Who is A.D?

Ok I’m sold Bethany Young is Uber A. She’s back for revenge for everyone “killing” her that night.

Not ONCE has Marlene ever admitted to having seen AD more than once. Since forever, she was ALWAYS saying “you have seen AD before”. Now, after 7x11 has aired, she has finally expanded that and can say “more than twice”. WHAT CHANGED between 7x10 when it was “you’ve seen AD before” to 7x11 “more than twice”? WE MET KATHERINE DALY IN 7x11, THAT’S WHAT CHANGED!

First time: flashback in 6x10 Second, third, fourth time (how many scenes did she have?) : 7x11

A rough idea on her motives can be read here: https://thebestplltheories.tumblr.com/post/158288021343/new-pretty-little-liars-endgame-alternative

Although note, it appears Katherine does not have a deformed face as per the theory. Maybe that part isn’t true?

Obviously all of this could be wrong. But, after seeing Marlene’s tweet, we need to be prepared for Katherine/Bethany to be AD. Again, WHAT CHANGED - why has Marlene all of a sudden said “more than twice!?” SHE’S NEVER SAID THAT PRIOR TO 7x11.

THEY GAVE US A CLUE LAST NIGHT AND NO ONE HAS EVEN NOTICED. (Not complaining but a little surprised, tbh)

The Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare.

Emily and Aria found this play book inside of Archer/Elliott’s secret apartment…

We all remember the film adaption of The Twelfth Night with Amanda Bynes and Channing Tatum, right? Well, for those who don’t, I’ll explain.

The Twelfth Night is a play made into a movie about a girl, Viola, and her twin-brother Sebastian. In the movie version the character Viola (Amanda Bynes) switches places with her twin-brother and goes to college pretending to be him while he travels the world with his band. Viola is determined to prove to herself and to everybody else that girls can do anything a boy can do, if not better, so she joins the men’s soccer team as Sebastian. While pretending to be her brother she ends up falling for her/his roommate and teammate, Duke (Channing Tatum), which only further complicates her situation as she leads a double life. Eventually Viola’s real life brother Sebastian comes back home to school (without telling Viola of course) and messes up Viola’s cover. Sebastian ends up going to their final soccer match, as himself, with no idea how to play soccer. Viola sits back and watches him lose their match until she can’t take it anymore and at half time she confronts her brother and talks him into switching back places with her so she could play in the match as him. Long story short, the principal enters the soccer field near the end of the game and announces that he has suspicions that Sebastian is indeed a woman, which ends Viola’s little charade. She confesses that she was pretending to be her brother and they switch back to their normal lives, leaving Viola free to date Duke. 

Let’s connect that to our Pretty Little Liars world…

Could Cece and Wren be the real life version of Viola and Sebastian? 

Wren (Sebastian) left town to go to London while Cece (Viola) stayed in Rosewood to continue what he started, the A-game. When the Liars started getting closer and closer to A’s true identity, Charles Drake, Cece had no choice but to pretend to be her brother. So she let the Liars find her and she fed them her twin brothers story instead of her own. She lied that way her brother Wren/Charles would be free to carry out their master plan. 

She assumed the identity of her brother, Charles, in order to throw the Liars and everybody else off of his trail. The only problem was Elliott/Archer (Duke). Cece, still pretending to be Charlotte, accidentally fell in love with him. And who knows what she may have confided in him during those five years in Welby together…

If Cece and Wren ARE actually siblings/twins then that would also explain the recent picture that Huw Collins had posted on social media of himself and Julian Morris; Archer/Elliott and Wren could have been almost brother-in-laws.  And it’s possible that Archer is living out Cece’s part of the plan for Charles now that she’s dead. 

Archer Dunhill = A.D.

Charles Drake = Wren Kingston

Some of you probably remember I guessed 99.9% of the circumstances behind Charlotte / Cece and her reveal…

^^I left the sources in my screen shots for photo credit

So I was thinking about one of my favorite episodes, one where I was CERTAIN about Cece by this point. And I don’t choose to believe in coincidences, so, anyone else notice the similarities in the episode with Noel’s upcoming return?

**!! Both episode 9… !! **

In the Kahn game Cece claimed she was taking the girls to a party some of her old friends in high school were throwing.. Spencer HAD to be there. It could make or break her future with her college essay situation. And Cece said one of my favorite lines.. YOU’RE A HASTINGS… IF I COULD GET IN, YOU COULD GET IN.

It was obvious in this episode that Cece bad, major mood swings, was playing more than one side and knew a LOT more than what she let on.. She acted like she barely if at all knew that Noel and Jenna existed but she did.. And they were together with Emily “that night” and lied because of “mutually assured destruction.” Jenna stared straight at Cece when she said it.

This was an episode of major clues for me.. Noel said it best, in that episode.. “So many questions.. I wouldn’t mind a few answers.” They played the “game of truth.”

Also in that episode as shown in the photo Caleb said that quote about A. I remember; he pretended to be A (sent a text to Hanna) and at first Hanna went to SPENCER about it.. Which seems interesting considering their situation now.

Noel’s brother knew Cece really well, and it seems Noel knew her well enough too.. And Noel has secrets too. This is just a preview of the million clues that I think will surface in this episode. :) I’m not done but had to get the thought process started.

This is a timeline of A messages to show the change of hands from Mona (Original A) to Wilden (Big A) to CeCe (Black Veil) Further to my last post I believe Wilden and CeCe are the siblings from the Halloween story (fraternal twins?) and are continuing to fight over their dolls, Alison, and the liars. They are connected to the DiLaurentis’s and the question remains how. I think Wilden is Charles and he faked his death. They knew each other as children, the Drakes were perhaps the “Youngs” or relations of Kens. Bethany was their sister I think and the baby in the video. Jason and Charles/Wilden were close as children. I have a master post to come but these messages are what cemented my theory. Wilden was beach hottie and he and CeCe were competing for her time in Cape May, like a doll. 

Pics from PLL wiki

Hang in there, this is a long one!

Sent to Mona from Wilden (who was preparing to steal the game from her) her surprise was genuine. 

From Wilden to Mona

Police report written by Wilden (notice the writing) sticky note by Mona (notice the writing) about Hanna

Sent by Wilden to Mona, foreshadowing the change of A Game hands. She knew he was closing in on her.

“Show Me Your Boobs” This is thought to be Anonymous but who knows it could have been Wilden

 “Mona played with dolls. I play with body parts. Game on, bitches. –A” This was Wilden, his way of announcing he took the game from Mona,

Sent to Aria warning her to tell her Dad about trashing his office or he will tell the police about her affair with Ezra. (I think this is around the time when Wilden started to blackmail Ezra into working with him to get information) 

“Daddy needs to know. Or I let the other one go. To the police. ‘Night-night. – A” (Sent From Wilden)

“DEAD GIRLS CANT SMILE” on the teeth from Bethany’s Grave (Wilden)

“Imagine what I could do with fifty grand. – A” This is from Wilden in response to the reward money Jason posted for the return of Alison’s body

I’m everywhere, Hanna – A (Sent from Wilden to his favourite person to pick on Hanna) This accident I believe was actually caused by Melissa or Wren (the vodka soda) who was working for him either by choice or blackmail. It was her laptop shown at the airport lounge.

“Hey Spence, I have one more surprise for you. Garrett isn’t their killer. – A” This was Wilden. In this episode Spencer ran into Wilden at the hospital where she was spying on Garrett and his mother.

This one should have been obvious in hindsight. It was Wilden mocking Hanna because he put the Ouija board in her house (of course he could get in there, was very familiar with it) He has showed up at her house telling her he would in regards to the blood found on Alison’s anklet. 

“SEE HOW EASY IT IS FOR ME TO GET YOUR BLOOD?” (A is circled)

Sent from Wilden to Spencer, Emily and Aria regarding Radley’s plan to move Mona to another institution. Wilden wanted him gone but Wren intervened getting  Hanna to advocate for her. This did not go over well with Wilden.

Mona’s almost gone. Hanna’s next. – A

Sent from Wilden to Paige. He had Lyndon James grab her and take her to that cabin. I think he was blackmailing him over the Maya situation. (He was stalking her) 

10PM Saturday Rosewood Cemetery or Emily gets hurt. – A

Stand down, bitches. Play it my way and Emily stays safe. – A

Sent by Wilden to Aria, Hanna and Spencer warning them not to interfere with the Paige/Emily/Lyndon situation. I think he wanted Lyndon to kill Paige because she was trying to find out who he was.

Let’s settle this. Alison’s grave. 10 pm. Bring Maya’s bag. -A Sent by Wilden demanding they bring Maya’s bag. He attached a pic of the body bag threatening to reveal Emily’s roll in the grave digging if they did not.

Digitally altered phone call from Wilden warning Emily to get out (he never intended for her to get hurt) before Lyndon killed Paige. 

“You have one minute… GET OUT!

(Phone call - digitally altered voice) Emily, I owe you one. He was glad to have Lyndon out of the way because he had seen Jenna the night the grave was dug and they knew they had a witness. He was now out of the way.

Sent from Wilden to Hanna on the Halloween train who had just had Garrett killed and had locked Aria in the box with him. 

Put outside Ezra’s apartment by Wilden for Aria

Warning Aria (Wilden) to tell Ezra about his son.

Wilden left a message in the diary for the liars to see after the pages were ripped out. 

Sent by Wilden to Spencer in regards to the debate team competition for captain (against Mona…..but have been Mona though)

Sent to Hanna (form Wilden) taunting her about giving Mona the cold shoulder reminding her how sadistic he is (with body parts)

Sent by Wilden (Or Toby) after the incident with the mannequins. 

Sent by Wilden pretending to be Aria getting her to cause trouble and tell Ezra about his son before Aria did. I think Wilden was ticked off that Ezra was distracted and wanted to cause a rift with Aria and Ezra.

Sent by Wilden to Aria

Sent by Wilden to Emily. The postcards were in the casket so he had possession of them. They may have been translated by CeCe who knows French, or Mona.

In English: Stop digging! The police already know it’s you that’s capable of murder!

Sent by Wilden to Spencer warning her not to tell about Toby’s involvement in the A Game. I think the distinct T’s are meant to be Wilden, not just a production thing. Mona’s writing is very different.

Sent to Emily by Wilden after he covered Jason’s porch in Whiskey bottles.

This was Melissa or Toby in retaliation for the Wren kiss

This was Mona, directed by Wilden for telling the liars about Toby.

This is to Emily to Toby at the construction site (dollhouse?) I think this was Wilden because of the writing.

Mona, this was her Radley room and she could get in and out easily. May have been Wren.

From Wilden to Hanna in regards to her Mom hitting him with her car.

From Spencer to Aria. Spencer took Ezra’s son to the carnival.

Sent by Wilden or Toby to Jenna about the lodge fire plans.

Sent by CeCe after she killed Wilden (or did she….) She now had possession of the dolls from her brother Wilden, check mate)

This is obviously not a complete list of A messages, I will be making a larger post but it helps show how the game changed hands twice and how Wilden, Mona and CeCe are involved.

I submit that Ezra, Wren, Melissa, Jenna, Shana, Lucas, Andrew and Jason have all been manipulated by Wilden and CeCe in this game. Once my master post is complete I will show how they are all involved. 

Thanks for sticking this crazy post out, I know it is a long one! More on this soon.

PS Wilden is alive If you don’t think A can fake his own death (he faked Mona’s) when he is controlling everyone around him….well he had to, to throw CeCe off her game and then take it back to get the liars into his very own dollhouse.

NOTE: RE-BLOGGING THIS POST FROM ME WILL ENSURE THE MOST RECENT AND UP TO DATE POST. I AM CONSTANTLY EDITING AND UPDATING THIS WITH MORE QUESTIONS (AND ANSWERS WHEN WE GET THEM), so whilst it’s great you share it around (please do!), please remember that I AM THE ONE EDITING so check back to THIS post for the edits! Here are (what started out to be) 50 questions across all seasons that have not been answered and still need to be answered before the series finale (7x20). 

At the end of every episode of season 7, I will re-blog this and update it with answers. I quote Marlene: “reveals on a week by week basis” for season 7. 

Please get involved in this too! Send me questions I missed, or answers I haven’t updated yet! This is a group effort that we will all contribute to; crossing these off for this final season!

Here’s to hoping that we can cross off all of these by the end!!

Extremely obvious questions that we WILL get answers to, definitely, are first. Who is Uber A/AD?

We know Uber A became A to avenge Charlotte’s death. Why is Charlotte’s death so important to this person? What was their relationship?

What are Mary and Rollins up to?

Who killed Charlotte? Why isn’t Uber A attacking THAT person? Why attack the liars over this?

Who killed Jessica?

Rollins says he married Ali so that he can avenge Charlotte’s death, but he was already seducing Ali before Charlotte had even died. This makes no sense. Clearly, there is an ulterior motive here.

What’s up with Rollins and Charlotte being a thing? When and why? Rollins was into Ali and Charlotte?

Everything about Bethany Young. Why haven’t we seen her face, how was she identified as Alison in the grave all those years ago, why did Jessica want her to call her Aunt Jessy, why was she in Radley, etc. I think I have all these answers as per my master theory (check blog description for a link to the theory), but it does need to be confirmed in the show.

Which boy pulled a gun on Ali? (flashback in 4x11) Is this important or irrelevant?

Why was Wren colouring in a red coat?

Is there a reason Eddie recognised Aria at Radley, or was that just a friendly coincidence?

“We’re not having the same problems again, are we Eddie?” said Wren. Then Eddie said “from the minute that guy got here, it wasn’t for the right reasons”. What is going on between Wren and Eddie?

“We have a problem, you take care of your end and I’ll take care of my end.” - Wren. Explain please, Marlene.

Who was in Jason’s house in season 2? Remember we saw a shadow and blood in the trash.

Why was Jessica at Aunt Carol’s house and who was she hiding in the house? Remember how Jason heard noises from inside. What if this wasn’t Jessica at Aunt Carol’s house, but was Mary, hiding Rollins inside?

Are they ever going to address the fact that Rollins was Mona’s doctor in Radley too? Is this significant or not?

Who attacked Ali at Halloween? I don’t think this was Mona. I would LOVE it if this was AD, and AD was the original attacker who started it all.   

Marlene tweeted recently that there might be more to the Maya storyline. I hope this is in relation to Miss Aria You’re A Killer Not Ezra’s Wife (Maya Knew). [I would just like to point out the foreshadowing there to Aria killing Shana!] I don’t like Marlene’s answer that Maya knew Nate was in Rosewood. What did Maya know!?

Where is Eddie!!? We last saw him delivering a drawing made by Bethany - next day he’s gone. Clearly, there is a mystery surrounding Bethany.

Who was the man and woman in the doll shop in 2x24 that wanted to hurt Ali, that “Seth-baby” was talking about? Mary and Rollins?

My biggest question: if CeCe was a patient at Radley, why did she need a visitor’s pass? This can be answered if they reveal that CeCe lied in 6x10, and Jessica never took her back to Radley after Charles’ funeral. She said she went back to Radley to add to her sob-story but instead was roaming the streets of Radley becoming A. 

Why were members of the NAT club slowing being killed? What is up with that club? Such an awesome storyline from season 1 that was just randomly dropped. I hope they can continue this, and say that maybe the NAT club caught Mary Drake on tape, and she began killing members who saw her.

Which brings the next question: where has Mary been all this time? Why are we only hearing of her 6 seasons later? 

Did CeCe know she was adopted? She must have known, since she chose the name CeCe DRAKE, obviously using her mother’s name. So then why did she lie to Ali in 6x10 about being sisters? Her whole motive for being A was to bring Ali home safely because she missed her sister; so is there another motive she hadn’t told us given they’re not actually sisters but cousins?

Sara Harvey!? Everything about her needs to be answered. Obviously, in particular, why she helped CeCe, and what she was doing in 6B staying in CeCe’s old room at Radley (and also the big hole in her room). She’s doing some investigating of her own, but why? And is she really that angry at the liars for being electrocuted? That wasn’t the liars’ fault!

Jason says he saw CeCe that night, but CeCe said that wasn’t her. Jason clearly saw someone but just got the face wrong. His eyesight was blurry, but it wasn’t making stuff up that wasn’t there. Who was Melissa talking to!?

Who was the person in the baseball cap who was talking to Melissa in 5B, that Spencer caught on her camera?

Why even tell us that Andrew is adopted? I hope the answer is not because they wanted us to think he was Charles, and that’s all.

Why did Lucas and Jenna go to prom together? What’s going on there?

Why did Leslie have 765432 pairs of glasses?

How was CeCe listed as Prom Queen if she didn’t even go to the school? Marlene, don’t tell me she just hacked the school’s system.

Wilden was paid off by Jessica to keep quiet about what Charlotte did to Ali. So then why was he so determined to pin it on the liars in season 1 if he already knew the answer? Maybe he was trying to frame someone else so that he can let his guilty conscience go free? Or did he not know what Charlotte did to Ali? Surely he could’ve put two and two together: someone is paying me to say CeCe wasn’t in Rosewood, on the same night a murder took place!? So what’s up with the “rest assured, I will find out what happened that summer”!? He already knew!?

The Sydney Driscol storyline went absolutely no where. Remember how they were making us think she is Jenna’s twin/sister? Why!?

Who was the fourth person to the picnic with Jenna, Sydney and Mona? What were they discussing?

What is Ali’s sexuality? She is married to Rollins so we can assume straight or bi. But does she have feelings for Emily?

Rhys Matthews. What was his purpose in the show? They went through a lot of effort to cast a Jason-look-alike.

Mona killed Bethany and had no punishments?

Who put the “Chandelier’s Rituals, sister launched lair, A ruler’s list chained” note in Mona’s room? This is an anagram to Charles DiLaurentis, BUT, do the individual words have meaning too? SISTER launched lair is intriguing, given we know there’s a twin SISTER now.

“You know me Spencer, you killed me”. Why did CeCe send this note to Spencer? Makes no sense. It almost seems like CeCe was forcing Spencer to believe she killed Ali or Bethany. But why was that her plan?

There was a continual theme of A loving Aria’s pink hair. This seems odd now knowing it is CeCe. The only person who loved Aria’s pink hair was Jason, and he’s not A? A tiny detail, but I hate inconsistencies.

Why was Melissa helping Jenna and Shana that night at the lodge? Are we supposed to believe what she said in 404 that she was just there spying on them to protect Spencer? It’s not “spying” if you’re working with the enemy.

How the hell did CeCe get the vials of blood in Spencer’s bag in London? This just screams Wren to me.

Not to mention the British spelling of “Nosey Bitches Die”? Why did Mona spell it like that?

Who burnt Cyrus? WHY? What even happened to Cyrus? What was his purpose on the show?

Marlene, please clarify the whole Varjack thing. I got NO idea. Was that CeCe? Why use that name? Ugh I don’t get it. This is actually a mess and an embarrassment on the writer’s behalf to start a storyline like this and INSTANTLY drop it within one episode.

“One of you has been touched by the one Alison feared the most”. This can’t be in reference to Aria and Ezra, because Alison didn’t fear Ezra. Was it in reference to Aria and CeCe/A who literally just touched each other half a minute ago (when Aria grabbed onto CeCe to prevent her from falling)? I think this is the answer, but I’d love a confirmation. (Probably on Twitter, Marlene, it would be awkward to raise this conversation back into the show after a 5 year time jump).

Ghost girl in Hanna’s house in 3x13? I don’t like Supernatural stuff. This needs to be explained.

Is there a reason, or story-line application of Alison’s twin story she told in 2x12? Mary and Jessica? Did one stab the other and send her to a mental asylum; Radley, like in her story?

Was the Radley car outside the DiLaurentis home in 2x12 for Mary?

Who killed Mrs. Potter and WHY? That’s so damn random.

Is there a reason Wilden had 2 passports and no personal effects in his apartment?

Jason spoke to someone on the phone saying “meet me in the parking lot in 15 minutes”, and is seen writing a check for $50,000. Then Wilden shows up. Did Jason give that money to Wilden? WHY? Did Wilden have Ali’s remains (that’s what Jason was asking for to get the money). 

Why was Bethany wearing an Alison bracelet when she died? Someone clearly went to extreme efforts to make sure Bethany looks like Ali. Further, how was she mis-identified as Ali? Are their DNA similar? It’s possible if Bethany is Mary’s other daughter.  Or, was someone on the police force altering the reports?

    After finishing Season 6B of Pretty Little Liars, I feel fairly confident in saying that Lucas is the mysterious Uber A who has been tormenting the Liars. I’ve been following his clues throughout the season and he is the suspect who makes the most sense to me with Uber A’s actions so far. I’ll go through the episodes of 6B a bit and show how I developed the theory as the season went on. Without further ado, let’s get started.

    I don’t have too much from 6x11 or 6x12 since those were before Lucas reappeared and before I began suspecting him, however there is one obvious clue from these episodes: Uber A’s car. We see Uber A twice in these episodes, once at Charlotte’s funeral and once at Charlotte’s grave. Both times Uber A is in a limo. The fact that Uber A’s favored mode of transportation is a limo instantly shows us that Uber A is someone with plenty of money if they are always able to afford a limo. When Lucas returns, we find out that he is now very wealthy, which means he can definitely afford a limo. But why does Uber A need a limo? The first thought would be that it is someone who can’t drive and needs a driver to drive them around. However the only character who might fit this is Sara Harvey, but Emily sees her driving her own car in 6x19 which means she is perfectly capable of driving. The other reason Uber A might need a limo is for anonymity. This brings me back to Lucas. On 6x13 Hanna noticed Lucas’s silver Jaguar outside of the Brew before she even knew it was his, which shows that Lucas’s expensive car stands out pretty well. If it stands out parked on the street, just imagine how much it would stand out while stalking the Liars. Instead, by driving around in a generic limo, he does not stand out so much and prevents the risk of being immediately recognized by his own car. Lucas has the most reason to get around in a car other than his own because it enables him to avoid detection.

    Let’s move onto the events of 6x13, the episode where Lucas reappears and the episode where I began suspecting him. It’s an interesting coincidence that we see Uber A’s first message on the same episode that Lucas first comes back. It gets even more interesting in the context of Lucas’s role in the episode. Uber A’s first message “You know who did it and I’m going to make you talk” shows that Uber A has reason to suspect that the liars have information regarding Charlotte’s death and since this is when he sent his first message, it means he probably just recently gained information causing him to suspect them. This is the episode where Hanna asks Lucas to lie about his whereabouts and be her alibi, but she never tells him why she and her friends need an alibi. This means that Lucas, just like Uber A, has reason to suspect that the Liars know more about the night Charlotte died than they are telling people. Additionally, the timeline of Lucas learning the Liars syncs up with when Uber A would have likely learned that information considering the first text is sent shortly afterward. Another clue from the fact that Lucas was able to be Hanna’s alibi is that it confirms he has been in Rosewood since Charlotte’s death. This means that he was in Rosewood at the right time to have been the mysterious person in the limo at Charlotte’s funeral and gravesite. Not to mention, Lucas was pretty personally effected by the A game too both with his involvement in early Season 3 and his involvement with Mona around the time she was kidnapped. Even though Charlotte had a personal effect on him, he was nowhere to be seen at her funeral. Maybe he just didn’t care to go, but this could be further evidence that he was really the one in the limo at the end since we know he was in town and yet he was absent.

    Another point of interest is Lucas’s apartment. It was very generous for him to just give it away to Hanna and I think he may have had an ulterior motive for doing it. I’ll talk more about it later, but multiple times Uber A has had knowledge from private conversations the Liars had in Lucas’s apartment. I think he may have bugged it with recording devices and then given it to Hanna so that he can spy on the Liars’ private conversations. This explains how Uber A knows so much information about the Liars. It also serves a bit of a narrative purpose if Lucas is A. Even though he is not on every episode, we won’t forget about him because we see his apartment every single episode. This is a way for the producers to make Uber A a character who does not appear as often as others do because even when he does not appear, his presence is not forgotten.

    The clues got even more interesting in 6x14. First, there was a random scene of Uber A taking pictures of Spencer from a car. This scene seems to have no point since we never see A’s pictures and there is no further reference to them. However, they included this scene for some reason so I think its purpose is as a clue. The character who has been most associated with photography is Aria, however it doesn’t really make any sense for her to be Uber A since she has been in the same place as Uber A multiple times already. Let’s not forget that Lucas previously worked as a photographer’s assistant. This seemingly unimportant scene of A photographing Spencer could really be a clever hint about Lucas’s past connection with photography.

    Also in 6x14, Uber A sends the Liars the picture of the nine iron and they recognize the background as the floor of a room in the Radley Hotel. So why was Uber A living in the Radley Hotel instead of a permanent residence? This means Uber A is not a natural resident of Rosewood anymore because he was living in a hotel room. But what is even more interesting is the fact that Uber A is living in a hotel the very episode after Lucas gives away his apartment to Hanna.  The hotel isn’t a very permanent lair and seems more like a place A would stay at while looking for a new place to make a lair, which means Uber A had probably just recently lost a place to live and Lucas is the only character who recently lost his only place to live in Rosewood (Technically he could live with his parents but he was supposed to be out of Rosewood and that wouldn’t provide much subtlety for him).

    Uber A’s choice of costume is also interesting. As his message said, he is “hiding in plain sight”. But why does A need to stay hidden in plain sight, such as at the election event at the hotel at the end of 6x14, which was a public event with a lot of people present. The only real reason I can think of that A would need to be disguised at a public event like that is if it is someone who is not supposed to be in Rosewood and is pretending to be out of town. The only characters who had appeared already and were supposed to be out of town were Lucas, Ali, and Rollins (I can’t remember if Melissa had already left for London or not, but she may have been out of town then too). However, Ali and Rollins were away together and referenced their trip in private on a later episode, so neither of them could have been in Rosewood without the other knowing. So this means the only character who was supposed to be out of town and would need to be hidden in a public place was Lucas, and possibly maybe Melissa if she was already supposed to be in London then. Either way, it is not a very big list.

    It gets interesting with Emily’s eggs storyline because Uber A has to be someone who knows that Emily is donating her eggs. The other Liars knew about it, but it seems pretty unlikely for any of them to be Uber A at this point. Ali and Rollins were both aware of what Emily was doing from when they came by the apartment, but they were both out of town at the time when Uber A was walking around in the old man mask. This leaves one other possibility for who would have know about Emily’s eggs. She was staying in Lucas’s apartment at the time and had her conversation with Rollins about the eggs inside of Lucas’s apartment. If my earlier theory about Lucas bugging the apartment is true, he would have been able to overhear everything about Emily donating her eggs and he would have had specific information about where she was donating them so he would know where to steal them. Additionally, A shut down the technology at the egg storing place in order to steal them which suggests he has some pretty good technology skills to be able to pull that off and we know that Lucas owns a tech company. Lucas appears to be the only character with the knowledge and ability to steal Emily’s eggs.

    Uber A also seems to have a fixation on Hanna’s fiancé Jordan. In the middle part of the season, A made multiple threats to hurt Jordan if Hanna did not listen. This is what began to drive a wedge between them and caused Hanna to grow more distant from Jordan. However, A did not do anything to drive Aria away from Liam or Spencer away from Caleb (Maybe the election leak, but A did not actually take credit for that so I am not convinced that A was responsible yet). This special focus on Hanna and Jordan’s relationship makes me think A is someone who wants to break them up and who would want that more than Lucas, who is still single and definitely seems to still have feelings for Hanna. Also, Uber A’s first act of direct violence against the Liars was with the fire at Hanna’s wedding shower. Could this sudden lashing out be related to anger Lucas might have about Hanna’s wedding? He should have finally had his chance with her once she broke up with Caleb, yet he finds out that she has already moved on and is engaged to another guy. This would definitely make him upset and could cause him to lash out at Hanna’s wedding shower as A did. Another clue that Lucas orchestrated the wedding shower attack is the fact that it used the technology in his loft. He would have both the familiarity with the system and the technical skills necessary to orchestrate the attack with a universal remote.

    Lucas’s second appearance in 6x19 also had some interesting clues about him. First, he does not seem at all concerned that A just lit a giant fire in his apartment. Wouldn’t he at least be a little upset or even worried about it happening again? Of course if he was the one who caused the fire, he would have no cause to be upset over it. Then  we find out that he just purchased an abandoned factory with his company’s money, which to me sounds like the perfect spot for A’s new lair. He also makes a comment about how he could “give Rosewood a second chance”. Aside from just sounding pretty creepy, this comment also suggests that he still has some bitter feelings toward the town and could want to get some revenge as A. Finally, at the end of the episode, A is seen sitting at a table completely covered with electronic devices. Lucas is the only character other than Caleb who we know works in a technology field so it makes the most sense for him to be the one who would use all of those electronic devices.

    The final nail in the coffin for me was how A kidnapped Hanna from the Lost Woods resort. Hanna did not tell A the meeting location until she was in position, so he would not gave had enough time to dig a tunnel under the hotel before she was kidnapped. This means the Uber A had to have knowledge of Hanna’s plan beforehand in order to have enough time to tunnel under the hotel and set up the trapdoor to kidnap her. The only people who knew about the plan ahead of time were the liars and the boyfriends; however, all of them were already occupied when Hanna was kidnapped. Mary Drake was on the footage outside of the hotel, so couldn’t have kidnapped Hanna from the inside. Since Mary and Elliot did not mention kidnapping Charlotte’s supposed killer in their conversation about how much they love her, I doubt Rollins was also at the lodge because they seemingly would have mentioned it in that case. This means that all of the people with knowledge of the plan were occupied and their possible accomplices couldn’t have done the kidnapping, so who could have done it? This brings me back to the idea that Lucas’s apartment is bugged. When looking at 6x19 and 6x20, Hanna and Caleb pretty much did all of their planning in Lucas’s apartment which means he would know every detail of their plan and would know to dig a tunnel ahead of time. This is the only scenario I can think of where a character would both have the means to learn of the plan so far in advance and also have the availability to kidnap Hanna.

    The only piece I haven’t explained yet is why would Lucas avenge Charlotte and why would Mary Drake work with him? (Marlene confirmed Mary is working with Uber A) I think the key to both of these questions lies in the final text message of 6B, which was signed by AD. Marlene has confirmed that AD is Uber A, so it must stand for something important. My main thought is that the D stands for Drake, meaning Mary had another child. I originally thought Uber A would be Charlotte’s secret boyfriend, who would be Lucas, but that doesn’t work anymore now that Rollins is her secret boyfriend. But the other connection that could drive someone to get revenge for Charlotte is a family connection. This is why I believe Lucas’s real name is not Lucas Gottesman, but A Drake (The A could be any male name probably something like Aiden or Alex). This gives Lucas a motive to avenge Charlotte and could also explain why he is working with Mary. Marlene said that Mary is the true villain of PLL, but since she isn’t Uber A maybe she is the puppet master giving commands to Uber A. If this is true, then it makes a lot of sense for a mother to be ordering her son around. Lucas was seen visiting Mona in Radley toward the beginning of Season 3, so maybe he met his sister and mother while he was there and learned his true identity. He never liked Ali and was already doing some work for the A team, so what if he just made Mona think he was only on the A team because he was being blackmailed and was really in on it all along helping Charlotte. Lucas has always been involved in the A team. Back on 2x13 he was in the same costume as Ali’s attacker and the first A sending her messages. Also, he was helping Mona back when she was A by giving Emily’s massage. He was involved again once Charlotte took over and if he was only a minor member, why did Toby try to run him over? Even though it wasn’t a real A group, he was also involved in Mona’s anti-Ali group. Lucas has always been involved in sketchy groups and the evidence seems to indicate he is still involved, but now he is the one behind the texts.

“It used to be easier to tell us apart”

“I thought she was Alison”

We’ve never seen Bethany’s face…

Is it because this is what she looks like?

Maybe Bethany didn’t die that night. Maybe Sara wasn’t the only one in a redcoat. (This explains the gaps in the redcoat timeline)

Bethany was sent to Radley, while Hanna was adopted by Ashley Marin. (Not saying these twins are them more like symbolically)

When this episode first aired the DNA comment screamed suspicious to me. Yes I could be overthinking it, but at the time we were nearing the finale and this stood out to me as a possible clue towards adoption/twin theory. Hanna being adopted could also explain why her father is so distant from her.

See Hanna has the life Bethany never did.

We know Bethany has some self image issues…

Which is another reason why she’s jealous of her sister

Who she keeps an eye on…

With some help from Mona.

No you didn’t Mona, you’re still protecting her.

Mona called Charlotte from the Two Crows the night she was released.

To either 1) lure her to the church for Bethany  2) to warn her about Bethany

Whether her plan worked, or she was too late, Charlotte ended up at the Church.

Where Bethany killed her, and started her plan to frame Melissa…

For burying her alive “That Night”

But if Mona didn’t hit Bethany who did?

The girls did. Either Spencer alone or the rest of them together. This is how the main girls are linked to that night and the story.

Alison wants Charlotte’s killer brought to justice…

Shade is thrown at Hanna, but it’s not her, but someone who looks exactly like her.

Her twin sister. There’s a reason it’s always been Hanna with the twin hints.

It’s the show’s homage to the books, instead of Alison & Courtney we have Hanna & Bethany.

See I think Charlotte was telling the truth, and Bethany is bat-shit crazy, just like the evil twin from the book. But why has she laid pretty low this whole time? Because she was finally free from Radley. Everyone believed Bethany was dead, meaning she wouldn’t be trapped or brought back to Radley any longer. Bethany finally had a good reason to come back out of hiding when Charlotte was released from Radley, to kill her.

Bethany could have been simultaneously messing with the girls at the same time as Charlotte, passing info on to her “allies” like Jenna & Shanna, who set the fire in 3x24; where Hanna was conveniently left to burn.

There’s this obsession on the show with blondes, specifically blonde twins. I don’t think they’re going to go with Alison, but the next blonde who we’re more familiar with, Hanna.

We all know this scene from 1x11, where Alison visits Hanna at the hospital. The upcoming episode of 6b is titled “did you miss me?”, and this time Alison is in the hospital. I think she’s going to see “Hanna” do the same thing. Except it will really be Bethany.  Alison will see Hanna after and decide she hallucinated the whole thing. This will be hinting to the viewers about Bethany, but they won’t confirm she was actually there, just like with Alison during 1x11. (This is all a guess lol (my hopes))

For an added bonus, Mona and Bethany’s friendship could date back to however long ago. Bethany could have been the one telling Mona what to do, or at least influencing her.

Maybe, just maybe Bethany mowed down her sister Hanna, and Mona took the blame for it to protect her once again when she was revealed as A.

Despite all the talk about 6B being a bit slow moving, we are now onto our second false flag murder weapon of the season!  Woot!  Anyone with a rolling suitcase has probably spent the last few days wondering how a suitcase part so flimsy that it frequently gets dented out of shape in the course of being a checked bag could possibly be used to kill someone.  (Unless in a fit of white hot airport rage after your fifth cancelled flight - but even then, it would take time to break or dismantle the bag, giving the lady who didn’t take off her shoes and really wanted to hang onto her Dr. Pepper in the security line plenty of time to flee.)  My guess is that it’s not going to be the murder weapon, but it might be important in a different way.

We know that Jessica’s death, although it hasn’t resurfaced yet in 6B, is one of the mysteries that needs to be wrapped up before the end of the show, right?  

Remember back in Unbridled, when Spencer and the finger bones in her corset saw Jessica handing something that looked like a suitcase to a hooded figure in the woods?

This picture is really dark, but I just learned how to do screen grabs, so.

We know this person wasn’t Charlotte, as Charlotte’s account in the 6A finale makes it clear she hadn’t seen Jessica since accidentally not-murdering Alison.

And who shows up later that same episode, wheeling her rolling suitcase into the frame?

Hi Melissa!  How was your flight in from the woods?

It’s Melissa!  Making an unannounced return from “London” because she’s heard there’s trouble on the home front!  This is right after Toby has gone to London to advise Melissa of the latest Spencer-related crisis, and comes back with a report that although he saw Wren, Melissa herself was nowhere to be found.  (Why Toby hopped on an expensive transatlantic flight rather than calling, emailing, or texting Melissa is a mystery unto itself.  But his Caveman logic is not like my logic, so we’ll let that one slide.)

Let’s speculate, for a moment, that Melissa was not in London.  Let’s say she was in Rosewood, but staying out of sight for Melissa-ish reasons of her own. Let’s consider whether Melissa might have been the person to pick up the suitcase drop from Jessica.

The very next episode is Jessica’s (black?) swan song.

Died, still waiting for Emison.

She’s killed in the #fatal finale, and buried next to the azaleas.

Fast forward though Ali’s return, Mona’s fake murder, Ali’s stint in the hoosegow. the Liar’s time in the Doll House, one million showers taken by Sara Harvey, and the reveal that Jessica abandoned her oldest daughter to a mental health asylum for being transgender - and here we are in 6B, with Charlotte dead and the police looking for a rectangular metal weapon, hollow at the end, that might have been used to strike Charlotte before she was strangled and tossed off the bell tower.

And what does Spencelock Holmes suddenly come across?

Melissa’s packing list: NAT club videos, mascara, grudges.

The conveniently broken suitcase of her sister, Melissa!  I mean, it’s heavy carting around a zillion plaster masks of your face all the time and they just don’t make murder bags like they used to.

Now, before anyone goes down the rabbit hole of whether these two suitcases look alike - or enough alike to be the same bag - I say to you: red coat vs. red robe.  And I say also, remember how Melissa must have had the same computer since high school in order for Spencer to have swiped her Russian history paper in the very first season.  The important thing is that they are both scripted as Melissa’s suitcase, and I think that’s connection enough.

One of the suitcase rods is broken off and missing - cue ominous music - and the handle detaches, revealing that it would be a rectangular piece of metal, hollow on the end!

Does this suitcase look innocent to you?

We believe, from the previews for next week, that someone wants the missing suitcase rod enough to go after Emily for it.  And why would they do that, if it’s not the actual murder weapon?  I’m thinking we should not overlook the part where the rod is hollow, and the suitcase may have come from Jessica.  We know Ali is great at finding hiding places for things, could that be a skill she inherited/learned from her mother?  Could important information or a big clue of some kind have been concealed in the hollow rod of the bag?  Papers?  A flash drive?  An indication of who Jessica was afraid of before she died?  A message that Melissa was supposed to give to someone, possibly Cece?  (Cece herself was arrested shortly after this episode, and then fled to Paris, so if Melissa was directed to pass something along, she might not have been able to complete that part of the mission.)  Something that would explain Jessica’s connection to Bethany, and/or the identity of Bethany’s father who Jessica allegedly had an affair with?  Something that would prove the existence of an Uber ‘A’? 

That’s my guess for where this is going: something was concealed in the hollow suitcase rod that jump starts the wrap up of the Jessica mystery.  When is a suitcase rod not a suitcase rod?  When it’s a hiding place for Jessica’s secrets.

“I don’t lurk in the shadows, I hide in plain sight”. (6x14 Promo) Maybe referring that A is someone we see every single episode?

Also that’s a quote from Belle Aurora, RAW Family #1. Here is the synopsis.

Growing up the way I did, you’d think I’d be more screwed up than what I actually am. Soon as I turned sixteen, I left that bump in the road I called home and took my chances on the street. Best decision I ever made. Now, at the age of twenty six, I’m educated, employed and damn good at my job. My friends have become my family. Like me, they know what it’s like to grow up unloved. But the saying is true. The world makes way for those who know where they are going. That’s me. I know where I’m going and I’ll get there eventually. On my own terms and at my own pace. But then there’s him. I feel his eyes on me. I see him hiding in plain sight. He watches me. He makes me feel. It’s unconventional. But it’s real. I’m sure you’re wondering how a person falls in love with their stalker. So am I. This isn’t a story. This is my life.