Piper at the Gates of Dusk
Piper at the Gates of Dusk by Patrick Ness
WOW, it is just as easy to fall right back into Chaos Walking as it was fifteen-plus years ago. Patrick Ness has such a compelling and readable style, where every voice is distinct and the words never get in the way of the message, and it’s just so thrilling to return to this world after so long.
a similar amount of time seems to have passed in the story as in real life; the narration this time is shared by Todd and Viola’s teenage children, Ben and Max. it’s a markedly different world than when we left it—though i’ll be honest, i haven’t reread the original trilogy in a long time, and went into this recalling only the basics. a widely-adopted cure for the Noise seems to have eliminated it almost entirely; humans and the Land—Spackle—exist in an uneasy peace. but the book wastes no time! the first scene introduces a new and terrifying problem: giant, screaming, skinless, fire-wreathed gods that appear suddenly, wreak destruction, and vanish just as fast.
Ness has such a straightforward but vivid way of relaying the terror and tension of every moment that follows. the mystery of what’s happening builds incrementally, interspersed between fascinatingly gray areas of interpersonal and political struggle. there’s no simple, clear-cut right or wrong, no easy fixes, and the young brothers’ alternating POVs skillfully model the theme of the whole within their relationship: that even across (some) disagreeing viewpoints, communication and empathy can build a better world. (but sometimes it’s still necessary to punch a bigot.)
i also loved the specificity of the brothers! book smart, fussy Ben, who speaks through sign and and an electronic device because of a side effect of the Noise cure, and foul-mouthed, courageous Max, whose transness is important, but not the whole or the focus of his story. these two have such good hearts, and that kindness permeates the book.
but in true Ness style, the epilogue is not so much a resolution as a first salvo in what will be the conflict of the next book—so don’t expect to finish this one with all the answers!
how i read it: in hardcover on a long car ride! it was a birthday present from my besties, who were just as excited to read more Chaos Walking as i was, and i had a great time live texting my reactions.
try this if you: loved the original trilogy! this one could stand alone if you’re VERY willing to go with the flow, but why not just read all the books? they’re very good!
some lines i really liked: two really clear examples of the very plainspoken incisiveness that permeates this book
Most of those kids were treated with different kinds of neurological stimuli and therapies and all that and were able to speak again.
Only one kid on this whole planet didn't change.
Guess who.
Now don't get any stupid ideas. This story, whatever it is, isn't about me "finding my voice." I have a voice just fine, thank you. It's in my face and my gestures and my words. When I'm talking to people outside my family, I type them (pretty fast) into a comm that reads them out for me.
I can't speak, but I'm not without a voice. Okay?
The problem is that over the years, Pop's grown to think the cure was a mistake.
Burly's not buying all that, by the way. He ways it's just a rock. Nothing to be worried about. He's saying the scientists are "maybe overreacting." He "understands their caution," but a link between the rock out there and the dream outbreak "seems implausible" and it's more likely caused by some kind of disease or contagion, most likely caught from the Spackle (Burly does not call them the Land), and he says his own medical team supports him on the disease idea, though I know Mom doesn't think much at all of his medical team, which somehow still includes Margery Wingard, whose little church I pass on my walk.
Though the first thing I notice is that it's not so little as it used to be.
pub date: April 7, 2026! i read something very recent for a change instead of a year belated. go get it, and read the other Chaos Walking books while you're at it!