I never actually explained my MCD Player theory ever. The idea that MCD Aphmau has been constructed from both Irene and the Player, Jess. I never actually saw people see MCD like this, yet I've watched the entirety of MCD, Mod Mod World and Mystreet season 1 through 4 with this idea.
When you watch MCD for the first time, you're watching Jess play Minecraft through her character Aphmau. The more she plays the more "the world becomes aware", they mention it multiple times, right up to season 2. Does the world become aware or does Jess become immersed into the world enough to be able to hear everyone speak, and think, and not behave just like NPCs?
Throughout season 1, Jess is the main character, not Aphmau. She greets us, she says goodbye to us every episode. She's aware that this is all a game, but NPCs around her "wake up". And the more they wake up, the more we lose Jess, and we get Aphmau.
Look at Lady Irene for a moment. That woman is white. She's. white.
Irene is a white name, she is pale. Aphmau didn't tan, this is her natural skin color. Why was Irene reborn with a slightly different look? A whole change in ethnicity? OG Irene's skin color was never retconned by the way. The last time we see a glimpse of her in season 6, she's still white.
That's because Aphmau is not just Irene.
The exact moment we lost Jess was at the end of season 1, where Irene's relic enters Aphmau. Since then, we've never seen the facecam. Did Jess disappear? Or did she completely fuse into Aphmau?
I am serious, rewatch Diaries and tell yourself it's a meta plot because it is. MCD is in Minecraft. Mystreet is in Minecraft. Diaries Rebirth? Jess explicitely stated it's different from original MCD, it's not a rewrite, it's its own thing. It can't be a rewrite because the meta plot existed for a long time and it would be a shame to retcon it.
Or I'm just crazy and Jess was just making things up along the way and it wasn't something real