Tiny Librarian {John Logan x reader} Part 51
Summary: You were stranded at the library in the pouring rain, the last shuttle bus had left just as you got there, you text your brother, Garrett Graham, if he could pick you up after practice. You'll never guess who he sends instead.
Garrett was breathing on the other end.
You heard people moving behind him.
Someone speaking somewhere farther away.
You stared straight ahead.
The television audience applauded again.
“Guilty on the stalking charge.”
Your hand started shaking.
His entire body went still.
“And the unauthorised access.”
A sob broke somewhere inside your chest.
Garrett’s voice cracked completely.
A sound escaped you that was somewhere between a sob and a gasp.
The phone stayed pressed between your ear and his chest.
Garrett was still crying.
Logan held you so tightly you could feel his heart pounding against your cheek.
You weren’t sure whether you were speaking to Logan or Garrett.
Garrett answered through the phone.
“All that fucking time he made me think I was crazy.”
Logan’s hand cradled the back of your head.
Garrett’s voice came quietly through the phone.
Years of being told your reality couldn’t be trusted finally colliding with twelve strangers saying that it could.
Logan pressed his lips against your hair.
“What did Ryan do?” you whispered.
Then Garrett added, “Until they took him down.”
“Judge remanded him until sentencing.”
You stopped breathing for a second.
Garrett’s voice shook with relief.
“He’s not walking out today.”
The sentence settled deeper than everything else.
You looked towards the windows.
For months, every sound outside had carried the possibility of him.
Every vibration of your phone.
Tonight, Ryan wasn’t somewhere out there.
Your body didn’t understand yet.
But for the first time, the danger had a door between you.
One you hadn’t needed to lock yourself.
“When are you coming home?”
The phone slipped from your hand onto the sofa.
For several seconds, you stayed pressed against Logan.
A laugh burst out of you.
It collided with another sob.
Logan smiled through tears of his own.
The words still didn’t feel real.
He had been there through nearly every part.
The nights you couldn’t sleep.
The moments you believed Ryan more than yourself.
Logan had never once demanded that you believe him instead.
He had simply stayed until you were able to believe yourself.
Your hand moved to his face.
Something shifted between you.
Quieter than everything else.
More frightening in an entirely different way.
That almost-word from the morning returned.
Logan looked at you like he remembered it too.
“I almost said something earlier.”
Your heart started beating faster.
“You stopped halfway through a word.”
Despite everything, you smiled.
Logan’s thumb brushed across your wrist.
His expression became serious.
“I don’t want today to be about me.”
“And you don’t have to say anything back.”
Confident, irritating, flirtatious Logan.
When he looked back at you, there was no joke left.
And somehow they felt bigger than the verdict.
Your eyes filled all over again.
Logan immediately panicked.
“You absolutely don’t have to—”
A laugh broke through your tears.
“Don’t make me repeat it.”
“Oh, you’re repeating it.”
“You nearly said it this morning.”
“I’ve emotionally waited months.”
Logan’s face broke into a smile so wide it almost looked painful.
Then his expression softened.
Not like the first night at the party.
No fear of Garrett opening the door.
Just Logan’s hand against your cheek and your fingers curling into his shirt while everything that had happened seemed, for one moment, to move farther away.
When you separated, his forehead rested against yours.
“You know Garrett’s going to hate that our first ‘I love you’ happened while he was gone.”
“He survived you dating his sister.”
The front door opened downstairs.
Garrett’s voice carried through the house.
You pulled away from Logan.
For the first time, you didn’t feel embarrassed to have been caught close to him.
Footsteps came quickly towards the living room.
Dean and Tucker behind him.
Garrett looked at your face.
Then the suspiciously small distance between the two of you.
Garrett pointed at Logan.
“Whatever just happened, undo it.”
“You can’t undo feelings, Graham.”
“Can we have five minutes before the threats start?”
Tucker held up the paper bag from the courthouse café.
The ridiculous hockey house that had somehow become home.
Then something settled over you.
You had expected the verdict to feel like an ending.
Ryan would still need to be sentenced.
Mason still had consequences to face.
There would probably be mornings where your phone vibrating made your stomach drop.
A guilty verdict didn’t erase what happened.
But maybe endings weren’t supposed to erase anything.
Maybe they simply created room for what came after.
Garrett crossed the room and held out his hand.
He pulled you to your feet and immediately wrapped you in a hug.
Dean joined without being invited.
Logan got dragged in last because apparently boundaries had temporarily ceased to exist.
You laughed against somebody’s shoulder.
“Family moment,” Dean announced.
Garrett’s voice came from somewhere near your ear.
Then you answered differently than you usually did.
Garrett’s arms loosened slightly.
Nobody told you that you definitely would.
Nobody promised everything would be easy now.
They just held you for another second.
And for once, uncertainty didn’t feel frightening.
Because whatever came next...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first thing you noticed the next morning was the silence.
Not the absence of noise. The hockey house was never actually silent.
Somewhere downstairs, a cupboard slammed. Pipes groaned inside the wall. Someone—probably Garrett—walked down the hallway with all the subtlety of an elephant in hockey skates.
You lay on your side beneath Logan’s blankets, staring towards the curtains.
For months, waking up had come with an automatic inventory.
Did anything happen overnight?
Is there someone outside?
Every morning, fear arrived before you were properly conscious.
Sometimes you woke already reaching for your phone.
Other times, you would lie completely still and listen for sounds outside the room, trying to convince yourself that footsteps in the hallway belonged to someone you knew.
This morning, your eyes opened—
The knot in your stomach.
The horrible impulse to check the window.
Then the memory of yesterday returned.
The jury had found him guilty.
Ryan had been taken into custody.
He wasn’t walking around campus.
He wasn’t sitting in a car somewhere outside.
He wasn’t waiting at the library.
He wasn’t outside your dorm.
For the first time in months, you knew where he was.
And it wasn’t anywhere near you.
You stared at the ceiling.
Something wet slid towards your hairline.
Then realised you were crying.
Your own whispered voice sounded ridiculous in the quiet room.
Another immediately followed.
Apparently this was happening.
Beside you, Logan stirred.
His hand moved across the mattress in that half-asleep way he had developed since you started staying over more often, searching automatically until his fingertips found your waist.
A second later, his eyes opened.
His voice was rough with sleep.
You wiped your face quickly.
“You have tears on your face.”
He stared at you for a second.
A tiny laugh escaped you.
Logan’s teasing disappeared.
He rolled onto his side, but he didn’t immediately reach for your face.
You looked towards the curtains again.
“Not today,” you whispered.
“He can’t just decide to drive over.”
“He can’t follow me to class.”
“He can’t find some stupid excuse for accidentally being wherever I am.”
You covered your face with both hands, embarrassed even though there was nobody in the room except him.
“You can be happy and still cry.”
“You also feel everything before breakfast.”
You lowered your hands enough to glare at him.
You turned onto your back.
“I thought I’d feel different.”
“I thought I’d wake up and feel…”
You searched for the word.
“Why would it be horrible?”
“Because he hasn’t been sentenced yet. And there’s appeals and Mason and all the other stuff.”
“None of that means you can’t feel relieved.”
“What if I get used to feeling safe and then something changes?”
Everything good was temporary.
You knew how quickly it could be taken away.
Logan reached towards you slowly.
You moved into his hand before he needed to ask.
His palm settled against your cheek.
“Then we deal with what changes when it changes.”
“I want you to say nothing will change.”
His thumb moved gently beneath your eye.
“But you’d know I was lying.”
“You once told Dean the scratch on his car came from a shopping cart.”
“You were driving the shopping cart.”
“That detail wasn’t relevant.”
It came out through the last of your tears.
He looked at you for another second before his smile softened.
You remembered yesterday.
The nervous way he’d looked down before finally saying it.
Logan seemed to realise what you were thinking at exactly the same time.
His ears went slightly pink.
“I said something very emotionally mature yesterday.”
“You panicked halfway through saying it on the phone.”
“You tried to claim you were saying ‘lunch.’”
“It was a strong recovery.”
He groaned and buried his face in the pillow.
“I'm never letting that go.”
Then his expression became quieter.
“I don’t take the other part back.”
“You don’t have to say it every time I do.”
For some reason, saying it this morning felt different.
Yesterday had been overwhelming.
Months of emotions breaking open at once.
Today there was no courtroom.
Just messy hair and morning breath and Logan lying beside you with a crease from the pillow across his cheek.
His smile appeared slowly.
“You were staring directly at me.”
“Emotionally distracted.”
He caught your wrist gently and tugged you closer.
Your forehead rested against his chest.
Logan’s arm wrapped around you.
“I love you too,” he murmured against your hair.
You smiled into his T-shirt.
Downstairs, Garrett was making pancakes.
You stopped in the kitchen doorway beside Logan.
There was flour on the counter.
Smoke rising faintly from a pan.
Dean stood several feet away with his arms crossed, looking personally offended.
Tucker had his head in his hands.
Four heads turned towards you.
Garrett immediately pointed the spatula at Tucker.
“You put pancake batter in a dry pan on maximum heat.”
“That's how cooking works.”
“No,” Tucker said slowly. “It genuinely is not.”
Dean noticed you properly.
Then moved towards Logan.
“I haven't said anything.”
Garrett looked suspicious.
Garrett stared between you and Logan.
You could practically see his older-brother instincts beginning to activate.
“Breakfast happened,” you said quickly.
“No. Something else happened.”
Logan shoved his hands into the pockets of his sweatpants.
Garrett pointed the spatula at him.
“I always look like this.”
Tucker’s eyes moved between the two of you.
Then understanding appeared on his face.
Garrett turned towards him.
Tucker immediately looked down at the pan.
Dean bit down on his bottom lip.
Dean made a sound somewhere between a laugh and a cough.
Garrett dropped the spatula onto the counter.
“Knew what?” you asked, far too innocently.
“You think I didn't hear him yesterday?”
Logan rubbed a hand over his face.
“You nearly said it on speaker.”
“I forgot you were there.”
“You forgot her brother was on the phone?”
“There was a trial happening, Graham. My attention was divided.”
“This is none of your business.”
Dean finally lost the battle and burst out laughing.
Garrett turned towards Logan.
“My sister was supposed to have casual feelings.”
“She launched herself at me after four days apart.”
Garrett pointed aggressively.
“I'd forgotten about that.”
You moved towards the counter and grabbed a pancake from the plate.
Garrett slapped your hand away.
You stared at the blackened edges.
Tucker quietly slid a different plate towards you.
Behind you, Garrett was still staring at Logan.
Logan’s expression changed.
The humour faded slightly.
Garrett obviously hadn't expected the answer to be that straightforward.
He looked at Logan for several seconds.
Not enough to stop him being Garrett.
Garrett picked up the spatula.
Logan looked equally suspicious.
Garrett pointed at him again.
“If you break her heart, I break—”
“Every bone in my body,” Logan finished. “We've covered this.”
“Beautiful family moment.”
You shoved a piece of pancake into his mouth.
Breakfast lasted nearly an hour.
Mostly because Tucker confiscated the frying pan and started over.
You sat between Logan and Garrett at the kitchen island while Dean told a story you had already heard twice and somehow still made entertaining.
At some point, you realised nobody was talking about the trial.
Nobody was talking about Ryan.
You looked towards the window.
Morning sunlight spilled across the garden.
Your eyes automatically checked the street beyond the fence.
You didn't get up to check.
You didn't ask Logan whether he recognised the car.
You just turned back around.
Logan was stealing food from your plate.
“You're not eating that.”
Heat rushed into your face.
Dean’s head snapped towards you.
“Oh, we're saying it casually now?”
“This is going to be unbearable.”
He grinned around the stolen piece of pancake.
Something warm settled into your chest.
Not the dramatic rush from yesterday.
Maybe this was what freedom actually looked like.
Not forgetting what happened.
Not suddenly becoming the person you had been before Ryan.
Maybe freedom was waking up and having other things matter more.
Garrett threatening Logan over breakfast.
Tucker complaining about the state of his kitchen.
Being told I love you without wondering what you owed in return.
Your phone buzzed on the counter.
Logan didn't ask if you wanted him to check.
Dean didn't stop talking.
You looked at the screen yourself.
Hannah: How are you this morning? ❤️
You: actually... I think I'm good
Put your phone face down.
And returned to breakfast.
Logan's knee bumped yours beneath the counter.
For once, the answer arrived without needing to be examined first.
And this time, when you said it—
you weren't trying to convince anyone.
Taglist {open}: @notsosweetcreature @dina2223 @haydee5010 @rexit-mo @kmc1989 @mads-writes-vibes @superbfishhumanoidweasel @brianna28483 @m3lodyxo @antisocialfiore @sunshinevansh @girlidekanymore @nihoshi17 @em1ly57 @jamesmackreideswife @ralilda @k3nz13a @wilmonyibo7 @solstice-333 @aajames217 @wintermoonly @f4ll-for-you @ilocuras24 @garrettgrahamssexysnaps @parker-barnes-af @katrinaellie @caffeinatednerd90 @ryswritingrecord @wolfiee10 @daykrisr9libraries