I really don't mind that the christmas special is canceled, RTD is out of Doctor Who and the BBC are looking for a successor. The show has been suffocating under its own legacy for a long time, and each time there was a new Doctor and/or new showrunner, I hoped that the new season would be more accessible to newcomers, but it never ever was. I'm not a newcomer, but more of a casual/sporadic viewer, and every time I tried to get into the show properly, it bombarded me with callbacks and with storylines that just assumed everyone knew this or that character or idea, and no explanation was needed. It wasn't fun. Think Series 11: They made a point that there would be no returning characters or old monsters for Thirteen's first season. It sounded like a "fresh start" and my chance to finally get in. But Series 11 was fairly mediocre, and when Series 12 began, it immediately jumped into all the old lore - The Master! Gallifrey! Cybermen! Jack Harkness cameo! - and began a bizarre attempt to rewrite the origins of the Time Lords ... which was unpopular with old fans, but would also have been entirely meaningless for newcomers. I don't think that era had even mentioned Gallifrey before the scene where they expected the viewers to be shocked to hear of its destruction. So I gave up on the show and waited for the next showrunner, the next Doctor, hoping that this time would be a good entrypoint for newcomers. Well, those hopes were immediately dashed when RTD had the Doctor regenerate back into David Tennant, brought back Donna and used the opportunity to wrap up some loose ends from Series 4? And bring back old monsters and enemies, actors and just generally feed entirely off the nostalgia of an increasingly small, increasingly frustrated fanbase. I didn't actually watch any of this, but I was keeping half an eye on things to find out if the madness would stop. By the time the Doctor regenerated into Billie Piper as a cliffhanger, I had stopped caring.
I get the impression no one was really looking forward to the christmas special. I mean, no one was expecting to enjoy it. People talk about it like it's a chore, something to get out of the way before the show can move forward, a tedious obligation to resolve RTD's stuntcasting cliffhanger.
Now that there's been this radical decision to end this abysmal era of Who altogether, resolution be damned, I have this stupid hope again: Please just "reboot" the show. Ignore the cliffhanger, ignore the loose ends, just start the way New Who started in 2005: With a new Doctor, new characters, new adventures. Keep the lore minimal and make sure that everything plot-relevant is actually introduced and explained on screen. It's not like you can never include easter eggs or cameos, but the whole emotional arc of an episode shouldn't rely on the assumption that viewers have seen a specific decades-old piece of TV. Only bring back the Master, Gallifrey, Daleks and the like, if you actually have an idea for a story, not out of obligation. Only reintroduce bits of lore into the series if it's important for the story. Don't waste time with exposition to "fix" plotholes in past series, explain how the new Doctor fits intothe continuity, if the Timeless Child is still canon. I hate the modern obsession with lore, it's so angry and rigid and not very wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey. Honestly, just have the Doctor point out that what with several Time Lords constantly zipping about the universe in time machines making messes, their history is actually quite fluid and it's best not to bother trying to understand it. Embrace the chaos, the premise is perfect for this.
Really, just don't give the show to a hardcore fan who is itching to canonize his headcanon or return to a favourite storyline from the 1970's. Find someone who is excited about telling short, varied sci-fi stories!












