♬܀٭𝐺𝑒𝑒𝑘𝑦٭⊹♫

In both the alternate and main timeline, Blue trusts Pink to help them, even though their trust is misplaced. In the alternate timeline, Blue is fairly quick to help Pink and trust them, despite Pink being shown to be more loyal to pizza than to Blue. They’re also the first to bargain with Pink during the Season 1 finale despite Pink trying to kill them a few minutes ago.

When Blue hears Purple and Red‘s tragic backstory, their first question is about Pink, not their best friend. They’re also sweating here.

When they hear that Pink’s always been an imposter, they show a much bigger reaction than White - sweating again before getting lightheaded.

Conclusion?

They fucked.

Blue fucked Pink and is only just finding out that they fucked an imposter.

Evil evil Crewmates

Purple and their tiny ass joyfriend bruh