BELLY TO BELLY
andrew pope cody x f!reader
summary: pope comes home from prison and meets craig's new gorgeous friend, you. you're quiet and a little odd, in an adorable way he becomes obsessed with. and he wonders how a sweet girl like you could be friends with an idiot like his little brother. one night, he learns about your little stingray obsession and uses that as a way to try and get closer to you. and it works.
content/warnings: lots of em dashes (only because I've always used them, I swear this isn't AI), a whole ass book before they even kiss (really just me yapping), age gap (reader is like 20-21, pope is late 30s), s1 pope (because I think his haircut is cute), i'm sorry if everyone is ooc (i'm new here), reader isn't described as a specific race or weight but does have a specific style, all the cody boys are here & my girl cath, reader is kinda a stoner, mentions of sm*rf & b*z, switch!pope, pope's a bit of creep (he likes to smell you and touch your hair and watch you and touch your body when you're sleeping or when you're not looking, it's okay you like it), dry humping (yum), cumming in pants (yummier), biting, chasing, finger in mouth, mentions of male masturbation, a bit of fluff, nicknames for reader by Craig include pet/bug/shorty, nicknames for reader by pope include honey & baby, baz catches you and is pissed but craig to the rescue, pansexual tendencies, 18+ ONLY!
note: this is my first fic on tumblr... it's kinda long and not proofread, so please be nice and thank you. muah!!
Your brother sold weed, that's how you met your best friend. Craig Cody, or El Craigo as he's tried to get you to call him. Of course, you don't. He came onto you, thinking you were hot. But every time he tried, womp womp. He eventually gave up yet couldn't stay away from you, you were funâ in a quiet way.
You often prefer books and embroidery to actual human interactions but he prefers surfing to anything else (sometimes even parties), so friendship went smoother than dating would have. And the one thing you had in common was really what kept you guys together, weed. You two would smoke up to three blunts and just laugh about nothing before ordering too much food and/or annoying deran.
His family loved you, even the wicked witch herself. She liked how you just did what she wanted (though you only did because you could tell she was awful and wanted her off your back). Deran thought you were great, he loved having you around. J liked how colorful your vibe was compared to the Codys. And Baz... you hate Baz. asshole. No real reason to, you just do. Cath could do better, you thought every time you saw him.
Then came Andrew.
The day you met was a few days after he returned, a week after his sister died. You walked behind Craig like you were his little tail. Dressed in a little green 60s mini dress, tights with little bugs on them, and ballet flatsâ an outfit that was considered toned down compared to your usual fashion.
"Yo." Craig called out as he walked into the kitchen, everyone immediately ignored him as soon as you appeared.
"Hey!" Cath practically squealed, happy to see you. You liked Cath, she was kind. Everyone greeted you, having not seen you in almost two weeks.
"Y/N, this is our brother, Pope. Pope, this is my pet bug, Y/N." Craig says, using the same joke he always does when he introduces you to someone. You turned around and there he was. my word... Immediately you could feel how different his presence felt compared to others. And how much you liked it. And how pretty fucking hot he was.
You weren't someone who had a partner or felt much interest in dating. It was easier to be alone, though it was lonely at times. But here he stood, the mysterious older brother. Andrew, who they called Pope for a reason you didn't know. Deran had told you about him but you never saw a picture. God... how you wished you knew how handsome he was. And as you felt his unsettling aura, your mind wandered to places it only would when you were aloneâ in the darkness of your room.
"Hi." You whispered. You were always so soft-spoken.
"Hi." He spoke back. He voice was nice, raspy. You began to pick at your fingers as the conversation went on with everyone talking about things you didn't care about.
You tried your best not to look at him. Andrew. You tried to look at Craig or your hands but Baz was standing too close for comfort. He always tried to put his arm around your shoulder, even in front of his wife. And you hated that. You weren't big on touch, especially not with Baz. ewwwahhh
You liked physical touch, lots of it. But it had to be with someone you've accepted into your soul family. You were a strong believer in that we all have more than one soulmate. And Baz was NOT a part of your soul. So when he tried again, you stepped aside and bumped into someone. Andrew. He was already looking at you when you looked over.
"Sorry..." Even though you were barely audible, he heard you. You looked away again, but he didn't and you felt it. He looked down at your tights. How they hugged you thighs...
"Alright, Smurf. Come on, bug." You ears heard Craig say as he left, you followed close behind but not before taking a peak back to the oldest Cody. Still, he stared at you... and you didn't seem to mind.
"Your brother is very handsome." You tell Craig as you enter his room.
"Ew! Don't tell me Baz finally got to you." He replied, you immediately pretended to gag.
"I'd rather have my skin be peeled off little by little." You joked, he laughed loudly as he plopped down onto his bed. You never went near his bed unless you knew for sure his sheets were clean, thankfully today it was cleanâ or clean enough.
"Then who? J? Cause he's not my brother, he's my nephew. And Deran is gay, remember?" He asks as he begins to roll a new blunt, you lay back on his headboard.
"Not J or Deran. The other one, Andrew." You say, Craig pauses. He slowly turns to look at you, expecting you to laugh or give him some type of sign you were joking. But you didn't.
"Pope?" He sat up, "Pope!?" Any louder and they would've heard him in the kitchen.
"Yeah." You answered softly.
"Please tell me your joking. You can't actually be saying you wanna fuck Pope." He said, you rolled your eyes at your best friend.
"I said he was handsome, not that I wanna fuck him." You told him as you chris crossed your leg.
"I've known you for two yearsâ you wanna fuck my creepy brother, it's all over you face. You want him all over your face." He teased, you laughed. Oddly enough, as stupid as he can be, he was usually the only one who could make you laugh and smile. He knew you quite well.
"Would it bother you if I did?" You ask. The question came out before you could stop it. You were a virgin, you never actually wanted to have sex with anyone. No one ever caught your eye. But Andrew...
"I mean you can if that's what you really want. You body, your stupid choiceâ or whatever the fuck. Just know I'd throw up tho." Craig replied. He didn't care who you slept with or dated, not as long as you were happy. Even if it was his weird older brother.
The next time you saw Andrew was a random Thursday, the next week.
You were back at Smurfs, sitting on the couch with Craig. It was late. You wore purple patterned shorts and a blue tank top, blue spiders on your white knee-high socks. Your legs were draped over Craig's lap, a bowl of M&Ms on your lap, both of you laying back as if you had worked for hours on end all month. You guys had just smoked two blunts and were laughing at horror movies. Deran and J had joined you somewhere into the marathon, not really taking your attention.
Then you felt it... his presence.
"What are you guys watching?" You heard him ask, your heart almost moonwalked out of your chest. You looked back and again, there he was. His eyes never seem to look at anything else, just you.
"Scream 1." J answered his question. You looked away, pressing your thighs together. Thankfully Craig was so high he probably didn't know he was still alive let alone that you were sexually attracted to his older brother's unsettling aura.
"Come on." Deran calls him over, Andrew sat down on one of the chairs. Specifically the one that was next to you since you were on one of the ends of the couch. You looked again, you can't help yourself. He's so handsome.
He stares at you still, you're getting used to it quickly. You gave him a small smile before turning away. The chair was close. He was close. Andrew got an unbearable urgeâ he wanted to touch your hair. It was just there, hanging perfectly down your back. He wanted to cut off a piece and keep it in his pocket so he could smell it when you weren't around... of course he wouldn't actually do that he definitely would.
He just liked you. It was weird for him to admit that but he did. His own family was scared of him. They found him strange. But you? You smiled at him. You fucking smiled at him. That's all it took for him to pick you out of everyone. He picked you, he wants you. You will be his. Maybe you'll fix him. He thought about that. Maybe someone like you could be kind enough to fix someone like him, if he can be fixed.
You didn't think there was anything wrong with him. You didn't think like others, like him. He seemed normal to you. So he liked to stare at you, so what? It's so easy to just let him. He's not hurting you. He was just released from a cell, let him stare at whatever he wants. As the movie ended and J put in the next one, Craig groaned.
"I'm so tired." He whined, shoving a handful of M&Ms into his mouth.
"So go to sleep." J told him.
"Don't wanna." Craig whined while picking up M&Ms and gently throwing them at you. You tried to catch them with your mouth and failed a couple times. You chuckled as he tried to got up, defeated by sleep.
"Fine, whatever." He whispers, "'Night, shorty."
"'Night." You replied as you leaned away to take your legs off him.
That's when it happened. Your hair... it touched Andrew's hand. You didn't notice, it was just for a second. But oh... Andrew notice. He almost came grabbed it. He couldn't believe how soft it was. He'd bet his life it smelled nice too, like you. He remembers the day you met, how when you got closer he could smell you. Like vanilla and rose petals. He wanted to lick the scent off you... Who said that? Are you not hearing that? Whatever.
You planned on staying for the rest of the other movies, until Baz arrived. why is he here!!?? go home!! He immediately sat next to you, reaching out to touch your shoulder. You pushed his arm away as you sit up straight and placed the bowl in-between you and him. You could feel the uncomfortable-ness built in you when you realize he was looking at your exposed thighs. dickhead.
"I think I'm gonna go too." You say softly as you stand up.
"Hey, if Craig kicks you again, you can sleep in my bed. I'm gonna head over to Adrian's in a few." Deran informs you, the quietest little 'thanks' escaped your lips as you left.
"'Night." You whispered. And there it was again. His voice.
"Goodnight." Andrew replies, it was small and sweet. You smiled widely but thankfully you were already out of sight when you did. Oh... you've made up your mind. It's him. He will be the one to take your virginity. You don't know when or how, but it will be him.
It was the middle of the night. 3, maybe 4, am.
You laid on Craig's bed, him next to you. Well... actually he was almost on the floor but still. You didn't mind sharing beds with friends, you liked it. It was fun. You would shower with your friends if they wanted, TMI is non-existent to you. But tonight, you couldn't sleep. You couldn't stop thinking about your decision. Andrew Cody will take my virginity, the thought danced in your head like a drunk cowboy.
You stood up off the bed, your white Lolita style nightgown falling down to hang just above your mid thigh. It was almost see-through if you looked hard enough. Enough to see the orange polkadot panties you had on, and maybe your bare chest too. You walked out of Craig's room and out to the living room. You hoped you could just watch something until you felt sleepy. What you didn't expect was for Andrew to be there too...
It almost scared you, to see someone else awake this late. He simply sat in the same chair, watching tv. Little jellyfish swimming on the screen, a man narrating quietly. He looked so peaceful. Andrew. Just doing mundane things. You've only seen him twice, both times he seemed so tense and uncomfortable but he looked relaxed now.
You almost just wanted to leave him alone but your body moved before you could control it. You looked away from him as you approached, head turned to the tv. You took a glance at him, he's looking at you again. Or... he's looking at your nightgown. You didn't mind. It flattered you. Maybe he thought you were pretty.
"What are you watching?" You ask.
"Documentary." He answered. You liked his voice like this. So gentle, it almost cracks when he speaks.
"Can I watch it with you?" You asked him, finally looking at him. He stares up at your eyes for a good second, and you stare back.
"Yeah." He whispers. You smiled slightly as you sat down where you had been, close.
You're not sure how long you were there for, watching the fishes on tv. It wasn't until a big stingray appeared on the screen that you almost jumped up. You straighten yourself and leaned forward, once again chris crossing your leg. You listened to every word the narrator said, looking at the beautiful creatures. Andrew noticed.
"During mating season, the male ray will smell his prey from afar. He'll pick her without even interacting, immediately beginning the chase before she knows what's happening." The man in the tv said.
"He'll follow the female ray, chasing her for up to daysâ trying to bite her fins. Once the male has a good grip, he works to maneuver the female so they are positioned belly-to-belly. The male then bends his body over her, inserting a pair of tube-like sex organs called claspers into the female's body by rubbing himself on herâ to transfer his sperm and reproduce." He explained, you chuckled as you leaned back again.
"Sounds fun." You joked. You turned to Andrew, unsure of what you wanted from him. The corners of his lips very slowly rise up. It was almost a smile. Almost was enough for you.
You scratched yourself out on the couch, a sweet smile on your lips. You've expected that what you feel is a crush, a big one. That tiny smile of his just made you confident in your decision. He's the one. But you had to get to know him better. It can't be just a stranger in your bed, in you. You picked someone, now you have to make sure it was the right choice.
All the thinking and the pretty stingray images made you finally slip into sweet, sweet slumber. zzzz You were fine with sleeping on the couch, but I guess Andrew was not. In the state of halfway asleep, you felt him pick you up bridal style. You were very tired to move and you thought it was kind of him, so you let him. He ever so gently placed you back on Craig's bed, your best friend now laying on the floor with a towel as a blanket.
Andrew hovered for a moment, you felt his heat over you. His hand landed ever so slightly on your cheek. You felt how his rough palm pushed your hair back and caressed your neck down to your chest, just above your breasts. His hand made its way down to your legs. His knuckles lightly brushing up and down on your thigh for a few seconds before pulling your nightgown down.
You should have mined but you didn't. What is wrong with you? You don't know him. You met him twice. But he touches you in your sleep and all you think of was how easy it might be to convince him to take your virginity. If he liked you enough to touch you like this, he'd do it. Maybe. You reach over and grab his hand, he pulls away.
Andrew's heart drops. He thought you were sound asleep. He wasn't going to hurt you or touch you beyond the great 'no-go' line. He just wanted to feel your skin. Your young, soft, clean, perfect, untouched skin. You have to be an angel sent from heaven because you're completely unreal to him.
"Thank you, Andrew." You whispered out. It went straight to his cock, truthfully. You saying his real name and not the nickname that made him hate himself... It turned him on enough for him to practically run away. to spend the whole night in deran's empty room, stroking himself dumb as he thinks of you saying his real name. Who is saying these things?? My god...
Three days later, you were back. He felt so guilty after that night. Embarrassed, having done what he did to himself while thinking of you. Especially now, after seeing you again. Perfect little you. He had woken up late, a rare thingâ but he had been jerking off to the image of you in his head again and got tired thinking of you. WOAH!! anyways...
He stood behind you, almost next to you. Just looking... You had on a bright yellow 60s mini patterned dress on, matching ballet flats, and those adorable bug tights. They're your favorite, you wear them with everything. Andrew wants to rip them off you and buy a hundred more. *sigh* this is getting out of hand...
You looked like you came straight out of a movie. He was so taken aback by your style every time he saw you. No one he's ever known has ever been so bold. But here you are, embracing the fact that anything goes in California. And you rocked every piece you wore. You sat so fucking pretty on the couch.
You were embroidering on the hem what he guessed is another one of your little dresses, this one in blue. You're so cute. Watching the nature channel, lions on the tv. Something he would watch. The closer he gets the more he feels like running back to deran's still empty room to continue his inappropriate shenanigans. for fuck sakes I need her on me, he thought. These voices need to relax!!
You hadn't noticed he was there, watching you, until a lion started to eat a baby deer on the screen and you turned your head away. That's when you saw him. You didn't jump or get weird out or tell him off. You smiled, again. that's like three, he's counting. Your shoulders relaxed as if he was everything you were searching for.
"Hi, Andrew." You say quietly, as if he was your little secret or something.
"Hi." He doesn't know why his voice changes for you when he speaks. He only ever does that when he's talking to his Lena. The voice of a man trying to show that he means no harm, that he only wants to interact.
"You wanna watch it with me?" You asked him.
"Sure." He says, nodding. You move your bag to the chair he was on the other night so he can sit right next to you on the couch. You wanted him closer. You wanted to feel the heat you felt when he carried you to bed. Andrew sat down, very aware of your thighs touching.
"Where is everyone?" He questions. The house was quiet, very uncommon.
"Deran is at Adrian's again, J just left with Nikki, who cares where Baz is, and Craig was supposed to be here but one of his girlfriends told him she might be pregnantâ third time this year." You explained as you very carefully pinned the needle through the fabric.
"Smurf?" He asked, you shrugged. The wicked witch had apparently found someone who can tolerate her enough to take her on a date and she was barely around anymore, according to Baz. *gags*
"Maybe you have a new dad." You joked. Instantly you regret it. It was a dumb joke and you can tell he didn't like it.
"Sorry..." You whispered as you basically hid in your embroidery.
"It's alright, honey." He replied. Honey... holy fuck. no way. no fucking way. somebody sedate me!! The voices are valid right now.
Because your cunt actually had a reaction. Like a physical fucking reaction. Like a heartbeat, just thumping. You pressed your legs together, wanting her to relax. He noticed. You noticed he noticed. fucking mother of mary-kate and ashley... The corners of his lips turned upward, the tiny smile returned. It returned for your very inappropriate behavior.
"Did you hear about the new stingray at the aquarium in Carlsbad?" He asked you, you looked back up at him.
"There's a new one?" You sounded so small as you asked.
"They say it's the biggest one to ever exist, 14 feet." He tells you, he could have drowned in the excited look on your face. He did his research and it was paying off.
"Ugh... and Craig's not here to take me." You complained softly as you looked down again.
"I'll take you." He says.
"Really?" You ask as you try not to look at his beautiful eyes.
"You wanna go now?" He questions.
"Yeah." You said, looking up a little. He stood up so you placed your things aside and stood up too. He stayed there, in front of you, for a few before he moved aside to let you walk ahead. He was fighting the urge to touch you.
The drive there was about 20 to 30 minutes of silence. Andrew didn't play music or talk, not that you minded. You felt comfortable around him, knowing you didn't have to talk as much as when his brothers are around. When you arrived, he opened the door for you. Very gentlemanly of him. When inside, you practically ran towards the big sign that told you where the new arrivals would be.
"They're outside." You said. He gladly followed you around, enjoying how you stop and look at every fish you pass on your way out.
Once out there, you followed the crowd. Next to a big pool, everyone stood on little steps. They looked in as a man with an english accent talked into a microphone. You grabbed Andrew's hand and stepped on, there it was. It was insanely huge like andrew and it swam around gracefully. Did you hear that? No? Okay...
"This beauty came straight from Southeast Asia. 14 feet long, 730 pounds. Record breaking." The English man told everyone. "We've named him BB, for Big Boy."
You laughed. If Andrew could bottle the sound, he would. He'd keep it on his bedside table and hug it when he sleeps. Not that he really does. But if he was holding you, he might sleep forever. Though you probably hadn't even noticed, he didâ you were still holding his hand. Yours small compared to his. Skin so soft...
"Now that doesn't mean he's nice. BB here is quite a rude boy. So please be careful not to touch him or the water." The man explained, you leaned back a little. Your left shoulder lightly pressed on Andrew's chest. He wasn't even looking at the stingray, just at you. He leans in a little and smells his hair, he was right. It smells just like he dreamed it would. Sweet and clean.
"We're thinking of getting him a girlfriend, maybe see the mating ritual done in person." The man said. Andrew couldn't get enough of your face and how lovingly you looked at BB.
You spent the rest of the day together. You explored the rest of the aquarium, touching sea stars and watching seahorses grip seagrass. Andrew even bought you a stuffed stingray from the gift shop, even though you told him he didn't have to. He wanted to. He saw how you lit up when you saw it.
You two ate pizza before he took you to get ice cream, vanilla with chocolate sprinklesâ your favorite. He got plain vanilla, which said a lot about him. But it was cute. He was almost confused when he saw all the flavors, and the tops were too much. You barely even talked the whole time, you just enjoyed each other's company.
He drove you back to the house. Surprisingly, it was still quiet. The sun was setting and no one had come back yet. Just a text from Craig an hour ago, 'false alarm, no baby'. That's it. Usually Andrew would maybe worry a little but he wanted to be alone with you. He needed to be, for what he was planning next. He felt like a creep. He was about to take a bold step and he was actually praying you wouldn't react in a negative way.
"You wanna play the stingray game?" He asked you as he watched you gather your things on the couch.
"The what?" You question as you look up at him. His heart was about to combust.
"The stingray game." He repeated, his voice cracking.
"What's that?" You ask with a smile, genuine curiosity in your eyes. Oh god, it was working. He caught you on his hook. Now he has to reel you in carefully.
"Someone chases you around and if they catch you, they bite you. Like the mating thing." He explains. You were silent for a moment... please don't leave please don't leave please don't leave, he thought.
"Okay." You said. victory!!!! You stood up and waited for instructions, he couldn't believe this was working.
"I'm gonna chase you, okay? If I catch you, I get to bite you." He told you. you're wet, thinking about his teeth on you ENOUGH!!
"Okay..." You whispered as you took a step back. He smiled. Not a tiny one, a regular closed lip smile.
He could tell you were already playing so he took a step forward. You chuckled as you took off running around the house, he was faster than you thought. You made it all the way out to the backyard and to J's his room. He caught you at the door, his big arms wrapped around your ribs. He lifted you a little as you laughed.
"I got you." He breathes on your ear.
"How are you so fast?" You ask as you try to catch your breath. Your back was pressed against his chest, his racing heart on your shoulder blade.
"Where can I bite you?" His voice was quiet, maybe giving you the chance to ignore him. But you didn't. You held out your right arm, he swallowed deeply. You were actually going to let him bite you. Twilight style.
He gently grabs your wrist and bites down on your forearm. And the unthinkable happened. You moaned... out loud. He stopped, looking at you as he licked his bottom lip. Your eyes were wide and you had no other choice but to laugh, as if it was a joke. It wasn't. You knew that, he knew that. You turned your head away, embarrassment crawling on your face.
"You like that?" Andrew whispers. ahhhhhhhhhh!! fuckmefuckmefuckmefuckme I'm getting there, chill!!!
You looked back, stunned. You couldn't talk, you tired. You just slowly nodded your head yes and he leaned down again. This time digging his teeth into your upper arm, again you moaned. You slapped your other hand over your mouth and closed your eyes, you could feel his smile on your skin.
"Yeah?" He asks as he grabs your other hand, taking it away from your lips. "Can I bite you here?"
His fingers softly glazed the crock of your neck. You sighed, knowing it was happening. His mouth was gonna be on you, it was happening. finally! You laid your head back on his shoulder and nodded. He leaned in as close as he could to your neck, his breath sending chills through your entire bodyâ cunt included.
"Words, baby." He whispers. Baby... fuuuuckuhhh!
"Please bite me, Andrew." You say oh so nicely. He wasted absolutely no time, sinking his teeth into your neck. Like a vampire who hadn't eaten in decades.
You stopped fighting yourself and let the moan that was in your core slip out loudly. The sound made his cock twitch and with how hard he was holding onto you, you felt it. You reached back and grabbed a handful of his short hair, pulling as you slightly rubbed your ass on his crotch. He pulled away and turned you around, roughly bringing your lips to his.
He lifted you again, just a little. Enough so the tippy tips of your feet brushed against the ground as he walked into J's his room. You had your arms completely wrapped around his shoulders/neck. You could feel his tongue against your teeth. He tasted like the vanilla ice cream he had and it mixed with the taste of the chocolate sprinkles you ate.
"Andy." You moaned into his mouth, the back of your legs hitting the bed. His head ached at the sound. Andy. Not Andrew, not Pope. An-dy. God, he needed you.
He pushed his knee in-between your leg as he laid you down, your head hitting the plush of the pillow. He laid his entire bodyweight on top of you, pushing your dress up. Now belly to belly, you wrapped your tights covered legs around him as he kissed down your neck. You reached your hands under him and undid his jeans, just pulling them down a littleâ he let you. You didn't want to have sex, not nowâ not yet. But you wanted to feel him. You grab onto his ass and push him forward, he groans into your skin.
"Like that, Andy." You told him, feeling just how hard he is. Andrew was more than happy to just let you use him. He would lick the ground you walked on if you asked.
"Yeah..." He breathes out as he grinds against you. He can feel how warm you are through your panties and tights.
He places his hands on either side of your head, smelling your hair without shame this time. You moaned loudly again when he bit your jaw, not hard enough to mark but enough to make you leak through your tights and into his underwear. You move his shirt to try and kiss his neck. He stops for a second, sitting up and ripping open his button up. You smile at the sight of his freckled body.
He lays back on top of you, crashing you but you're not complaining. You kiss and lick and bite all over his neck and shoulder. His hands are all over you, from your ankles to your face. Kissing him felt like seeing the holy ghost in person. He was such a great kisser. His grinding, his touching, his kissingâ it made your stomach turn. You had barely kissed others before let alone this. You felt like throwing up, but in a good way.
"You're so perfect." He groaned into your ear, going harder now. The headboard rocked against the wall, he was pushing himself so hard on you... you swear this might just count as losing your virginity.
"Faster." You whined, he happily obeyed.
You've never had an orgasm before. You tried to give yourself one but failed more than once, simply because you didn't have anything to think of. Porn wasn't really your thing, erotic books were great but not enough. But now here's Andrew, just what you needed. And it was the same for him. The only women he slept with were the ones his family paid for. And Cath, but he'd rather not talk or think about that.
"yeahyeahyeah!" He moans softly on your lips. He was close. But he wasn't even gonna think about cumming until you did.
And you were. You felt it. Or at least you felt what you think is an orgasm. Like a rush of pure heat making its way up from your cunt to your chest, your stomach tightening. You placed your hands on his face, looking into his eyes as the heat became worse. You ran your thumb across his mouth. Unexpectedly he took it into his lips and sucked.
That's what drove you over the edge. You threw your head back and ached your back, your vision whitening. You moaned louder than before. Clinging onto Andrew as your legs shake, feeling it pool in your underwear. His arm around your waist, keeping you close. He made sure to ride you out before he let go. Moaning your name as he came, resting his head on your chest.
Neither of you moved. Why would you? This was heaven. Him on top of you. You under him. You had gotten used to his weight, you didn't need oxygen. You stroked his hair, he rubbed your outer thigh. Your cunt and his cock still closer than ever, just letting each other's cum wet the other's underwear. You felt so sleepy. Until he slapped the side of your ass, making you laugh. He kissed your chest, up to your neck. Gentle and sweet.
"Andy." You whispered. The nickname stuck. You couldn't call him anything else and he didn't want you to.
"Yeah, honey?" He replied. You might just have to change your name to honey so he can call you that every hour of every day.
"If this is a one time thing for you, that's fine. But I don't want it to be. I want you. I wanna get to know you. See the good, see the bad. I want you to take my virginity." You told him, he lifted his head and looked you into your pretty eyes. For a moment, he wondered... how did he manage to get a girl so perfect and beautiful and kind, and untouched?
"It's not a one time thing. You're mine now. And I'll take your virginity if you want me to. I promise I'll keep it safe." He says back. You felt your heart flutter like a butterfly.
"I'm yours? Does that mean you're mine?" You ask.
"Yeah." He whispers, another real smile on his face.
"Yeah?" You teased as you ran your thumb across his mouth again. And again, he took it into his lips with a little 'mhm'. He rested his forehead on yours, sucking your thumb slowly.
"Are you fucking joking!?" You both jumped up when you heard someone else talk. Baz. ewwwww!!! fuck off!!!
He stood at the doorway, shocked at the scene. You quickly pushed Andrew off you, just to pull your dress down. You didn't want him seeing something that now belongs to his older brother. Andrew pulled his pants up but left his shirt open.
"Out of everyone, you choose him? I've been trying to get you to let me just touch you for the last two years and the moment our psychotic brother comes home from prison, you open your fucking legs." Baz spat out, Andrew stood up off the bed.
"Go away, Baz. I don't wanna hurt you." He tells him as nicely as he can. Not because he actually didn't wanna hurt his brother but because he didn't wanna scare you.
"Fuck you, Pope!" Baz shouted in his face.
"Yo! What the fuck is all the yelling about?" You all heard Craig from outside, coming over. He saw you on the bed with your hair all frizzy and your lips red, and Andrew's shirt and pants open. He was an idiot but not that dumb.
"Back off, man." He immediately said to Baz.
"You're okay with this?" He asked, Craig shrugged his shoulders.
"Don't be pissy 'cause it wasn't you. Go home to your wife." He answered, Baz scoffed.
"Un-fucking-believable." He cursed under his breath as he left but not before kicking a chair into the pool. Craig turned back to you and Andrew.
"You sure 'bout this?" He questions you, you nod your head with a smile.
"Alright..." He whispers before taking a step closer to his brother. "You hurt her, I'll fucking kill you. I don't care how big and scary you can be."
You chuckled quietly. That's very adorable. He was your best friend and he wanted nothing less than to protect you. You're very grateful for Craig, despite wanting to choke him out most days.
"I won't." Andrew whispers back, Craig nods. He turned to leave then stopped.
"Is that a bite mark on your neck?" He asked then held up his hand, "Forget I asked."
He was quick to run away.
"I don't think you're big and scary." You tell Andrew, he turns to you.
"No?" He asks as he comes back to you, you shake your head. He kisses you sweetly, pushing you back to lay back in the position you were caught in.
"Thank you."
Note: I hope you liked it!!! Maybe part 2?
ughhhh i NEED more of this dynamic SO BADđđđ love them togetherđĽş














