Ok so I mentioned this on discord BUT
What if thereās another shadow in book 3, and what if itās Hanya? Think about how this will affect the entire plot. Hanya is the only one in the group with no intention to kill Rusty whatsoever, and is by far the most morally pure. At least, to our knowledge. Now the shadow rapports do put these characters into the shoes of darkness and we can see what may bring them to the point of hypothetically turning to Fenris. What would Hanyaās wish be? Hereās my biggest guesses:
1. Bringing down her corrupt family; that could be her wish, and if she failed to get the axe to the last one in the bloodline, then sheād have a backup plan.
2. Protecting Notia; she cares about Notia, whether or not she rules it. If she was that concerned and happened to come upon a wish that could assure her of her goal, she might take it.
So hypothetically, we have our shadow Hanya. But how would the characters react? Our biggest players at the moment are Rusty, Ananke, Eugene, and Perenna to a slightly lesser extent.
Rusty has become aware of Hanyaās noble intentions over the course. This contrasts his earlier attitude where he (ironically) trusted her the least. Would he have what it takes to deal with her, though? Yes. Itās also not that hard considering sheās part of the family that killed his, and he still probably isnāt sure of how much she would have been in the know.
Ananke would be surprised. She expected Hanya to be infallible and too strong to be tempted. Yet I think sheād also be understanding, especially having made her own pact out of desperation. Sheād believe Hanyaās reasons were fair. Anankeās currently at a standstill with where her actions will lead her. But thereās no real reason for her to deal with Hanya unless the latter affects her goals. She wants to use the axe to help free her of shadow, and heck she might even convince Hanya to do the same.
Eugene, now heās the wild card. Heās interesting because of why heās so devoted to Hanya. Itās not out of romantic ambitions or blind loyalty to the country Ć la Camus. Heās devoted because he knows her principles are just and that her goodness makes her a perfect fit to rule. But that goodness is cracked with the reveal of her shadow pact. So it depends now on if Eugene is more attached to Hanya, or his idea of Hanya. If he chooses Hanya, heād lay down his life to protect her, and believe that she could still do good as a shadow. But if his expectations are shattered, he might be distraught, or angry. Heād go against her because everything he believed was a lie. But if he fought her, it would still be with regret nevertheless.
Perenna probably wouldnāt really care. Her goal is getting paid for the job, and her role has nothing to do with Hanya whatsoever. I bet sheād be take aback similar with Ananke, but not enough to have her actions affected in any way.