Love this, and the points you’re making are quite true, in that he does love teaching. It’s the second part of the last line that I doubt, however.
This is from the end of ch 95 btw.
In this frame, he states that he’s taking the girls on a field trip. (In the English translation), he even calls himself their master! To me, this is not the vibe of a man who would not admit that he loves teaching.
Of course, the argument can be made that this is later in the manga, and recent events have shifted his perspective on the matter. However, there’s a panel from the same chapter at the top (39) that, in my eyes, reveals the real reason.
Here, Jujy has asked him why he wouldn’t take on an apprentice, and he says this:
Now, it’s important to note here that Olly is a Watchful Eye. And for all the skirting his job that he does do, there are instances where he puts his foot down. His debut wasn’t Like That ™ for nothing.
For several reasons (his childhood and being a prodigy, Qifrey’s shitfuckery against the Brims), he is quite pro-Pact. (Not to the levels of someone in the KM, say, but I’d say he’s one of the most conservative members of Qifrey’s Atelier). And I believe that’s what’s being referenced here.
And here comes the theory segment:
I believe that this is about to change in the coming arc. He’s facing dragons, he’s without Qifrey, tensions are rising, and people, including the atelier fam, are beginning to have doubts in the current PH system. I think something is going to happen in this arc that disproves what he said in 39.
And I don’t think he’ll be the only one.
I theorise as well that Agott is also going to slowly start to question and doubt the current system, but I think that for her, this will take longer.
Anyway, this was quite fun!
(PS: You mentioned him possibly taking on Tartah in the future, and I’d like to say that as he is right now, that’s not happening. Tartah is currently highly skeptical of the pact and pointed caps, enough to leave with the Brims. If my theories are correct, however… it could be discussed)