I would like to rant a little bit about the subreddit r/powermetal. It is often a frustrating place due to the many people who dislike certain forms of power metal, and who'd rather bitch and gripe about bands they hate than hold up bands they actually like. The most bizarre thing, in my view, that it is often Gloryhammer fans who are utterly livid at the existence of "gimmicky", tongue-in-cheek power metal bands. They will argue that Gloryhammer, Alestorm and all other projects by their beloved Chris Bowes are different, but I just don't see it! Of course, the worst part is that Bowes himself has often been in these threads pushing these same ideas, making his stupid pet peeves everyone's fucking problems, always followed around by a bunch of sycophants who fall over each other to assure him that his shit doesn't smell. There is an outsized hatred toward the band Victorius. And the funny thing is that Gloryhammer fans cannot even decide if Victorius sucks because their embarassingly idiotic gimmick (laser-shooing dinosaurs) is so DUMB, or if they suck because they stole the genius idea (laser-shooting dinosaurs) from Gloryhammer. As someone old enough to have watched Dino Riders, I don't understand why people find the idea out there to begin with! I am not even a Victorius fan, but I did see them live a while ago. The venue was fairly packed, but it was also a venue with a capacity of under 200 people, so when Chris and his fans shit-talk them, it just feels wrong. It's literally a successful artist with two hit bands attacking a much smaller band ... because they are having fun wrong? To be fair, I have not seen Chris post quite this much recently, but seeing him be such an uncharitable, gatekeeping asshole has permanently soured me on Gloryhammer, I fear.
I think Gloryhammer is just aggressively tongue-in-cheek enough that they work for the kind of people who are really self-conscious about liking nerdy stuff. Power metal is nerdy. It is often fantasy-themed, essentially audio-fanfic at times, and with melody-driven songs and high vocal ranges, it's just not the rough gruff tough testosterony stuff that people tend to associate with heavy metal.
Fun anecdote time: My first power metal concert after the pandemic was in 2023. When I mentioned at work that I had been to a metal concert the previous night, one co-worker asked if there had been anything still going on in terms of Covid measures. I said, not really. He went on to say something like how yeah, that's what he figured, and wouldn't it be badass if one of these gruff, sweaty metal singers took an FFP2 mask, blew his nose in it and threw it into the crowd with a gutteral scream ...? And internally I was like: Ew, that's unhygienic. And also: Oh, he got the wrong idea entirely, didn't he. Because I went to a Twilight Force concert. So their two guitarists were actually wearing face covers. You know, as part of their elf costumes. And that's power metal!
I think I wasted a lot of my youth being self-conscious about the stuff I liked, for fear of being judged by jerks. It really sucks to see this anxiety on full display in a subreddit dedicated to this very, very niche music! The kind of people who can only unclench and enjoy this music if they have been thoroughly assured that the band knows how silly this is, that this is not real, that it's a joke. Anything that makes them uncertain about the intention, they complain that they "take themselves too seriously" or are "unintentionally funny", "cringe", waaah waah.
And then you go to see one of those bands that are "the worst thing to happen to power metal" according to Reddit, and you just ... have fun? surrounded by people who are having the time of their lives, getting definitive vibes that the band is having fun, too, and the positive vibes make me two years younger at least!
I dunno. Online fandom, especially Reddit fandom, is so often the worst version of fandom. Full of posers, of judgmental assholes, of people drawing lines and trying to be divisive and angry and dramatic and snooty. And then elsewhere people just chill and enjoy themselves.
















