Gorillaz - Humanz - Album Review
(Warning: this is a very long one. Summary is at the bottom if you donāt want to read it all)
This is gonna be an interesting review for me, if for no one else. My reviews up to this point have been almost entirely about rock and metal music, reflecting my general listening habits. But I have also been a fan of Gorillaz for a few years now, even though Gorillaz is about as far from rock/metal as you can get. But I respect the originality and innovation on display in so much of their music, and I love the virtual band concept as well. Just for context, my favorite Gorillaz album is still Demon Days, with Plastic Beach as a close second. Both are great in their thematic focus that is shown throughout the album, with themes of politics and environmentalism on display on both albums. With this in mind, I was hoping for a similar level of thematic focus on Humanz, especially with interviews with Albarn stating essentially that many of the songs were written as a response to Ā being in a world where Trump is president (which at the time of the recording was only hypothetical). So for Humanz, I was expecting a focus on political and social themes with the level of tightness and eloquence of Demon Days.
I do have to say that Humanz is certainly not very focused musically or thematically though. However, this does not mean the album isnāt good, not by a longshot. Ā Itās hard to cover this album in broad strokes, and yet I donāt want to just dive headfirst into a track-by-track critique, so Iāll mention the few broad strokes about the album first.
So Humanz strengths lie in its infectious beats that are in nearly every song. Even the songs I like less have a great rhythm, in one way or another. Many of the guests are top notch as well, with my personal favorites being Peven Everett, Popcaan, Mavis Staples & Pusha T, Kali Uchis, and RagānāBone Man, Zebra Katz & RAY BLK.
However, the weaknesses of Humanz are much more apparent on a first listen, namely the overabundance of guests. There are hardly any songs where 2Dās (Albarnās) voice carries an entire song, the few instances being Busted and Blue (the only song with no features), and most other songs relegating him to a chorus at best, or even just a short bridge verse. Iām aware that Gorillaz have always collaborated with other artists, but it feels like they went a bit overboard on Humanz, causing the ever hard to define Gorillaz sound to be nearly non-existent, drowned out in a sea of other talented artists. And there are even some songs where I think certain guest artists actually decrease the overall quality of the song, which Iāll get into later.
The other major malady that I kept noticing throughout Humanz was the lack of any momentum building, or really any variation within individual songs. This makes me sad, because there are many songs that, if they had a bridge that added just a bit more energy, or a different rhythm, they would go from songs that are simply solid to really great songs. Iāll also point these songs out later.
While itās much easier to talk about the broad negatives of Humanz in comparison to the positives, Iāll say once more, this doesnāt mean I dislike the album. The songs are so varied that itās really difficult to discuss what I like about it in broad strokes, so from here, Iāll go into what songs I liked and why, as well as the ones that fall short and why they do.
Well, here we go, track by tracking a 26 song album (although Iām not gonna mention the Interludes. Theyāre there but they donāt really add anything, so itās really 19 songs).
The album starts off fairly strong with Ascension, featuring Vince Staples. Iām just gonna say here that I havenāt heard of him before, and the same can be said of almost all of the guests on Humanz for me. But his voice has a unique sound to it, and his flow and rhythm are really good. The only thing that holds this song back for me is that I donāt much care for the lyrics of the chorus. Itās overly repetitive and Iām not a fan of the main line being about dropping asses. However the verses are great to counterbalance it a bit.
Strobelite, featuring Peven Everett, was an immediate favorite for me. The beat is fun and funky, and had me bobbing my head on the first listen. Everettās soulful vocals are also just fantastic.
Saturnz Barz, featuring Popcaan, is another favorite song of mine, but it reached that point over time, with me not liking it very much at first. Popcaanās vocal style and rhythm are great, if a bit hard to understand at times. And 2Dās parts on the chorus and bridge are just amazing, bringing a down and somewhat eerie tone. This combined over the fantastic beat makes for one of the best songs on the album for sure.
Momentz, featuring De La Soul, was a song I was looking forward to, since theyāre also on Feel Good Inc., arguably Gorillaz most well-known song as well as my personal favorite. Unfortunately, Momentz falls short for me. Not bad, but one of the weaker songs on the album. Lyrically it doesnāt do very much at all, and its beat is okay at best. It also feels a bit disjointed, with the various parts of the song not really meshing or flowing together very well.
Submission, featuring Danny Brown and Kelela, is another great song that has just one bit Iām not huge on. Kelelaās voice is fantastic, and the lyrics are also great. Unfortunately, Iām not a big fan of Danny Brownās contribution to the track. Lyrically the bridge is good, but his voice is just, I donāt know, weird. It clashes a bit with Kelelaās beautiful voice on this track, and brings it down just a bit for me.
Charger, featuring Grace Jones, is pretty much the only song on the album that uses a guitar sound. It uses the same gritty riff throughout the whole song, so itās a good thing that itās an infectious riff. 2Dās vocals sound oddly loose here, almost like heās drunk or something, but thatās not a bad thing really, it works with the rest of the songās feel. Grace Jones contributions to the song arenāt huge, although her voice is great. A personal favorite that I could see other people not liking as much, and I would understand that.
Andromeda, featuring D.R.A.M, was another immediate favorite, and as such was a great choice for a single. A more dance-y track, something that wouldnāt be out of place playing in a club of some sort. The beat is simple yet infectious, getting you to bob your head and bounce your feet almost immediately. 2Dās vocals are great, and so are D.R.A.Mās. One of the best songs on the album.
Busted and Blue, being the only song on the album to have no features on it (despite having a section with a female vocalist, who is uncredited in the title. After some research it appears that it is Kelela), had a lot to live up to for me, in terms of the expectation of delivering a more classic Gorillaz sound. The song itself is a very quiet, subdued one, with minimal instrumentation and lyrics that seem to be about technology, but Iām not entirely sure what itās going for. I want to love this song, but I canāt really. I like it, but it exemplifies the problem I stated earlier about songs feeling like they never really go anywhere, it sort of just wanders aimlessly until it ends.
Carnival, featuring Anthony Hamilton, is a track that, if it were a minute longer, would be amazing, but itās still great at its 2 minute runtime. Hamiltonās great voice combined with the darker sounding, drum-heavy beat create an imposing and eerie atmosphere that I really like. Itās unfortunate that the song feels like it ends just a bit too soon.
Let Me Out, featuring Pusha T and Mavis Staples, was another immediate favorite for me. Pusha Tās rhythm and flow are fantastic in the verses, as are the lyrics. Mavis Staples voice on the chorus is amazing, and the politically charged lyrics throughout the song are great as well.
Sex Murder Party, featuring Jamie Principle & Zebra Katz, is another song that I wish I liked more than I did, but it falls just short. The drumming beat throughout the song is great, and 2Dās voice on the chorus is fantastic. However, I donāt quite get what the lyrics are really going for here, and that holds it back a bit for me.
Sheās My Collar, featuring Kali Uchis, is fantastic. An immediate standout on first listen, and a song that I like more than most of the singles. Itās beat is fantastic, and 2D takes center stage on the song, with Kali Uchis only coming in for the bridge and final chorus. Uchisā voice is great, and the lyrics for the song are good as well.
Hallelujah Money, featuring Benjamin Clementine, is an interesting experiment if nothing else. It doesnāt do much for me musically. Clementineās voice is interesting, but the rhythm of the song feels off, almost spoken word but not quite. The implicitly political lyrics are good, but this isnāt really a song that I come back to.
We Got the Power, featuring Jehnny Beth, is great. It stands in stark contrast to most of the darker toned songs on the album, providing a pop-tinged message of power through unity. Iāve seen many people say they donāt like the song because of that, but I love it because of that. After most of the album has been darker or political, itās a good change of pace just before the regular album ends.
Now this is where the regular album ends, but the deluxe version includes 6 (really 5, with another interlude) more songs. So letās get to them.
The Apprentice, featuring RagānāBone Man, Zebra Katz, and RAY BLK, is awesome. One of my favorites for sure. I can see why it was relegated to the deluxe album, because as great as it is I can see that it doesnāt exactly flow with the other songs on the album. The song itself has an amazing beat, and all of the artists on this song have incredible voices that bring a soulful sound to the song. The only negative I have is the bridge, and not because its bad, not by a longshot, but I feel it clashes with the verses and chorus a bit. The bridge is explicitly political in its lyrics, and the verses and chorus are less so, if at all. Overall though, another favorite track.
Halfway to the Halfway House, once again featuring Peven Everett, has a great beat and Everett appears once again with his great voice. However, I may just be missing something, but I donāt quite understand the lyrics of this one (like why is āCherryage fountainā repeated again and again?). Not a bad song, but one that I wouldnāt call great.
Out of Body, featuring Kilo Kish, Zebra Katz, and Imani Vonsha, is a strange song. Kishās voice is... odd, and Iām not really sure how to describe it at all. Itās not bad, as once the song gets going, her rhythm and flow are great. But the song itself just doesnāt do much for me outside of great vocal rhythm.
Ticker Tape, featuring Carly Simon & Kali Uchis, is a slower affair, but a solid one for sure. 2Dās voice is great, as are Carly Simonās & Kali Uchisā. The lyrics are great as well. I feel like this song is closer to what Busted and Blue couldāve been.
Finally, the album closes with Circle of Friendz, featuring Brandon Markell Holmes, is odd. The vocals from Holmes are fantastic, but the song consists of very few unique lines, and musically, it doesnāt really go anywhere. It kind of works as a thematic close to the album, but doesnāt really stand on its own very well.
And there you have it. All of my thoughts on Humanz. The album is far from perfect, but itās pretty darn good. Itās certainly not better than Demon Days, and just barely edges out Plastic Beach for me. Itās an album that is well worth your time. Whether youāve been a fan of Gorillaz or not, there is probably something on this album that you can enjoy.
(Also I canāt wait to see Gorillaz live in October, if nothing else I have Humanz to thank for allowing me to actually do that.)