[BRIM HAT!CALEB x WITCH!READER] Your old love stops by the atelier, and bittersweet memories come rushing forward.
CW — witch hat atelier!au, angst, lovers to exes, body modification, reader has an unspecified illness, forceful memory erasure, gn!reader, feat. watchful eye!zayne, witch!rafayel, & a few side characters as kid apprentices, UNEDITED
The kids are tucked in their beds, out like a light for the night, after a long day of practicing their penmanship and cleaning up the mess of ink they somehow managed to get all over themselves. Rafayel said his goodnight a while ago too, sequestering himself away in his workshop to undoubtedly continue to work on his next 'masterpiece'.
'A most beautiful and brilliant invention by the one and only witch, Rafayel' as he calls it.
You decide to stay up. The full moon is out, beaming through clear skies, and leaving little work for your lamp as you kneel beside the flower beds. You pick up a clay pot housing a budding flower and tilt it just enough to see the automatic watering spell drawn on the bottom of the pot. Licking your thumb, you smear parts of the spell to nullify it. Tomorrow the kids will work on filling in the original spell.
You're sure they'll figure it out quickly—they're smart kids, after all. The only ones you're worried about are the twins and Isaiah. They'll be too busy trying to figure out how to turn the pot into an elaborate prank, but you could never fault their creativity.
"Working hard as always."
Your hands retreat into your cloak on instinct, reaching for the palm quire tucked away in your inner pocket. With ease, you flip to a page where a defensive spell is pre-drawn. All you need to do is aim and close the circle. Only, the person you find on the other side of the fence sends a cold shock through your body.
"Leave now or I'll call the Knights," you say, leaving your voice devoid of any emotion despite the ache in your chest as you glower at the Brim Hat lingering by the fence.
"I know you wouldn't."
It's strange how so much can change in so little time. Only two months ago, you stitched up his pointed hat after the twins' fire ball prank got too out of hand and left a crater in the field behind the atelier. He sat at your side the whole time, arm resting against yours as you worked. The two of you settled in a peaceful silence, basking in the summer sun while the kids worked on fixing the field under Rafayel's semi strict supervision.
You blamed the summer heat for the warmth crawling up your cheeks as Caleb leaned in to praise your careful stitch work. His fingers brushed the valley of your knuckles, slipping your hands together in a swift movement, forcing you to stall your work. "It's no wonder you're a talented witch. You've got such steady hands."
You rolled your eyes, but made no move to remove your hand from his. Instead, you gazed into his violet eyes and leaned in to place a quick peck on his lips. "Do you want your hat fixed or not?"
His stunned expression melted into an easy grin as he hummed, "mhmm."
You tapped the tip of his hat against his cheek, ignoring the way he leaned in. "Then stop flirting and let me focus."
"You started this," he teased, eyes flickering down to your lips.
"Did n- mph!" He pulled you into a deep kiss, silencing your argument. His hat falls from your hands as you thread your fingers through his hair instead.
The memory burns.
As you look at the man before you, clad in dark robes and a brimmed hat that covers the eyes you once knew, it get harder to breathe. You want nothing more than to run up and tear that stupid hat right off his head. It doesn't suit him. It never will.
"I could scream, and Zayne will be out here in a second," you threaten, though, it holds no real weight. You turn your head. It has always been hard to lie to him. Even now, when he has betrayed everything you thought you knew about him. You find it too easy to want to forgive him, especially when he still looks at you like you were the best thing that's ever happened to him.
Maybe things would be easier if he just let the Knights Moralis erase his memories—even if that meant forgetting you and everything you shared. It'd be so easy to capture him, shout for Zayne, and have him taken away, yet you don't move an inch.
"Why are you here?"
"I wanted to see you."
"You should have stayed away." You wish your voice held more conviction instead of teetering off into a quiet waver.
"But I can't," Caleb admits. He reaches for you with his ink stained hand. Intricate sigils permanently etched into his skin cover the expanse of his hand and lead up his arm. You can't quite tell exactly what he has drawn onto himself without being able to look closely. But even when you had the chance to study it, you couldn't comprehend anything other than horror.
"I miss you," he whispers, now. His touch is warm, just like that summer day memory permanently etched in the corners of your mind and heart. And you still can't find it in you to pull away. "So much."
Your mouth twists into a frown as traitorous words dare to form on the tip of your tongue. So, you stay silent, letting him inch closer, allowing his hand to travel over your shoulder and neck.
"I know you don't understand why I'm doing this, and you don't have to."
You didn't understand then—and you don't understand now. You never will.
A mysterious illness befell you last winter, leaving you bedridden and weak. Everyone in the atelier was worried. The children kept you company when they could, telling you about all the new techniques they learned that day. Zayne and Rafayel took turns visiting you throughout the day in an attempt to keep your spirits up.
But, Caleb was a constant at your side. He refused to let you be alone for a second. He hand fed you breakfast, lunch, and dinner despite your insistence that you were strong enough to feed yourself. He held you tightly in his arms as he carried you to the restroom when your legs wobbled. He stayed with you though the night, pulling you to his chest and letting you fall asleep in his arms.
As the days passed, you found yourself slowly getting better. You were able to get out of bed, spend more time with your students, and bask in the sunlight rather than the stuffy four walls of your bedroom. But as you got better, the less and less you saw Caleb.
Reclusive and seemingly always tired, he lingered in the shadows longer. You figured it was hard for him watch as you deteriorated, but now that you were better, he could finally relax. A hopeful and foolish thought.
When you decided enough was enough and he couldn't keep hiding away in his room, you barged in one night to find him hunched over his desk. Crumpled paper was scattered around the room and pools of ink stained his desk. He held a wand in one trembling hand.
"What are you doing here?" He didn't sound surprised, just tired. The exhaustion had sunk into his bones and rotted him inside out.
Your eyes darted to the uncovered arm resting on the table. Circles of ink covered his unnaturally pale skin. The ink swirls and blurs on his arm like it's alive, siphoning the life from his arm.
You rushed forward and gripped his arm, nails digging into his pale flesh, now forever scarred by his foolishness. "What have you done to yourself?" You voice trembled with both fury and panic.
There was a cold, hollow look in his eyes as he regarded you with silence.
Your hand scrubbed over the ink, scrubbing, hoping that it would disappear with the motion and it was just a cruel prank. But you both knew his choice was final and nothing would ever be the same.
It's hard to look at him beneath that brimmed cap.
"I just want you to be happy," he admits.
"How can I be? When you're throwing everything away, and for what?" Your body is so tense it aches and sways. All you want to do is grab him by the shoulders and shake whatever ridiculous ideas he has in his head, scream your heart out and beg him to rethink his decisions. "Please—just stay. We'll find a way to fix this together."
His eyes waver on yours, eyes glossing over. His breath catches in his throat.
"I… can't." He shakes his head. The hesitation on his face dissolving into resolve, hardened and nothing like the gentle violet eyes of the man you love. "I'm sorry it has to be like this. You deserve so much more than me."
Caleb lunges and clamps his hand around your mouth, forcing you to the ground and pinning you with his body. He smothers your voice and brings a palm quire toward your eyes. The dark hands of his spell reach toward you with spindly fingers that latch onto your temples.
Your back hits the grass and cold, harsh realization claws at you, dragging you under, as the spell begins to work its magic on your mind. This isn't the first time he's done this, is it?
Your words are muffled behind his hand that refuses to let you scream. How could you?
"If only you could understand," he whispers as the edges of your vision blur and fade until there is nothing left but him twisted with anguish. "If saving you means my body rots away, I hope there's nothing left for you to mourn."
Your body grows weaker, slipping into unconsciousness. Like ink washing away, images of tonight—flower pots, moonlight, a brimmed cap—blur and fade into nothing until there is only a blank canvas.
—
"Hey! Hey, wake-y wake-y, teach!"
"You think they're dead?"
"Don't say things like that!"
Gentle hands coax you out of your slumber. Heavy, fluttering eyes open to six familiar children peering down at you, a mixture of worry and relief on their faces.
"Are you alright?" Hands belonging to caring green eyes ease you to a sitting position. "Careful now. Did you collapse?"
You groan, "I-"
What remains of your memory are fragments of moonlight and warmth blossoming on your hand. You stare down at your open palm as if you could concentrate hard enough to bring that fleeting warmth back.
"I think I… fell asleep out here."
Zayne's cold hand moves to cup your cheek as he examines the far away look in your eyes. "Is the new medication making you drowsy?"
"Um," you think, but all that comes up is blank.
Rafayel stands to the side, analyzing the area with quiet scrutiny before clapping his hands and drawing the childrens' attention. "Why don't you all help them inside and get breakfast started?"
The twins are the first to hop up, exclaiming at the same time, "I'll start the fire!"
The children along help you stand. They guide you back to the atelier while Zayne and Rafayel stay behind.
Rafayel doesn't waste time before pointing his finger at Zayne. "Isn't your whole job to—oh, I dunno—watch?" he hisses. "So things like this never happen?"
Zayne doesn't let his expression give anything away. He lowers Rafayel's hand and replies with steady ease, though his heart is anything but. "He's concealing himself from my spells."
"Obviously," Rafayel drawls, rolling his eyes toward the drifting, scattered clouds. "We have to tell them he's been visiting."
Zayne glances toward the kitchen window where you're lifting Tara up so she can reach for bowls. Your smile is light, tired, and doesn’t light your eyes the way it used to before Caleb left. "Carefully,” he replies slowly. “It won’t be easy."
The purple haired witch sighs. His head is beginning to ache. All he wants is a long soak in the bath. "Our old friend really is an idiot."
A/N — was this just an excuse to write caleb w a full sleeve? maybe……… i hope this au makes everyone go and read/watch witch hat atelier bc it’s so amazing i need everyone to enjoy it
TAGS — @kingraspberry12-blog @dreamsandmoonlight @xxvendettaxx @heartofafiend @fantastucbaby @bouncingballofbuff @meemska @zayora @sunniisky @theeidare @urlocalash1 @w1nter-n1ght @missileprincess @kingkaisen @imaginationofafan @itsmeaudrieee @pixiu-palindrome @yandere-kou @partycityyyyyyy @aenishas @gardenialily @calistaxoxo24 @angeleclair
















