Leta❦

Drew Starkey x Reader (Y/N)

🖤 : Angst → Fluff

📎 Summary: You’ve been Drew’s best friend — and something more — for years. But when Odessa A’zion enters the picture, you start to question everything. Until Drew makes a choice. And he chooses you.

⸻

You weren’t one to eavesdrop. But it was hard not to when everyone in the room was talking about Drew and Odessa.

“Did you see the way she looked at him during the shoot?”

“I heard they went to dinner alone last night.”

“Honestly, they’d be cute together.”

Cute. Perfect. Hollywood’s new favorite pairing. Odessa A’zion and Drew Starkey.

You sat in the corner of the trailer, fidgeting with the bracelet Drew had gotten you last fall. The one he said “looked like you — quiet but meaningful.” Whatever that meant. It used to make you smile.

Now, it just felt like a reminder of how replaceable you were.

Drew walked in moments later, his laugh echoing down the hallway before he even turned the corner. Odessa was right behind him, shoulder bumping into his in that flirtatious, casual way. She was beautiful. Golden. Effortless.

You looked away before either of them could see your expression. But Drew saw you. He always did.

“Hey,” he said, stepping toward you. “Been looking for you all day.”

You forced a smile. “Didn’t know you noticed I was gone.”

He frowned, cocking his head. “Y/N, what’s up?”

“Nothing,” you said too quickly. “You seem busy. Odessa’s funny, huh?”

Drew blinked. “What?”

“She’s cool. Pretty. And clearly into you.”

The words slipped out sharper than you meant. Your throat tightened. You didn’t want to cry. Not here. Not in front of him.

“Y/N…” he started, his tone softening, but you stood up.

“I get it. You’re Drew Starkey. You can have whoever you want. You don’t need to explain.”

“You think I want her?” he asked, stepping into your space.

You met his gaze. “Don’t you?”

There was a pause — heavy, loaded, thick with silence.

“I want you,” he said finally. “I’ve always wanted you.”

You blinked, confused, heart skipping painfully.

“But you’ve been with her—”

“I haven’t been with anyone,” he cut in, frustration flickering in his eyes. “You saw us talk and you assumed the worst. But the whole time I was thinking about you. Wishing it was you next to me. Wishing you knew.”

“Then why didn’t you say something?”

“I thought I didn’t have to,” he said. “I thought you already knew how I felt.”

The emotion in his voice cracked something inside you.

You stepped closer, voice barely above a whisper. “I was scared.”

“So was I,” he said. “But not anymore.”

His hand found yours. Warm. Certain.

“You’re it for me, Y/N.”

You let out a breath you didn’t realize you were holding, leaning into him.

“Don’t ever make me doubt it again,” you whispered.

“I won’t,” he promised, pressing his forehead to yours.

And when he kissed you — slow, aching, real — all the noise, all the doubts, all the fear melted away.

It had always been you.

⸻

I tried lol. I Hope you enjoy it:) if not I can easily re-write it. I used the show I’m watching rn cause I didn’t know who to use lol 🤍 ps. I didn’t add the vlogsquad cause I genuinely didn’t know how to add them to the story :(

>>>>>>

   Your favorite moments with David usually consisted of lazy days at the house begging him to rewatch your favorite movies or tv shows. Today in particular you had a need, no an urge to rewatch the best tv show ever, to your dismay of course which happened to be Teen Wolf. You have been bugging David all day to sit with you and binge watch at least the first season with you .

Although David wasn’t big on supernatural tv shows he still gave in, knowing it would make you happy and oh how he loved seeing that big smile and jump of excitement you would do when he caved in to your antics.

 You had just finished setting up everything in the living room from popcorn to all of yours and his favorite drinks and snacks . As you pressed play, you lay yourself in between David legs with your back against his chest with a blanket wrapped around you both. Ten minutes in, Stiles (Dylan O’Brien) appears on screen and you can't help but gawk over your celebrity crush.

The words “ Ugh Dylan is so sexy I can’t”, “Omg meeting Dylan would be such a dream” spewed out of your mouth, you feel David tense up behind you. As the episode finishes David gets up saying he doesn’t want to watch anymore. With your eyebrows furrowed you question why?   

 David remains silent and you remembered what you had just said, with a smirk on your face you ask “are you jealous that I find Dylan O’Brien attractive?” David just sits back on his phone ignoring you. Shocked his does so, you decide to mess around with him.

You continue watching the show on your own now still making side comments on how you want Dylan for yourself. From the corner of the room you hear “psh he’s not better than me though” feeling bad you get up and sit on David’s lap making him look at you.

You smile at him and start to giggle giving him a quick peck on the lips. “ I love it when you’re jealous”

“I’m not jealous”

“ oh really so you don’t mind hearing how much I love Dylan O’Brien and how-“

“ok, ok I am jealous, but only because Sometimes I can’t believe you chose me, someone as amazing as you deserves someone like Dylan”

“ you’re right”

“Wait what?”

“I said you’re right”

“Oh..”

“I do deserve better, but you are better, you are way more than I deserve and that’s why I love you”

This is my first fan fiction and it may be too long lol idk what i’m doing... so whoever reads this feel free to give me feedback on what I can do better in and maybe send in some request idk lol I will try my best to capture ya’ll ideas just the way ya’ll want lol.. I hope y'all enjoy. 🥺 btw there might be some typos.

>>>

You and David have always  been super close, ever since first meeting back when you first arrived in L.A. a little over a year ago. Unbeknownst to you, he would become the person you rely on the most. You first started to notice your growing feelings for David on the night of  Zane’s birthday where you had one too many. He had dropped everyone off at their disengaged houses but took you back to his to take care of you. He would wake up at 6am hearing your hangover hit you, where he quickly rushed over to the bathroom and held your hair while you were hunched over the toilet. He did everything  possible  to make you feel better although while also laughing of how drunk you had gotten the night prior. Though you just believed those kind gestures where him being friendly. What you didn't know was that David felt the same way, but you were soon to find out.

David had realized his feelings for you when he noticed how much you cared for others. You were always making sure everyone else was feeling okay or willing to do anything for him and his friends. You had no ounce of evil in you. David’s feelings grew stronger ever time he was with you. He loved how when sitting next to you, you would mindlessly cuddle up next to him and run your nails up and down his arm. Or when he would have a long night of editing you would be the only one willing to stay up with him even if you both just sat on the cloud couch in silence, but to him it didn’t matter cause he enjoyed your presence.

Knowing your birthday was coming up David spent every second of his day with the help of Natalie of course trying to figure out the perfect plan. So when David had shot you a text “make sure not the make plans on your birthday I’m taking you out” You couldn’t help but feel butterflies erupt inside of your stomach thinking of spending your day with him, but cooling yourself down thinking he would never like you cause to him you were just a friend.

As your birthday approached you wore a casual red dress with cute sandals as David told you, you guys will be dinning outside. You get a text “ I’m outside” and you immediately spray on perfume and make your way outside. 

Walking up to the beautiful white Tesla stood David in his normal black attire and red roses, Looking down at you, you couldn’t help but blush as he leaned in to give you a hug and whispering the words in your ear “happy birthday y/n.” He opens the passenger door for you, but you couldn’t help but notice he looked nervous. While driving, you ask him “where are we going”  to which he replies “It’s a surprise, but I promise you that you are going to love it, I spent weeks planning.” 

Surprised that he cared so much about your birthday you couldn't help but feel those butterflies again. You assumed you were nearing closer to your destination when you heard those infamous words.

“I’m going to need to blindfold you” not thinking he was serious you busted out laughing until you looked over and saw that he was indeed very serious. “You’re not going to leave me on the side of the road right” hearing his famous laugh that you have learned to love he continued with  “no you weirdo, I just want to make it extra special.”

As he puts the blind fold on he parks the car and open your door. As you guys are walking he tells you to take off your shoes and you do so by using him as a balance. Next thing you know your feet touch to what feels like sand to you.

“okay I’m taking the blindfold off now”, As he takes it off your breath gets caught in your throat. You couldn’t believe he did all this for you. You were know looking at a candle light beach dinner with the moon illuminated above you. When you turned around to look at him, he's at already looking at you. leading you towards your chair  “I can't believe you did this” “I’ll do anything for you y/n” 

As you guys finish dinner, he leads you towards a blanket on the sand floor  laying down besides each other looking up at the stars. “You know I've been planning this for weeks, I wanted everything to be perfect just for you.”

Turning your head to look at him you guys just stare into each others eyes until he leans in and kisses you with so much love just as you do the same. You pull away first to catch your breath, but you see him smiling like there’s no tomorrow. “I’ve been wanting to do that ever since I first laid eyes on you y/n, you have have no idea how much I like you, I literally can't go a day with out thinking about you. I want to be with you y/n.”  

You lean in to kiss him again but pull away with a smile on your lips , “I want to be with you to David, not a day goes by where I don’t want to be with you.”