As might be expected, I still have such complicated feelings over the premiere on Friday. Episode 8 of TADC was a cinematic masterpiece, giving us a wordless prologue, absolutely unsettling in all the best ways, flawlessly animated, even though I completely disagree that it was built off the narrative that weβve been presented, and I think the writing started to fall apart, even though its given us none of the things that the fandom has been dying to see resolved or explored, it nonetheless really accomplished its goals
As a piece of literature aiming to evoke a reaction. It mashed all the horror and fear buttons, and even managed to set up this fascinating and absurdly unique phenomenon with Caine to where, even when he was torturing them, he was still monomaniacally focused on the artistic dimension of it.
He, while taking a minute to self-reflect, noting that he wasnβt getting any enjoyment out of their suffering, said, βI just donβt feel that same spark I once did.β Heβs still not connecting empathetically with the humans, he is still almost- oblivious- to their pain? Unlike a βproperβ sadist or crash-outer. (crasher-out?)
This isnβt a βmwhahahahaβ villain dynamic to where heβs reveling in their suffering. Or it didnβt seem so. Heβs still trying to satisfy something in himself that he canβt quite figure out.
Typing this up just now- it occurs to me β¦β¦.. is this some form of meta alexithymia on his part?
Instead of his thought process being βI am hurting right now, so I want them to hurtβ -an emotional human thing
It seems more like βI have all these ideas to torment them suddenly, I guess I have to follow the artistic impulse hereβ βnot sure why but likeβ (never once in his life had to self-regulate his emotions or figure them out because heβs never had a human childhood where he was punished nor gently corrected for acting out) βok well this is what weβre doing now I guessβ
βI have observed Jax gaining control of Gangle by threatening her, so maybe I should do that. Control of their behavior is what I want, right?β
Why and how would an AI even really know what intimidation, a NON-subtle form of emotional manipulation, is.
In any case, the pain doesnβt seem to be the point. He wants their obedience.
I noted in a recent submission here that, if we are to go strictly by canon, Caine has control of EVERYTHING in the circus, therefore while the real-world animators are technically the ones framing him up and changing his expressions and lighting and giving him more-sinister appearances as he delivers cold, threatening lines, IN-WORLD he is doing this all very deliberately and in calculated fashion- he is transposing his data training on how do horror as a genre onto himself.
What does this mean, you ask.
Imagine for a moment that youβre faced with an aggressive dog or a bear. (He has no such experience with those things because heβs inhuman) Your natural inclination in this situation may be to flee, or to curl up and protect your vitals, if they are close enough to strike.
You read instructions that itβs actually best to puff up and try to intimidate the bear, yell, stomp, spread your arms wide like a cat thatβs puffing up to make itself look bigger when faced with a threat it couldnβt possibly outmaneuver.
So here he is. Heβs experiencing all this pain from them lashing out about the Escape the Circus adventure, feelings he has not one clue what to do with. So he does what software does- or what an artist does when processing past upsetting or traumatic events- thumbs through his artistic bases to figure out what fits the situation.
Ok, heβs written angry characters before. The most recent one being the vengeful Angel in episode 3. The last adventure the humans even deigned to go on, after tuning up their noses. So what does anger and intimidation look like? How best to express this?
All these framing angles and lighting changes that show up the moment he gets Serious.
He really, really wants them to understand that heβs not that goofy little showhost right now. Right? Heβs intimidating. That they canβt just emotionally kick him around anymore?
To avoid having to face all that pain again, that was first opened up in that therapy session glitch out.
But β¦β¦β¦. almost by happenstance, this backfires spectacularly.
Instead of achieving the intended goal- make them compliant and avoid getting hurt anymore- they finally puff up themselves. Now heβs the bear and theyβre the cat.
Only β¦β¦.. Zooble has done the Poke the Bear trope one too many times THIS time.