I'm still new to paganism and recently I think I've been feeling guilty. Specifically, I'm a black girl who was raised on stories about greek and celtic mythology and such and I was drawn to Gaia and Kernunnos as patron deities for various reasons. But I've seen various people say that since I'm black I should try to stick to the gods and goddess of my heritage like the Yoruba or Egyptian Gods. But I don't feel any connection to those gods AT ALL. Do you have any advice for me?
What those people are telling you is straight-up bullshit. The Greek and Celtic polytheisms are open to anyone regardless of culture, ethnicity, race, or other identity.Â
Disclaimer: I am white in both passing and identity and have never experienced what you have. However, Iâm a Celtic polytheist. A few, though not all, reasons on why these various people are wrong:
Being black doesnât automatically disclaim you from a Greek or Celtic-based heritage. Itâs entirely possible for someone with dark skin to have stronger blood ties to a Greek or Celtic culture than someone with white skin.
However, blood ancestry is not a requirement to be a Hellenist or Gaulish/Celtic polytheist. Â Thereâs a reason we Celtic polytheists (and others) use the address âancestors of blood and spirit.â
Cernunnos is a Gallo-Roman deity, and we all know how much the Romans loved spreading their culture and syncretizing their deities to everyone elseâs. Restricting Gaulish polytheism on the basis of skin color is protecting an ideal that never existed in the first place.
The Greeks did this too, especially in the Hellenic era.
This also has nothing to do with your nationality. What if you were born and raised in Greece and identify as Greek? Or in France and as French? You have as much right to your nationâs heritage as anyone else who shares your national identity. (The concepts within race are also different in Europe than they are in America, so that undoubtedly changes historical and contemporary views about your question depending on where you live and who youâre talking to.) Ethnicity, ancestry, nationality, and culture are all different things, though definitely related.
For them to tell you which religions are okay or not okay for you to practice because youâre a black girl sounds like an expression of colonialist privilege and assumption.
Both religions are open as long as respect is paid to their original cultures, both the historical and the contemporary, which should be true for every religion anyway. There may be small, individual groups who have initiatory requirements, like dedicated priesthoods, but they are not representative of the broader communities.
Itâs possible some of these people mean well. Maybe they think that âencouragingâ you to stick to what they assume, correctly or otherwise, is your ancestry is being supportive. Doesnât change how wrong they are.
Thereâs also a theological conflict here. Again, I canât speak for Hellenics, but:
Some of the most important principles in the Celtic polytheisms include honor (which admittedly can be defined in various ways), right action and judgment, and hospitality. If any of the people excluding you because youâre black are Celtic polytheists, they are in contempt of their faith and their gods. There is no honor, justice, or community in gatekeeping âsince [youâre] black.â
The Celtic polytheisms are orthopraxic, which emphasizes conduct over ritual or âpurity of faith.â Conduct that violates the principles that define so much of what many of us practice is hypocritical just in general.
This is all true even if the gatekeepers themselves have blood ancestry.
I would much rather have someone like you, who seems to be respectful and sympathetic person, standing beside me in a ritual rĂĄth than a racist and hypocrite with a fancy ~Celtic~ pedigree.
Anon, you have as much a right to walk a Hellenic or Celtic path as anyone else. You read up on Hellenic and Gaulish etiquette and patron deities, go chat up Gaea and Cernunnos, and ignore the squeaking of rats.
Whoever is telling you that because youâre black you âshould look to Yoruba or Kemeticism insteadâ clearly donât know either religions very well. Just because youâre black doesnât mean youâre able to proclaim the title of Mambo in Vodun. Just because youâre black doesnât make you a priestess in Kemeticism. Yoruba is a tradition that is heavily protected and has a solid structure that needs to be followed, whether youâre black or not (as far as from what Iâve seen said by Yoruba practitioners).
Ancient Egyptians had quite a few different ethnicities, including Nubian, Middle Eastern etc. Kemeticism itself is an open religion seeing as Ancient Egypt was imperialistic and colonialist, because they viewed their way of life as the most civilized way to live.
You are free to go where your heart leads you especially considering your heart is leading you to gods that will most certainly welcome you with open arms.
before asking | faq+tags | resource blog