My name is Paul (he/him). I'm a duck on the internet. Welcome to my blog!
I mostly post about Sonic here on Tumblr (for now). You can find more fandoms and other socials at chaoticducc.carrd.co.
My ask box is open!
Fandoms/Interests
🦔 Sonic the Hedgehog - #sth
🛰️ Project Hail Mary - #phm
I'm also really into Cities: Skylines, Satisfactory and computers/tech though I don't post about that on Tumblr. My Reddit is home for that.
Other Tags
🗨️ Rambling - #duck thoughts
✏️ Stuff I made - #duck creations
Ships are tagged. Reblogs do not get their own tag.
More info below the cut.
Tag Formatting
<comment> <duck> <fandom/communities> <ships>
comment: something I have to say. Could be empty or there could be multiple.
duck: might be #duck thoughts or #duck creations. Could also be empty if neither apply, like for reblogs.
fandom/communities: what communities/fandoms the post belongs to. Could be something like #sth, but could also be #artists on tumblr. Could also be empty.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Read through your Sonic Chronic AU today after seeing a few updates reblogged on my timeline and I absolutely love it!
I love me some good angst, and this has got all the elements: broken hero, lost identity, lost morals, addiction, running out of time, self-sacrifice, self-destruction.
Intentionally or not, I feel like you've created an allegory for an addiction to pain meds, the emeralds being the meds and that "pull" being the addiction, because it feels unstoppable and inevitable that the emeralds/meds will come back. Sonic doesn't want to fight his addiction, because they make the pain go away or at least he feels that way, until their effect stops and he crashes harder than ever before.
The way you write Sonic feels so on point for someone who's experiencing constant pain and going through withdrawal (I don't speak from personal experience, which is why I can't confirm).
I’ve seen a couple different interpretations of what the Emeralds could be, and I love reading through them every time. Seeing people make connections and interpret symbolism has been really cool, it’s one of my favourite parts of posting this au. I’m glad you like it, thank you!
ive caught myself speaking in 3s like rocky (good good good, etc) irl multiple times and often and idk if thats something i already do but didnt pay attention to until now or if rocky is actually rubbing his nasty carapace off on me
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
what do you get when you put an aroace hedgehog who's chill with physical contact and a bat who's extremely comfortable with most forms of physical affection in same friend group as a touch starved echidna not used to PDA? Whatever this is, that's what.
Doodled this cause i was just thinking about Sonic and Rouge's dynamic. No they’re not dating. No they don’t like each other romantically. Did they even actually kiss? Honestly probably not, it could've just be the angle. But they're the most physically comfortable with each other out of the group simply because they both know there won't be any crushes or anything happening between them, so it's safe to just be affectionate. They usually stick to cheek kisses but they wanted to troll on Knuckles a bit.
Knuckles is having a moment. Over what? You pick <3
1. I was thinking about an aroace Sonic who says things that can be taken as wildly flirty/romantic but he just means them genuinely. “You have beautiful eyes, I keep getting distracted while looking at them,” not cause he’s interested romantically in them but because eyes can be really cool and pretty man I dunno what to tell you he likes looking at cool things and he thinks his friends are neat. “You’re the most beautiful person here,” because he really thinks that, he loves his friends
2. Sonic randomly dropping heartfelt genuine comments on his friends out of the blue completely blindsiding them and then moves on like nothing happened while they’re left going ?????? Bonus points if he does something immensely stupid or jerkish just before or immediately afterwards and they can’t tell if he was serious or not with the compliment (yes he was)
3. Sonic usually being so allergic to truly vulnerable moments that when he expresses something heartfelt randomly Tails thinks he’s been stabbed or something and does not believe him when he reassures him that he’s fine he’s fine he’s not dying yeesh
The adverse effects of sleep-deprivation include: a weakened immune system, disrupted hormones, impaired logic and thinking, increased risk of: illness, depression, anxiety, forgetfulness, high blood pressure, heart disease, some cancers, type 2 diabetes, etc.
Tails has abandonment issues
Watching someone close to you that you care about be in pain and intentionally hurt/neglect themselves takes a toll, whether you want it to or not. Thats the inevitability of caring. Tails has had a front row seat to Sonic’s physical and mental disintegration since his first seizure. He’s been doing everything he can to do things right in this situation (after much trial and error), to give Sonic space to grieve and keep living while also behaving in a way that ensures Sonic allows him to keep looking after him. The easiest way for Tails to cope is to just throw himself into projects, so that’s what he’s been doing. Instead of sleeping, he works on improving Inhibitors for Sonic and researching possible ways to reverse the negative effects of the chaos overexposure to drown on any anxiety he feels. If anything happens, Tails is there with an invention and instructions for his friends, but he can’t keep that up forever. He hasn’t reached his breaking point yet, but it’s easy for Ivo to see where he’s headed because—
they watched Sonic do this already. And yes, in case you’re wondering, if Tails continues on like this he will damage himself, chronically, like Sonic did. Just add this to the list of ways Sonic and Tails are alike.
Ivo is DoneTM. He didn’t humor Sonic’s nonsense and he’s not gonna humor Tails. He’s got that weird sort of ‘does he care or doesn’t he?’ thing going, but he’s more than comfortable being the bad guy regardless.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
1. Metal definitely isn’t supposed to be pulling up to Tails place but hey when u gaining a lil sentience you tend to not abide by the deals your creator/dad made with someone else
2. Options for what Metal is thinking that a) giving sonic an emerald will mean he’s back to full power and then he can fight him and go back to proving he’s the real sonic or lose and know for sure if he’s not. b) Sonic is the real Sonic and the world needs Sonic so he better get him back up and moving right the heck now because how dare he give up being the only thing Metal’s ever wanted to be. Which one is it? We may never know!
3. If you think they look a little too horrified all I gotta say is hey if your friend started giving the doppleganger designed by his enemy to kill him his name as a way of giving up on his own identity and inviting himself to be replaced you’d be horrified too
Finally managed to find time to read chapter 9 and I have to, once again, say that I absolutely adored this chapter. Admittedly Knuxouge isn't really my thing, but for what it's worth I really enjoyed reading their banter and learning more about their relationship.
Something I've noticed in this chapter and in previous chapters is just how long you manage to make parts where you talk about the characters feelings, thoughts and relationships without repeating yourself. To me that implies a deep understanding of the characters and their relationships. I was wondering just how you do that? How much planning goes into a chapter like this?
(oh and a follow up from my last ask where I said that it felt like chapter 8 lost steam toward the end, I don't feel that for chapter 9)
(Youre good man, DW. I didn't even notice tbf until you corrected it xD)
I'm so glad you enjoyed Chapter 8 and the Knuxouge stuff despite it not being for you, that makes me super happy. Also really pleased that you didn't feel it lost steam, I really did try to tie things up neatly with this chapter, but the fact that it stood alone as it's own thing kinda leant towards that a bit more. It was definitely a challenge though, cuz it was more like writing a clean short story rather than the typical chapter with a more open ending.
That's a really interesting question btw and I'm gonna do my best to answer it because I think half the stuff you're asking about isn't always a super conscious decision for me, so I'll try to be more analytical about my process. But thank you! I do try to get really into details with their characters and relationships (this is a drama afterall, so thats important) And i think thats where all this stems from is wanting to really portray exactly who these guys are and the depths of their relationships and why thats important.
(Actual answer below but I realised it was very long so if I were to give a TL;DR; I write out the scene, then I dive into the character's actions and dialogue within the scene, and explain why it reflects their character and relationships to each other, using themes and symbols to emphasise :') tho sometimes the reflection comes first and I write the actions around that too! Most of the time its not that linear, sometimes it flows out and i switch between, sometimes i go back and add things, either dialogue/actions or emotional reflections/description.)
---
I'm kind of a waffler anyway, its pretty obvious at this point that i like to info dump, and im sure thats not for everyone but people seem to like it. I actively try to tone it down and fine-tune it as best as I can, but I just really like getting deep into things.
So in general, there are themes that I want to cover, headcanons I want to share, emotional details I want to explain, and there's a lot of subtext underneath every scene and because I'm trying to give you my versions/headcanons of these characters, I'm trying to explain and show that subtext so that they feel believable.
The biggest thing I'm thinking about when I'm writing a relationship (romantic, platonic, familiar, whatever) Is what they mean to each other, what do they represent to each other? And in order to understand what they mean to each other, I gotta think about what they lack as individuals (or maybe not LACK, but what are they missing/need that the other person fulfils in their life just from what that person has in their personality or character), and then I go deeper into why that matters.
I also like to work a lot with themes and symbols and metaphor. There are concrete themes in TDWM that are kind of the groundwork for everything else, and to express how important these characters are to each other, i like to go into what they symbolise to each other.
And because no-one ever does anything on accident (we all make decisions based on our character), I'm looking at why a character says or does something and then I explain it.
Once I've sneezed it all out onto the document, I go back and refine from it sounding like waffle to it having some kind of flow xD
---
So with the Rouge and Knuckles chapter for example; There is a lot of 'telling' initially, because I wanted to give context throughout the showing, so that when we get to the flashback scenes you have all the information you need to fill in the blanks and understand why every decision they've made has brought them to this present relationship. At least that was my intention, but I still have a habit of waffling too hard sometimes.
In a way, i kind of treat it like 'doing the math' lol
So for them, the thought process goes like this (and a lot of this is headcanon building on headcanon based on what I take from the media) :
What does Knuckles represent to Rouge? -> Home, security, comfort, stability, predictability. -> Why? Because he was raised to care about tradition, because he knows the importance of commitment and duty (why? because he's spent the first part of his life guarding an important artefact without question or applause) -> Why does this matter to Rouge? Because 1 we know she respects competence (based on how she acts and who she associates herself with and the self-respect she has for her own capabilities) and Because 2 Rouge lacks that stable predictability in her own life (why? because shes a government spy/treasure hunter who is all over the place fulfilling her job and goals.)
So then how is this shown in the chapter -> Rouge comes home from work and Knuckles is already making dinner, making her tea, taking care of her, doing domestic things like reinforcing pre-established predictable house rules. How does Rouge respond to this? Throughout the chapter she visibly relaxes, she banters back about house rules because she's aware of their established routine, she physically disrobes to get comfortable, she cuddles him and rests against him for support, she falls asleep in the bedroom knowing that she's safe and loved and is being taken care of.
Then what are the symbols? -> Mountain's being unshakable, flying creatures are in constant motion and without the ground they'll keep falling, birds needing somewhere to perch etc, the dragonfly finding a tulip to settle on, the bee wearing the pollen of a flower so it can return to it, lighthouse on an island for ships in a storm.
For Knuckles, his symbolism is more obvious because he's consistently comparing her to an angel even in his own words, (and I like that it contrasts with how Rouge has seen herself and has been seen in the past, even by him.)
So do it again. What does Rouge represent to Knuckles -> hope, freedom, liberation, his bridge from isolation, someone who descended into his lonely world. Why? Because Rouge lives by her own rules (why? because she can physically go anywhere in the open air as a flying creature, shows up to him uninvited and leaves on her own terms. She completes government missons and treasure hunts all around the world) -> Why does this matter to Knuckles? Because he spent his life being tethered to one spot and bound by duty (and completely alone with limited access to his friends).
How is this shown in the chapter? -> She makes it possible for him to live away from the Emerald and build his own life (because she handles the modern world for them). She offers to reach out to his friends for him because he can't do it alone. She gives active solutions to the Sonic situation because Knuckles struggles to reach out. (why? because he's been conditioned to accept isolation.) He waits for her on Angel Island because he learns from her company that he's actually very lonely, and her presence makes him feel less trapped in his duty. All of this is forms of liberation.
What are the symbols? -> There's physical angelic symbolism in the way she's floating and descending to him to hug him while she's helping to untangle his concerns. The freedom of flying and jealousy over it- In some ways I put in tradition/religion being oppressive, and the bitterness that can come from seeing someone live freely in a way that feels inaccessible under strict order. Burrowing animals being led into the light. Being crushed by tombs. Being trapped under the earth. Just liberation imagery.
And because this is a healthy relationship, I like to mention how they notice the cues of each other, and actively fulfil those needs. Like Rouge noticing that Knuckles might need her to text Cream for him -> thats her understanding her partner on a deep level. Knuckles realising that he spoke a little to harsh about shadow and later being nice about it -> that's him understanding Rouge and tending to her emotionally.
And I'm trying to work all of that in together, between context/subtext, actions and dialogue in the scene, and symbolism. And sometimes that comes from writing out the scene first and then thinking 'ah, this action happened because this character is feeling this way' so then I explain that. OR its the other way around where I want to write about why they matter to each other, and then i think 'i can show this by having them do/say this in the scene'. And i just figure out where that works.
So for example, the moment with them bantering about each other having an attitude, I think 'thats a good place to dive into their banter, and then their personalities, and the fact that Rouge likes a guy who is willing to play with her, but how she also likes a man she can fluster- so then I explain how knuckles is that perfect middle ground- and zing, theres the attraction! But not just that, here is how their compatibility works on a deeper level too...' And that all came from them arguing over a wash basket lol,
because the wash basket moment shows a bit of everything- from their chemistry to their domestic routine, which easily leads into me explaining what they want when it comes to engaging with a partner (why they're attracted to each other beyond aesthetically) and why their values align on a deeper level (shared competence + stability and predictability vs freedom to build a life)
---
NOW FOR SHADOW AND SONIC it works the same way.
So if we look at the scene from Chapter 2 where Sonic and Shadow are having their conversation at the table, theres also a lot going on that im trying to show, because why is Sonic even in that situation in the first place and WHY is his relationship with Shadow so important? I do the math.
Shadow represents a feeling of safety that no-one else can give Sonic -> Why? Because Sonic is the worlds hero and Shadow is his rival -> why does that matter? Because that means only Shadow can match him, and that means that if Sonic were to fail then at least someone could catch him and finish the job = Sonic feels less pressure on him when Shadow is around, he's allowed to be vulnerable because vulnerability no longer means that people die (because someone else can do his job too). -> So what happens when that's gone? It means that Sonic, without that invisible safety net, is unable to be vulnerable when things go wrong. -> And what are the consequences of that? When things go wrong (like a divorce) he can't reach out to his friends, he can't admit he's struggling, he cries on his own, be berates himself for struggling and he constantly feels alone. And when he finds himself homeless and struggling with money, he can't ask for help -> Until Shadow comes back.
I've sort of explained that by working backwards there, but if it was reversed and i asked first 'why is sonic in this position' instead, doing the math the other way still makes sense to me how things transpired by Shadow disappearing, and why he was so desperate to see Shadow and stay with him when he came back.
I do the exact thought process with how his relationship with amy fell apart, and how I write Shadows internal thoughts with the 'maria voice'.
Usually when there's an emotional/character/relationship point I want to make, I'll write a list out for that beat (exactly how I've just shown you here, but less detailed), or I'll put in a note while I'm writing just to be like 'mention Shadow in conversation here- then explain Knuckles' history with him, initial relationship jealous but shadow mega gay lol, then why hes pissed that he left rouge on her own for a decade.'
This was a long response but I wanted to go into detail and I hope that helps, I've never thought about it in concrete terms before haha xD
I was not ready for a wall of text, but I absolutely love it! It really seems like you put a lot of thought into this story and the characters.
You've said before that this is your first fanfic, but I can't help but wonder if you've done this before? Like if you've written fiction before, because it just seems so well thought out and practiced for a first attempt.
This is my first proper published fic. I've experimented with writing prose for myself a couple times, I've planned out personal project stories, and I've done script writing but my main writing experience I'd say is from RPing. I developed a lot of my writing from the many years of doing that (and in a lot of that RPing I was 'doing the math' with characters too as I was feeling them out, so the same style applies) , but when it comes to actually planning and writing a fanfic to be made public, this is the first time I've even done that. This is the first time I've written something that wasn't kept to myself or between me and another writer. I've really been enjoying it though and the response to his was more than I ever expected! Plus its been some great experience into more story planning, which is good if I want to make something longer and completely original down the line, which I definitely plan to hopefully!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Finally managed to find time to read chapter 9 and I have to, once again, say that I absolutely adored this chapter. Admittedly Knuxouge isn't really my thing, but for what it's worth I really enjoyed reading their banter and learning more about their relationship.
Something I've noticed in this chapter and in previous chapters is just how long you manage to make parts where you talk about the characters feelings, thoughts and relationships without repeating yourself. To me that implies a deep understanding of the characters and their relationships. I was wondering just how you do that? How much planning goes into a chapter like this?
(oh and a follow up from my last ask where I said that it felt like chapter 8 lost steam toward the end, I don't feel that for chapter 9)
(Youre good man, DW. I didn't even notice tbf until you corrected it xD)
I'm so glad you enjoyed Chapter 8 and the Knuxouge stuff despite it not being for you, that makes me super happy. Also really pleased that you didn't feel it lost steam, I really did try to tie things up neatly with this chapter, but the fact that it stood alone as it's own thing kinda leant towards that a bit more. It was definitely a challenge though, cuz it was more like writing a clean short story rather than the typical chapter with a more open ending.
That's a really interesting question btw and I'm gonna do my best to answer it because I think half the stuff you're asking about isn't always a super conscious decision for me, so I'll try to be more analytical about my process. But thank you! I do try to get really into details with their characters and relationships (this is a drama afterall, so thats important) And i think thats where all this stems from is wanting to really portray exactly who these guys are and the depths of their relationships and why thats important.
(Actual answer below but I realised it was very long so if I were to give a TL;DR; I write out the scene, then I dive into the character's actions and dialogue within the scene, and explain why it reflects their character and relationships to each other, using themes and symbols to emphasise :') tho sometimes the reflection comes first and I write the actions around that too! Most of the time its not that linear, sometimes it flows out and i switch between, sometimes i go back and add things, either dialogue/actions or emotional reflections/description.)
---
I'm kind of a waffler anyway, its pretty obvious at this point that i like to info dump, and im sure thats not for everyone but people seem to like it. I actively try to tone it down and fine-tune it as best as I can, but I just really like getting deep into things.
So in general, there are themes that I want to cover, headcanons I want to share, emotional details I want to explain, and there's a lot of subtext underneath every scene and because I'm trying to give you my versions/headcanons of these characters, I'm trying to explain and show that subtext so that they feel believable.
The biggest thing I'm thinking about when I'm writing a relationship (romantic, platonic, familiar, whatever) Is what they mean to each other, what do they represent to each other? And in order to understand what they mean to each other, I gotta think about what they lack as individuals (or maybe not LACK, but what are they missing/need that the other person fulfils in their life just from what that person has in their personality or character), and then I go deeper into why that matters.
I also like to work a lot with themes and symbols and metaphor. There are concrete themes in TDWM that are kind of the groundwork for everything else, and to express how important these characters are to each other, i like to go into what they symbolise to each other.
And because no-one ever does anything on accident (we all make decisions based on our character), I'm looking at why a character says or does something and then I explain it.
Once I've sneezed it all out onto the document, I go back and refine from it sounding like waffle to it having some kind of flow xD
---
So with the Rouge and Knuckles chapter for example; There is a lot of 'telling' initially, because I wanted to give context throughout the showing, so that when we get to the flashback scenes you have all the information you need to fill in the blanks and understand why every decision they've made has brought them to this present relationship. At least that was my intention, but I still have a habit of waffling too hard sometimes.
In a way, i kind of treat it like 'doing the math' lol
So for them, the thought process goes like this (and a lot of this is headcanon building on headcanon based on what I take from the media) :
What does Knuckles represent to Rouge? -> Home, security, comfort, stability, predictability. -> Why? Because he was raised to care about tradition, because he knows the importance of commitment and duty (why? because he's spent the first part of his life guarding an important artefact without question or applause) -> Why does this matter to Rouge? Because 1 we know she respects competence (based on how she acts and who she associates herself with and the self-respect she has for her own capabilities) and Because 2 Rouge lacks that stable predictability in her own life (why? because shes a government spy/treasure hunter who is all over the place fulfilling her job and goals.)
So then how is this shown in the chapter -> Rouge comes home from work and Knuckles is already making dinner, making her tea, taking care of her, doing domestic things like reinforcing pre-established predictable house rules. How does Rouge respond to this? Throughout the chapter she visibly relaxes, she banters back about house rules because she's aware of their established routine, she physically disrobes to get comfortable, she cuddles him and rests against him for support, she falls asleep in the bedroom knowing that she's safe and loved and is being taken care of.
Then what are the symbols? -> Mountain's being unshakable, flying creatures are in constant motion and without the ground they'll keep falling, birds needing somewhere to perch etc, the dragonfly finding a tulip to settle on, the bee wearing the pollen of a flower so it can return to it, lighthouse on an island for ships in a storm.
For Knuckles, his symbolism is more obvious because he's consistently comparing her to an angel even in his own words, (and I like that it contrasts with how Rouge has seen herself and has been seen in the past, even by him.)
So do it again. What does Rouge represent to Knuckles -> hope, freedom, liberation, his bridge from isolation, someone who descended into his lonely world. Why? Because Rouge lives by her own rules (why? because she can physically go anywhere in the open air as a flying creature, shows up to him uninvited and leaves on her own terms. She completes government missons and treasure hunts all around the world) -> Why does this matter to Knuckles? Because he spent his life being tethered to one spot and bound by duty (and completely alone with limited access to his friends).
How is this shown in the chapter? -> She makes it possible for him to live away from the Emerald and build his own life (because she handles the modern world for them). She offers to reach out to his friends for him because he can't do it alone. She gives active solutions to the Sonic situation because Knuckles struggles to reach out. (why? because he's been conditioned to accept isolation.) He waits for her on Angel Island because he learns from her company that he's actually very lonely, and her presence makes him feel less trapped in his duty. All of this is forms of liberation.
What are the symbols? -> There's physical angelic symbolism in the way she's floating and descending to him to hug him while she's helping to untangle his concerns. The freedom of flying and jealousy over it- In some ways I put in tradition/religion being oppressive, and the bitterness that can come from seeing someone live freely in a way that feels inaccessible under strict order. Burrowing animals being led into the light. Being crushed by tombs. Being trapped under the earth. Just liberation imagery.
And because this is a healthy relationship, I like to mention how they notice the cues of each other, and actively fulfil those needs. Like Rouge noticing that Knuckles might need her to text Cream for him -> thats her understanding her partner on a deep level. Knuckles realising that he spoke a little to harsh about shadow and later being nice about it -> that's him understanding Rouge and tending to her emotionally.
And I'm trying to work all of that in together, between context/subtext, actions and dialogue in the scene, and symbolism. And sometimes that comes from writing out the scene first and then thinking 'ah, this action happened because this character is feeling this way' so then I explain that. OR its the other way around where I want to write about why they matter to each other, and then i think 'i can show this by having them do/say this in the scene'. And i just figure out where that works.
So for example, the moment with them bantering about each other having an attitude, I think 'thats a good place to dive into their banter, and then their personalities, and the fact that Rouge likes a guy who is willing to play with her, but how she also likes a man she can fluster- so then I explain how knuckles is that perfect middle ground- and zing, theres the attraction! But not just that, here is how their compatibility works on a deeper level too...' And that all came from them arguing over a wash basket lol,
because the wash basket moment shows a bit of everything- from their chemistry to their domestic routine, which easily leads into me explaining what they want when it comes to engaging with a partner (why they're attracted to each other beyond aesthetically) and why their values align on a deeper level (shared competence + stability and predictability vs freedom to build a life)
---
NOW FOR SHADOW AND SONIC it works the same way.
So if we look at the scene from Chapter 2 where Sonic and Shadow are having their conversation at the table, theres also a lot going on that im trying to show, because why is Sonic even in that situation in the first place and WHY is his relationship with Shadow so important? I do the math.
Shadow represents a feeling of safety that no-one else can give Sonic -> Why? Because Sonic is the worlds hero and Shadow is his rival -> why does that matter? Because that means only Shadow can match him, and that means that if Sonic were to fail then at least someone could catch him and finish the job = Sonic feels less pressure on him when Shadow is around, he's allowed to be vulnerable because vulnerability no longer means that people die (because someone else can do his job too). -> So what happens when that's gone? It means that Sonic, without that invisible safety net, is unable to be vulnerable when things go wrong. -> And what are the consequences of that? When things go wrong (like a divorce) he can't reach out to his friends, he can't admit he's struggling, he cries on his own, be berates himself for struggling and he constantly feels alone. And when he finds himself homeless and struggling with money, he can't ask for help -> Until Shadow comes back.
I've sort of explained that by working backwards there, but if it was reversed and i asked first 'why is sonic in this position' instead, doing the math the other way still makes sense to me how things transpired by Shadow disappearing, and why he was so desperate to see Shadow and stay with him when he came back.
I do the exact thought process with how his relationship with amy fell apart, and how I write Shadows internal thoughts with the 'maria voice'.
Usually when there's an emotional/character/relationship point I want to make, I'll write a list out for that beat (exactly how I've just shown you here, but less detailed), or I'll put in a note while I'm writing just to be like 'mention Shadow in conversation here- then explain Knuckles' history with him, initial relationship jealous but shadow mega gay lol, then why hes pissed that he left rouge on her own for a decade.'
This was a long response but I wanted to go into detail and I hope that helps, I've never thought about it in concrete terms before haha xD
I was not ready for a wall of text, but I absolutely love it! It really seems like you put a lot of thought into this story and the characters.
You've said before that this is your first fanfic, but I can't help but wonder if you've done this before? Like if you've written fiction before, because it just seems so well thought out and practiced for a first attempt.