Hanna

I just think that the versions with all the trauma, suffering and history deserved a happy ending. I don’t think the take away should be that the only way to get a happy ending is for those things to have never happened to you.

The destruction of the entire universe and every soul in it is a truly depressing ending. Just because God replaced it with another universe that looked similar doesn't change anything - this is Job and his children all over again. Job doesn't want new children, and neither do I.

aziraphale saying that crowley was “the best angel” and listing out his angelic qualities irritates me to no end; it reaffirms crowley’s idea that aziraphale is endeared towards him because of his past rather than who he was as a being post-fall. which isn’t true — there’s been two whole fuckin seasons of aziraphale doting on crowley because of his enduring kindness and curiosity and minor-mischief-making as a demon. and what’s WORSE is that somehow we got more of a uncharacteristically positive reaction from crowley when aziraohale said as much than what we did when aziraphale confessed in front of GOD that crowley completed him

the entire point that kept coming up over and over again is that even though crowley and aziraphale are there on earth, they don't actually have to like, do anything. coz humans just do everything on their own. like neither heaven nor hell have really any influence on what happens. and the afterlife has never been portrayed as unfair. like the show has never been a critique of either godly meddling or of the sorting of souls into hell vs heaven. the entire world was just fine chugging along on its own and none of the angels or demons or prophecised apocalypses affected it at all. adam even made life slightly nicer if anything. so did jesus 2. what exactly was the reason why all 8 billion people in this world deserved to die. and in what universe would either crowley or aziraphale be okay with their entire world beind destroyed. let alone with each other dying.

and another thing… idk about you guys but my crowley and aziraphale are a demon and an angel, enemies to friends to situationship to almost-lovers, a 6,000 year slowburn. and they were fully shaped by the fact that they are supernatural beings, and by all their shared experiences, good and bad. that crowley and aziraphale have now semi-canonically been snapped out of existence, they have *never* even existed in this universe, they were basically book of lifed, the very punishment that was a threat in s2. and no weird ooc human au can ever be them because what they’ve been through and what they’ve learned is so much of who they are

Good Omens HQ : "Hey what if we put EVERY nightmares of the fandom in that finale ?"