At the age of seventeen, in a Catholic high school, it was not difficult for me to fall in love, or at least infatuation, with the young women that graced the halls in plaid skirts. When a particular one from Australia sat near me in Religion(guess which one?) class, then read out loud, I didn't stand a chance. It wasn't just her accent, it was the way she stood and spoke, both proud and terrified at her voice filling a room of thirty unknown faces.
We were both pale with black hair, but the physical opposites that truly attracted me (besides the typical areas you'd expect a teenage boy to notice) were her luminous blue eyes. Strands of hair were continually falling across the right one, which she would let build to an opaque sheet before lifting or shaking it away.
We actually did end up in a relationship, sparked in typical awkward teenage fashion in the darkened cafeteria of a school dance. From there, things got strange. Her insanely protective younger brother tried his hardest to injure my brain with a thoroughly padded volleyball during gym class.
Our dates consisted exclusively of seeing movies, which her parents dropped her off at and picked her up from, expecting me to do many evil things in the five minutes between her house and the theater. She also signed her texts "love, her name, xoxoxo" which terrified me initially. I did realize it was how all her texts to everyone ended, unless she was mad at me, which occurred frequently.Ā
But on to why I'm traipsing down a memory lane fraught with embarrassment. I was talking to a friend in the library, going on and on about how beautiful I found my girlfriend to be. Then this happens:
'You know her eyes are fake, right?'
'She wears color contacts.'
This friend of mine, by the way, had beautiful eyes of her own, arresting and distinct, somehow blue and steel at once. So I believe she shared my feeling that color contacts were not just cosmetic, but cheating, a lie, really. Fake.
After our breakup, which really constituted about half the relationship, I returned to this idea. I had asked her about the contacts and she told me she didn't like her natural eye color. I told her I would like it. It was brown, like mine.
Besides the obvious issue of depriving a high school senior of the chance to put Brown-eyed Girl on a mix for his girlfriend, I took these contacts as a metaphor indicative of our entire relationship. There was always a cool blue film between us. We tried to show only our best-manufactured sides, leaving us playing as inept actors cast for too-large roles, worse than Tim Allen in The Santa Clause 3 (yes, we actually saw this together. Like I said, infatuated).
But now I'm not sure how to evaluate the things we add to ourselves. Everyone tries to project an idealized self, at least to the extent their budgets allow it. After listening to a couple friends/acquaintances comment on every outfit that passed, I told one:
'you care too much about things'
which she disputed. I continued, saying they were judging people based on how skinny their pants were. The person I knew least well responded:
'well you have to judge people on something.'
"Asshole" is the word that flew to my mind, 'Seriously??' from my lips. This interaction, and many like it, have made me to be wary of hipsters, which this fellow unapologetically was. It's not the appearance that troubles me- I'll admit I'm more drawn to plaid or vintage than pastels and patterned pants.Ā
It's the pride, it's the substitution of objects for personality. And yet, I must admit that I play along, I judge these people attempting to be awesome by dressing in a uniform alt way, much as I took color contacts to be revealing of a dishonest person.
I cannot deny that the things we adorn ourselves with have the potential to say something about us and mean something to others. Especially as a person with tattoos. I just generally care more about where those legs inside the skinny jeans have been and are going, how the eye beneath the lens appreciates each moment.
But can we ignore appearances, or are they inextricably tied to our ideas of self and Other?
Well, I still tell people I've never dated anyone with brown eyes. It doesn't feel like a lie.