How to Hook Your Readers: Myths and Tips
Opening a story can be daunting. Unless you're super inspired, it will likely always seem like a challenge to get that first sentence or paragraph down.
The good news? You can always go back and revise your intro as needed. You may better understand your story as you write it and think of a better starting point or line later.
The bad news? There are definitely some myths out there that writers often believe about their hooks. I know I have! Let's go over a few.
Common Myths About Hooking Your Readers
Never Start With Dialogue
I'm guessing that people give this advice because starting in the middle of a conversation can be a bit bewildering. Although that's true in real life, books or stories that start in a conversation can easily catch the reader up to speed.
"I swear, it's like I'm cursed to forever get pink chicken nuggets."
"Dude, it's just the cafeteria food. McDonald's would never steer you wrong." My best friend shook their head and laughed as I dropped my uncooked chicken nugget back onto my school lunch tray. The room was full of people buzzing with conversation, eating their food without complaint.
"No way," I said, my nose crinkling. "And of course my curse has to attempt some health damage on the day of my first ever musical tryouts."
The dialogue sets up the protagonist's generally sour demeanor and the conversation establishes the story's first source of conflict: the musical tryouts later that day.
You can also look to George R.R. Martin's A Game of Thrones opening line:
"We should start back,ā Gared urged, as the woods began to grow dark around them. āThe wildlings are dead.ā
Just with that one line, you know who's speaking, that they aren't in a good environment, and there's literally action right around the corner.
Speaking of action, do you always have to start with a scene that involves things like racing cars, a fist fight, or your protagonist sailing down the tracks of a rollercoaster?
Absolutely not. In fact, many of the most famous books start with gentle pacing so they can work their way up to bigger conflicts as the readers get to know their characters.
Think about Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice:
'It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife'
Or J.M. Barrie's Peter Pan:
All children, except one, grow up.
Your story may have a fantastic opening line or scene if it just makes the reader think of something new or from a new perspective. The shock and/or reframing will intrigue them to learn more about what you mean.
Readers Only Care About That First Line
When was the last time you read the first line of a book and judged it in its entirety? If I've done that, it's been rarely.
You're more than likely going to give a new book the first full page, or chapter, or the first 100 pages before deciding if you like it.
You'll know if it interests you when the hook makes itself known. Sometimes authors even make their hooks happen at the end of their first chapters. That's great too!
So try not to stress too much about having the perfect opening line. Most people will automatically read many more before making a personal judgement call.
Tips for Writing Great Hooks
Make the Reader Ask One of the W's
The W's can help you define a hook that mostly feels like going with your gut.
When you write a first line and know that it's perfect but can't describe why, ask if it will make your readers wonder any of the following questions:
Where is this character/action?
When is this taking place?
You don't necessarily need to answer every single one of these questions on your first page, but they should resolve within your first few pages or chapter. A useful hook will make your readers wonder about one or more of those questions.
Start at a Critical Plot Point
Sometimes the start of a story doesn't work because it's boring. Even if it answers the W's above, it can still take a while for people to start investing in the plot.
When that happens, you may need to press fast-foward a bit during the editing process.
Let's say your protagonist goes to the grocery store, which is where the primary conflict takes place. The story starts by describing their drive to the store, finding where they should park, and filling their cart with a few items on their grocery list.
While that information sets the scene for your readers and introduces your protagonist, it's not very interesting. They're all ordinary actions.
Instead, you could start with your character at the grocery store, spend a few lines or a paragraph on their inner monologue to develop their characteritics, then have the action happen right away.
Open on the scene where they encounter their worst enemy in the frozen food aisle or their ex at the checkout line. The conflict immediately gets the plot started and is guaranteed to interest the reader because without that initial conflict, the story wouldn't happen at all. It would just be another trip to the grocery store.
Confuse the With Something Unfounded
"I once heard that you should never trust someone who never blinks. I mean, an owl told me that, so they would know."
If you read this first line, you'd immediately wonder how the protagonist could talk to owls. Are they a human with a supernatural gift? Are they also an owl? Can the owl in question speak a human language?
Something as lighthearted and seemingly small as that kind of detail will make your reader curiously confused. They'll keep reading just to find out how the story unrolls from such a strange opening.
Although the shock-and-awe opener doesn't fit every genre or theme, it can be a fun way to make your readers do a double-take and dive into your story.
I am always reminding myself that the first thing I write when a new story begins isn't permanent. You can always go back, revise, and even shuffle scenes if you think the whole first scene of your story is boring.
Give yourself permission to go with your gut and you'll eventually hone that hook into something captivating.