Tortured Overthinker

“ Why didn’t you tell me?”

Tell you what?”

“That Blank is texting you.”

“Because they’re not?”

“Yes they are. They just texted me this morning and said they tried to text you, but you never read it. They’ve been really sad about it all morning and said that it’s a sign that they’re finally being rejected.”

“First of all I didn’t read their texts because they’re blocked. Second of all they are going to stay blocked because they’ve been rejected for over a year now, and it’s going to stay that way. I do not want them.”

Btw they were also talking to a minor who wasn’t even in middle school yet while they just graduated high school and were making jokes abt marriage with said minor and entertaining the idea of dating them…

In general I think Newt would be “Creep” by Radiohead and Thomas would be “The Chain” by Fleetwood Mac. But depending on specific fics I think that for The Knife Between us it would be “The Line” by Twenty One pilots or “Nobody’s Soldier” by Hozier. Newt would be “Fight or Flight” by Conan Gray. Honorable mention: “Scared of my guitar” by Olivia Rodrigo because it’s just SO Newtmas coded.l, and the “Doubt” by Twenty One Pilots

But honestly there are so many more and I have entire playlists built for so many different vibes. My red flag is that I make playlists over every minor inconvenience.