very much in my hater era
sirius isn't a damsel in distress
remus isn't COOL or CALM or BRILLIANT
regulus isn't an animagus ffs
regulus could NEVER save the entire world
barty is ten times cleverer than regulus
evan rosier put up a good fight with moody but DIED
volvol is literally a street urchin. he's poor and he was raised in an orphanage. his upbringing was religious as fuck
when james asked lily out in front of snape it was to stick it to snape, not to get her to agree. her saying no actually helped in his endeavour, "see, snivellus, she wouldn't go out with the most brilliant popular boy in school even to save your arse" sort of way
lily's brilliant but she doesn't PUT PEOPLE DOWN FOR IT
walburga is a cunt and irredeemable as well but she would never use the cruciatus ffs
walburga put up with sirius' shite because she fucking admired him, she preferred him over regulus
it wasn't remus who worked out how to become an animagus (one of the most dangerous and difficult things you can do) it was JAMES AND SIRIUS and also peter but it's inferred that peter needed quite a bit of help
peter wasn't useless. he was very good at magic, only sirius and james overshadowed him a LOT because they were simply better
remus doesn't "put up" with james and sirius, he's in AWE of them. he can't BELIEVE they call him friend
sirius didn't ABANDON regulus, he left an abusive household
sirius would NEVER choose regulus over james. people who say so truly don't know what having a best friend means
jegulus was fun when it was just a joke on tt but it lacks nuance in a way that is disturbing. as if james was boiled down to a simpering idiot and regulus was raised to the state of perfection
wolfstar is just the response to having jily as a ship and wanting some m/m. and that would be FINE except there is a heavy power imbalance in every iteration. and don't even get me started in the fucking cis-het characterisation of their relationship.
sirius is a fucking forest fire, not a bumbling bitch
the strongest person in the whole marauder's era is SIRIUS. he was raised in an abusive household and, against all odds, ended up with a strong moral compass and the ability to love with his whole heart. when he fucked up, the prank, he owned up to it almost immediately and told james. his best friend DIED and his first instinct was to protect his child. when that was denied, he was clever enough to know that there was no future for him and he, instead of breaking, sought revenge. when that failed, he was sent to azkaban, which is a place where MOST people die within weeks and fucking KEPT HIS SANITY, and a good part of his health. he was confined to the place he escaped , grimmauld, and he still was able to function (with a minor alcohol addiction. could be worse, given his situation). he was pleasant, collected, incredibly clever. he had the strength to forgive remus, who left him as if he'd never existed, for TWELVE YEARS. he was civil enough to the person who was responsible for the death of his best friend and who emotionally abused his godson, the only person he truly loves at this point. put up with being absolutely bashed and ridiculed by hermione, molly, even remus and arthur. put himself in arguably the worst and most dangerous place for him, an escaped convict, to save his godson and then he died, not losing a duel against bellatrix, but actually being hit by dumb luck with a stunning spell and falling through the veil.
james potter, arrogant, funny, beloved, said to be incredible on a broom, head boy, clever as fuck, had the biggest heart of them all. sacrificed himself without even batting an eye. put himself in danger numerous times, not least every full moon and ESPECIALLY when the prank happened. where was peter, huh?
remus was quiet, sort of cowardly, and ran from his problems. he ALWAYS runs. his friends find out he's a werewolf? he runs. his friends think he's a traitor? he runs. his best friend's son is left orphaned? he runs. his best friend is accused of betraying the fucking potters? he does NOT show up for him for TWELVE YEARS. his ex friend, whom he thinks is a murderer and of whom he has some information on? he chooses not to say shite because he's afraid of how it'll play out with dumbledore. he is asked directly by harry, a traumatised child, about sirius black and his relationship with his dead father and he... fumbles. he, in a sense, runs. his lycantropy is found out by the entire school but he still has a place for him as a teacher in the only stable job he's ever had? he runs. he falls in love with someone who loves him back? he fucking runs. he finally marries someone whom he loves and who loves him (don't even get me started on tonks, i've got a lot of thoughts on tonks and the disservice done for that character) and is about to have a child with that person? HE FUCKING ABANDONS HIS PREGNANT SPOUSE TO GO PLAY WITH SOME TEENAGERS. i am not saying he isn't a good person, or that he cannot be likeable, but for FUCK'S sake, he's not a hero. and he is, in my eyes, just as fucked up and capable of fucking up as sirius, if not more. he literally endangered students just because he was scared to own up to something he enabled when he was a teenager. he abandons his pregnant spouse because he's SCARED. look me in the eye and tell me if tonks, twenty-something tonks, pregnant with a, potentially, deathly ill child, WAS NOT SCARED SHITLESS AS WELL?! HE'S EVEN AFRAID OF STANDING UP TO HIS BEST FRIENDS, NOT EVEN AS A CHILD OR TEENAGER, AS A FULLY GROWN ADULT (in ootp, the firecall scene)