As a consumer of music, I have a love of metal (be it technical, progressive, metalcore, etc.).
As a creator of music, I am decidedly not a shredder, of guitar strings or vocal cords.
So come time to write the songs within The Dark, the challenge was finding that pocket that allowed for the satiation of hard hitting progressions without crafting sections that none of us in the band could play live. What evolved from the dilemma was a compromise that consisted of utilizing all three stringed instruments to fill out the audible spectrum with dissonant chords that complimented each other (allowing for that immediate crunch and desired texture), then using technical flourishes that bounced around the existing progressions and melodies. This culminates strongly in the first minute of Cities to the Sword. Coming out of The Dark swinging, with a gut-punch of minor chords that careens into a more open verse, punctuated with oddly metered chord hits that then dives, Pete Rose style, into a frenetic, finger-tapped tirade that's kept in check by an equally active bass counter melody and ambient, finger-plucked chords to both provide space and ease the song into it's quiet bridge.
This push and pull of musical elements was important to the overarching story of the record, and this section in particular. Where the previous songs (and songs to come) feature a continuous ebb and flow of elements, Cities to the Sword needed to put down some hard stops that felt overtly dramatic, as well as melodic ideas that started separate from each other to create an obvious dissonance. The entire conflict of this section of the album was born from an intense period of inevitable, personal questioning of faith, and the dichotomy of human/divine nature, in particular. The conclusion here falling somewhere near the mark of accepting the impossibility of perfection, spitting at that acceptance, and wrestling with the implications of what the outlook I'd subscribed to said that meant. Cities was not designed to deliver much of an answer, though, this song was an opportunity to offer little to no retribution, and revel in that emotion for a scant six minutes.
Stepping back from the visceral, live nature of the track in the studio really allowed us to fine tune some of the early chaotic passages. Originally, the section starting at 1:53 had absolutely no melodic structure to it, we'd open-strum our guitars and wail about until the proper 16-count had elapsed. Having passed on some live demos of the song to Terry Geer while preparing to record, he called me up with the note of "Change this section, tighten it up". He was right, and we re-wrote the section to have some semblance of structure to it without abandoning the desired chaos. Living on in the original’s stead are an oscillating, tremolo-ed guitar and a warped-out, tapped guitar (utilizing a patch I believe was called a MoogerFooger) that sounded like a demented ambulance. At one point, Terry applied those same effects to the shouted "It is here where sin dwells" vocals and exclaimed to me, "You sound like a demon!" This choice was, ultimately, nixed.
Those separating guitar parts really start to kick in at 2:03, as the repeating chord progressions slowly begin to wind away from each other with each recurring pass, only to be paired again in the following section, but consciously (and consistently) in harmony while trying desperately to sound like a simplified version of something off Protest the Hero's Kezia. All of which leads to the last lull in the track, a mellow, jazz inspired passage, recorded at the end of a long day of tracking. So long, in fact, that Terry had just woken up from a nap and sleepily stumbled through dialing in multiple effects pedals to get the sound I was loosely describing. “I can’t say much for myself,” he uttered, “but I can setup an effects pedal in my sleep”. Truer words, Terry.
Speaking of words, the closing lines were culled from either the book of Isaiah or Deuteronomy, and was designed as an ambiguous omen without an obvious target. At the time of it’s writing, I knew it felt right to frame it that way but I couldn’t have told you why it was the right choice. I'm still not certain of who is actually saying that last line, if it's supposed to be me speaking to myself or a threat to external forces that incite failure. Thinking on it now, I find that that last line exercises one of my favorite things about songwriting: That I could be honest without an answer, and therefore, honest with myself.
Another cherished element of songwriting was the community of people who connected with it. Without that community, we never would have laid down such boisterous gang vocals over the end of the song. And so, up from the bowels of some long forgotten hard drive, here’s the whole gang (almost, the lens wasn’t wide enough to catch everybody) back in 2011 hollering in a basement.