Hey! I heard the news about the game! I'm just here to say my thanks, because lord knows this community has been waiting for something new for years now. You tackling an entire game is admirable and I only wish the best of luck for you!
Anyways, since you wanted plot holes, I'll drop some here for you:
β Dusekkar doesn't know Scriptliss is in his trash can.
β Antagon kinda caused a war and killed someone but only got a month's worth of community service. (I'd either lessen his crimes or actually make him face the consequences)
β While on that topic, how did Antagon even steal the plot book anyway?
β Plus, how did Antagon learn of Scriptliss? And why didn't he do anything with him when he released him in the first place?
β How did Scriptliss end up in the middle of a forest when he got released?
β Tucker doesn't have a reason for why he wants to infiltrate Rozanda's ship.
β Antagon has no established motivation. He also lacks consistency. (Naive enough to not realize he's harming people while simultaneously starting a war to "cut short the supply of able-bodied soldiers...")
β Antagmom doesn't know her son is a war criminal.
β Dusekkar wasn't there for Tess' death and got the news in a random shop. Not a plot hole, just something really weird.
β The inconsistencies of the people who know the sages. ----> Scriptliss knows Lanter is a sage but doesn't know that his best friend, Tess, is a sage. ----> Otempes spontaneously gained the knowledge that the third door shouldn't be opened, and he knows Tess?? ----> The dialogue is weird and made it seem like Dusekkar only knows Lanter is a sage and not the others. Personally, I'd just simplify it so that only the sages know other sages, and maybe Dusekkar knows them all. It makes no sense for Scriptliss to know the sage thing about Lanter after meeting him just once.
β Literally, what is Cogen. Mind reading how??
β The villain's motivation and them not questioning the fact they're working for a child.
β Aristris being down for killing Tretone and not facing jail time for it.
β Tretone died and they turned his dead body into a fucking Christmas tree lol
β Scriptliss performing in a concert shortly after Tess' death. Also... they invited the villains to play as well... They should all be in jail.
That's about all I can think of.
Also, regarding your theory about Lanter. I think you're pretty spot on! But also, I'd like to think it was a culmination of things that ruined their relationship, maybe something as simple as them having different ideologies and that slowly growing into bigger and bigger disagreements. The dethroning of the old gods was probably the last straw.
I feel that Lanter's thing with Equinox needs a big of tweaking by the way. After all, Lanter denounced Equinox in the same sentence that he said he sided with him. So it would be odd that he'd hate Dusekkar because of Equinox even though he himself doesn't like Equinox either. Hope that makes sense!
Make the game 2d. That's all I have to say regarding that.
Sorry for the long message, it took me a bit to get this all down. I hope you have a nice time working on the game, I know these things can be difficult, especially with the source material being as convoluted as it is. Good luck! And stay strong, you have my blessing! πͺ
Ohh mmyyyy godd tysm for this message actually Ive been having trouble getting all the plot holes together π i canβt promise that ill fill spr plot holes bc the game im planning on doing is before spr but ill try to do smth π«‘
Also yeah tackling an entire game is probably an insane idea for me but honestly as someone who has absolutely loved paper roblox ever since 2016 im a bit excited to actually start working on it.
It probably will take me a really long time too (i mean i am asking a family member who is skilled at using blender and roblox studio but still) but ty for the blessings and also the list of plot holes πβ€οΈ
