“Potential” is a myth they tell children to encourage them to explore and develop their natural talents.
“Oh, you have a lovely singing voice. You could grow up to be like Mariah Carey!” they say. They do not say, “You could grow up to be like Edith Wisenhunt, lead singer at the Woodglenn Methodist Church in a town of 385 people,” although Edith may have Mariah Carey’s range.
“You are awesome at computers - you could grow up to be the next Bill Gates or Steve Jobs.” They do not say, “You could grow up to be a data-cruncher who changes jobs every 18 months when the startups that hire you dissolve.” They do not say “you could do payroll accounts for your local 7-11.”
“You are so good with people and teamwork - you could be a senator!” and not “You could be the team lead cashier at Safeway.”
“Potential” is a story about “famous people who have some of the same talents you do.” It is not “what you could actually do when you grow up.”
It’s a useful myth. For kids, everything is new and confusing. They know what they like, but not what they’re good at, because they have no mark of comparison other than their classmates. It’s useful for them to see a list of jobs - a list of people - that are related to their skills, so they can pick a direction, pick some things to practice.
Once they are adults - or even teenagers - they don’t need the “potential” story anymore. They can research for themselves what the career options are, what kind of life they could make if they work on the skills important to them.
They can seek a career in programming because they are good at computers - or they can decide they don’t like the options in programming and seek a career as a librarian. They can seek a career as an entertainer because they have a good voice and great dance skills - or they can decide that the entertainment industry is too fake for them, and become a teacher. They can hone their persuasion and teamwork talents and become a politician - or they can get a job in a mailroom, and coordinate their local under-10 sports league on the weekends.
“Potential” is not a list of achievements you should strive to make. Potential is a list of “some people with abilities that may have started like yours, have done these awesome things.”
I don’t think those things are awesome, or
Those are indeed awesome things, but I don’t want to do them.
And the “potential” stories that are about “I have seen you do X when you are deeply motivated and have all the resources you need, so you should be able to do X all the time and become like Famous Person” - those are pure bullshit.