much as I love Elriel, I want to read about Elain first and foremost. What's her thought process been like throughout the entirety of the series? Is she also haunted the same way Nesta was but is able to hide it better? Does she still mourn her human life or has she completely moved on? Do her powers flare in ways that she hasn't made the others aware of? These are the things that I am dying to know!
While I guess SJM could ultimately manage in convincing me to like Elucien, it would be a difficult process, especially after showing us throughout 2 books + 1 novella how much Elain doesn't want Lucien while developing a romantic bond with another man... Even if she ends up with Lucien, it doesn't change what has happened between her and Azriel:
He was the one to know what was "amiss" with her when it was supposed to be her mate.
She's exchanged charged glances with him while her mate was in the other room.
She was about to kiss (and potentially do more) with Azriel with no regard towards her mate, who was sleeping just one floor above.
How am I, as a potential Elucien, supposed to ever enjoy rereading the series when SJM has done nothing but constantly highlight Elain's discomfort around her supposed endgame and instead showed Elain connecting with another man?
Similarly, how am I supposed to potentially like Gwynriel when...
Azriel has been pining after Elain for a long time and meeting Gwyn, his supposed mate, did nothing to change that.
No matter how much time they spent together at training, Azriel still always struggled to sleep because of his need for Elain.
He bought that beautiful necklace with Elain in mind. The only reason Gwyn may have (she didn't) received it is because Azriel just wanted to be rid of it as he was hurt.
Azriel referred to Gwyn as a good distraction from his thoughts about Elain.
At this point, both Gwyn and Lucien would feel like the second choice that Azriel and Elain went for because they couldn't be with the one they truly want.
If Gwynriel was to happen then I genuinely would have no interest in reading that book. As much as I love Azriel and am keen to get into his head & learn more about him, I just cannot see myself interested in his book with anyone other than Elain. Why? Because one of my favourite things about Azriel is his relationship with Elain.
Throughout the whole series, SJM has established him as this aloof, lethal and introverted character. It's constantly repeated how much characters that aren't in the IC are wary of him due to his reputation. With Elain though? He's completely different and that's what I love.
Mor couldn't convince him to spend his time with her at Rita's for centuries. Surely if he was so in love and "obsessed" with her then he'd love to go, right? On the other hand, we have had multiple scenes where Azriel willingly offers to show Elain the garden and he even stays up with her till late at night to go over her plans for it.
She is the only person that Azriel gave TT to. In all 500 years, he's never gave it to Rhys, Cassian, Mor or anyone else. People who say it's insignificant are lying to themselves.
I don't mind Gwyn as a character, but I just don't care for her. She could die in the first chapter of the next book and I wouldn't bat an eyeđ€·ââïžAs such, I don't feel inclined to read a book about her as the MC. We've learned about her history and seen her deal with the trauma. We've seen her get her own found family. We've seen her journey from the lowest point in her life to becoming a Valkyrie and Carynthian (even tho she doesn't care for the title). Cool! Don't really need or want an ACOSF 2.0 where we see how Gwyn continues to train and gets out of the library. Again...
Anyways, the point to all of this is:
I don't want Elucien, but there is a small chance that I could like it if SJM wrote them accordingly
I hate the thought of Gwynriel and think that Gwyn deserves better than being Azriel's second choice