The thing i find so interesting about the idea of 'non-game aus' is what that changes for Gordon's character.
In a 'non game / sucked into game au', he's got the patience of a saint. Having to worry about about his life while the bamboozling bizzare bozos he travels with amp his stress up to 11.
Still an asshole, but you can argue his life was in danger and he was a normal human trying to survive while unwillingly babysitting four non-human entities who practically personify chaos.
Still an asshole, but god wouldn't anyone be? He gets betrayed, gets his arm CUT OFF, and has to keep stumbling around the hell site AND in 'sucked into the game aus' Coomer's ambush still makes sense.
But in a 'it's not a game aus' WHAT do you do with Coomer's ambush??? Like. It's an integral part of Coomer's character to become self aware. You could make him a robot, which i think works well, or just... like... does it for....???
But ANYWAY. This is about Gordon.
While in the its a game / canon .... he's a streamer. He was completely safe the entire time.
( now, there are aus where he sustains real damage from the game. I have made aus where The Player sustains damage from the game. But we're going with Gordon ' The Player ' Canon-man.
He was in no real damage ever. YES. I know NOW that in the vods The Player says at the start that he needs to act realistically or else the ai won't work properly.
But still. Obviously, the Science Team are still a whole hassle to try wrangle, but it's... different. He's not on their level, he's basically just... playing with them and their existence. NOW. Im not saying The Player doesn't care about the ai, but he's not in there with them. He's not in Black Mesa.
He can just pop off and get a snack if he wants, he gets to go sleep in his bed as the others sleep on the floor. He can't do anything to help them. But it's just... an interesting thing to think about.
Do I make sense?? It's the same character, same personality, same actions, but different perspectives.
Where Gordon is forced to suffer through hell. The Player chooses to come back to 'hell'.
Take in the door scene in act 1 part 2, no not the Benrey door scene. The one where GORDON goes under a closing door holding it for the others. It's a short moment that isn't important at all.
But take into account the two versions of Gordon's. And suddenly even that moment is different. It's weight is different. Not the weight of the moment specifically, but instead the weight of what that choice means.
If we look at it through a 'not a game au ' lens, it's Gordon literally putting himself under a door that cut another person IN HALF. Yes, yes Benrey wasn't a person, but that makes it WORSE. He was a non human in a bulletproof vest.
Gordon holds it up for ... give me sec- Bubby as it is ACTIVELY CLOSING AND THREATENING TO CRUSH HIM. As he says ' I can't hold it much longer ' and thats with Tommy helping him.
Though a ' not a game ' lens if he'd slipped, that could've crushed him. What if he slipped? Would the others have enough time to pull him - with the weight of his suit - out? Coomer's strong, yes, perhaps he would.
That's if he reacted fast enough. Tommy's got a great reaction speed, and he helped Gordon hold the door, but he can't let the door continue going down. That's result in a real Halved Life.- IM SORRY.
Ahem. BUTTTTT if we look at it through the ' its a game ' lens. It's still a showcase of care, just without the selflessness. The Player still did it basically instinctively, it was his instinct to go unde the door to hold it up for Bubby.
It shows he cares, if he didn't why would he bother? But he still needs to act like he's in pain, act like there's consequences, act like he's one of them. Even if he's not, he still cares.
But at the end of it all, he's the one who gets to walk away with no blood on his hands. He's the one who gets to walk away with no pain in his veins, agony in his bones, the sensation of being torn apart over and over.
He takes the choice to hear Coomer's plea, and ignore it. He may care for them, but are they worth all that trouble?
.... well, except for hlage. But im not talking about that.