Should we say "sustainably sourced" instead of "ethical?"
Hereβs a conversation topic I see going around the oddities communities:Β
βWe donβt say βethicalβ anymore because ethics varies from person to person.Β
Just say βsustainably sourcedβ instead.βΒ
To me, this just trades one problem for another.Β
Imagine if I tried to sell you a skull, and you asked if the product was ethical.Β
Understandably, I might say βeveryoneβs ethics are different, so I canβt answer that with a βyesβ or βno.ββΒ
What I should say, IMO, is what I know about the skull as it relates to ethics: Did I kill it for the skull? Did I kill it for another reason? Did I pay someone to kill it for the skull or another reason, or did I or someone else find it dead already?Β
Now imagine if I shushed you, told you that thinking about ethics is dumb?! And I declared, βInstead, we say βblack-owned business!ββ
Now, imagine I had zero clue who the business owner was. Imagine I donβt know or care what the phrase βblack-owned businessβ means. But I thought the rule was βjust say stuff that sounds good,β and that sounds good, so I said it.Β
You should reasonably be annoyed that I haven't answered your question, and I could actually be misinforming you at the same time.
To say βjust say itβs sustainableβ means that the seller doesnβt have to know or care what that word even means. It's an opinion at best. Case in point:
This fur seller posted this statement:
[Image ID: Etsy (tagged) Real fur is natural, sustainable, biodegradable, eco friendly, and BIODIVERSE!]
How can a real fur product be biodiverse?Β
βBiodiversity is all the different kinds of life youβll find in one areaβthe variety of animals, plants, fungi, and even microorganisms like bacteria that make up our natural world.β
How can your product be biodiverse? Is thereβ¦a thriving, diverse ecosystem living on each coatβ¦?
Oh, I see what happened.Β
It looks like the seller of these products is just stacking words that sound good.Β None of these claims are proven or supported by unbiased evidence, by the way.
I don't really begrudge sellers for greenwashing since everyone in every industry does it, nor do I begrudge consumers for falling for it, since that's the point and no one has the time to deeply research everything they buy. However, if you're a little more conscious in the oddities/dead animal parts laws field, or you sell a lot and care about ethics and sustainability, I'd like to pose this issue: IMO, "sustainably sourced" means barely anything more than "ethical."