after reading your ask abt the butchering of pokemon contests post-dp (which i do agree with), im curious to know what your thoughts on the gender segregation with pokemon showcases are? even when i was 12, i thought it was odd showcases were segregated as a “girls only” activity, and im still not entirely sure how to feel about it. idk if its just the nostalgia talking since i grew up with dp—but i always liked the gender inclusivity of pokemon contests. this just doesn’t extend to the inclusion of male coordinators and the fact ash willingly competed in a few as well, but also in terms of gender expression as well through characters like zoey with how she consistently dressed on suits, or harley with his more feminine appearance and flamboyant mannerisms. my memory may be incorrect so idk, but i really do not recall seeing a masc-presenting performer EVER in the xy/z saga.
I mean, I hate a good chunk of Kalos saga's writing decisions so... of course I despise Showcases being a girls only activity lmao I would even argue that XY's popularity is even a determining factor for the change in contests in JNs (⚆3⚆) I mean it sure is interesting only Serena was allowed to participated in the watered down "spetacular" contests that worked exactly like showcases...
But that's not here nor there. Onto Showcases being girls only: I hate when people bring up the "idol" aspect to defend Showcases being gender segregated, because;
male idols exist. In fact, K-pop, with its pletora of boybands started to explode worldwide around 2012-2019 before becoming the pillar of pop culture that it is today. american boybands have been a thing and extremly popular at that since the 90s? Why not capitalize on that aspect as well?
the most popular idols in japan tend to be part of an idol "group". I've talked about this before, but if pokeani really wanted to emphasize the idol aspect and culture of their own country, why not focus on something meant to be done as a group instead of the individualistic approach they actually went for?
So not only showcases were deliberately written to exclude men for no real reason but also to force competition between girls when the focus could easily have been on sisterhood and women working together towards a shared goal instead. Men cant be artists and female rivalry! That's two on two on the gender essentialism bingo👍
And another thing that reeks of misogyny in showcases that was never a problem in contests before is all of the girl's aesthetics and presentation. Like you said, amongst all the girls that appear in Kalos showcases, there's literally 1 single performer whose style is somewhat more masculine (and that's me being extremely generous?! this is not masculine, she's just not wearing a skirt)
Not only there's no place for boys in showcases, neither there is for masculine looking girls. Not only are characters like Drew and Harley not welcome in this environment, but neither is Zoey. Congrats, you created an tournament that excludes everyone!
All the girls there are expected to wear flowing skirts and do pretty dances where they float in the air like fairies, to be feminine, to be pretty, to be perfect. If they make a mistake, they dont get enough votes and not even as much a second chance. If they are creative and step out of the norm, they are activelly punished for it.
Never ever forget Jessie's first showcase attempt and how she got to dress up herself and her pokemon with matching outfits that emphasized the ghostly aspect of her ghost pokemon, pumpkaboo's pumpkin shape and also made reference to the french fairy tale Beauty and the Beast AND SHE LOST!!! Because the audience deemed it UGLY!!
And when you look at the freestyle rounds, all of them were created to fit in with Serena and not for her to adapt to them. That's a writing flaw and not really a sexism issue in my eyes, but the fact that the only ´possible challenges the writers could come up for Serena were *checks notes* dressing up. baking. vague trivia quiz. baking again. rhyhorn-fucking-herding; it creates a pattern that does reeks of mysoginy.
Showcases were created to center Serena, and even then the writers couldn't think of anything interesting for her to do in those that would actually be challenging for her? Only "stereotypical girl stuff" and "one single thing her mother taught her"? Really? How about art, sculpture, singing or anything artistic that matched the "entertainment" aspect of being a performer and an idol? How about competitions focusing on pokemon and human bonds since thats the WHOLE point of the franchise? Like Furfrou trimming, pokemon catching and fishing, pokemon sky/water/land racing, pokemon cosplay? Why, never once did we have a freestyle round that had the theme simply be battles?
One thing I especially loved about contests in the anime is that despite being an aspect that was more catered to the female audience (certainly worked with me lol; I used to—and still do to an extent—adore contests) it never made the gender discussion a plot point even though it would have been so easy to do. If Drew and Harley and ece Kenny and Nando want to do contests, the discussion was never about whether their gender would allow it.
Showcases don't have that discussion explicitly, but there's at the very least an implied bias there (and that's me being generous). And I love your point about Jessie's dress up in that episode. It was singlehandedly the most creative thing anyone has done in that episode, yet she failed because there's no judge and the winning criteria is so arbitrary.
Almost all the flaws in how Showcases are portrayed in the anime is because they're catered to Serena's character. Because unfortunately, beyond being cute and indecisive initially and having a crush on Ash, Serena... doesn't have much going for her character.
May had her arc about constantly falling short of her rivals and going from a rookie who didn't know a thing ti veing an experienced trainer and coordinator, and Dawn had her confidence arc and her learning that just because her mother's a coordinator and she grew up wantign to be one doesn't mean she'll automatically be good at it. Even the non-coordinator girls like Misty and Iris had an arc about maturity (imo Iris was handled better than Misty because the OG series' pacing was really bad, but it's been a long time since I watched any Pokemon series—and OG series especially).
Meanwhile, Serena is someone who, it feels to me, was never a character the writers were truly interested in fleshing out. Which is why she doesn't get to struggle the way the rest did. Serena sucks at battling. If Showcases were more like Contests, we could have had an inverse Dawn arc, where Serena would be better at appeals but suck at the battling aspect. But because she's never allowed to grow and change, showcases are conveniently made to not have any kind of battling. Heck, in the entire anime, Serena never gets a full fight against anyone who's not Team Rocket (aka pokemon jobbers). All her major battles are conveniently interrupted (and to begin with, they're never agianst an opponent who wouldn't treat her with kid gloves)
Because of the writers' refusal to let Serena strughle in any way, we get the stupid aspects of showcases that are conveniently tailored to Serena's character (because we don't actually see her try to get better at showcaaea beyond practicing the one appeal she uses in every single one, outside of that one XY ending song). Dressing up pokemon, baking, performing while baking (because that's so different) are all stuff she's already good at (because she's a girl and these are girl things *eyeroll*). The two things that could be perhaps more gender neutral are a quiz (which I don't recall being super hard) and Ryhorn herding. Which. Again, it's an activity tailored to Serena through her mother, and even then, the Ryhorn just gather towards her without her doing a thing which is just... They could have made her not do well for once but they chose not to because *checks notes* her mother is good with Ryhorns. I could buy Serena being good with them because she grew up around kne, but she doesn't even have to lift a finger there smh.
It doesn't help that Serena's biggest rival in Miette and even she doesn't really challenge Serena in showcases as much as she does for her crush on Ash, which is, to me, the least interesting aspect of her character and the most shoehorned thing in XY
A freestyle performance that also functions as a battle royale would go hard ngl. And stuff like ice sculpting. It would be nice to see Jessie's experience as a coordinator shine through as I genuinely believe that Jessie would be a better coordinator than Serena if the writing wasn't made to baby Serena throughout her journey. But because the writers' want her to be seen as the token cute love interest, we get showcases instead of contests. Normally, I wouldn't care but the fact that they are retconning contests into showcase-adjacent events make me wish that XY neevr happened













