Part 2: Still loving a dead man
Pairing: Jason todd:/Red hood x reader
Synopsis: 16 August is Jason’s birthday. Every year, that day comes round like a wound that refuses to heal. You tried to move on, to build something new with someone decent, and you almost believed it would work. But some ghosts just won’t stay quietly in their graves.
Warnings: angst, grief, mentions of death
The alley smelled like rain and rust.
You hadn't meant to take that route. It was a shortcut, the kind you'd taken a hundred times before without thinking, because Gotham at night had never really frightened you, not after years of patrol, not after everything. But tonight your mind was somewhere else entirely, turning over the same thoughts it always did on this day, and you weren't paying attention.
You heard them before you saw them.
Three of them, stepping out of the shadows with the unhurried confidence of people who had done this before. You had just enough time to register the situation before the first one moved toward you.
What happened next was fast and brutal and not at all what they expected.
But there were three of them, and you were tired, and it had been a long day of remembering someone who wasn't there anymore. By the time the second one grabbed your arm, you knew you were in trouble.
Then something hit the wall beside you like a thunderclap, and the alley went very quiet.
He was already standing over the last one when you looked up. Red helmet, broad shoulders, two guns holstered at his sides. He said nothing. He didn't even look at you right away, just scanned the alley with the practiced calm of someone for whom this was Tuesday.
His voice was low, rougher than it needed to be, like he was used to making it sound like a warning.
"I'm fine," you said, which was mostly true.
He looked at you for a second longer than necessary. Then he was gone, up the fire escape and into the dark, before you could say anything else.
You stood alone in the alley for a long moment, heart still hammering, and told yourself the strange feeling in your chest was just adrenaline.
The Batcave was quiet when you found it, or rather, when it found you, the way it always did when something was wrong and your feet carried you there without asking your brain first.
The screen was already on.
Red Hood. That was what the file said. Vigilante, operating out of Gotham's East End. Extensive criminal record, the criminal kind, not the Bat-family kind, though the line was blurry. Known for lethal methods. Considered dangerous by the GCPD and, apparently, by Bruce, whose notes in the margin of the file were terse in the way that meant he was worried.
You stared at the footage for a long time. The way he moved. The way he'd stood over those men in the alley without a flicker of hesitation.
You thought about the way he'd said "you good" like it was the only thing he knew how to offer.
Luke was already on the couch when you got back, the television murmuring in the background. You dropped your jacket on the chair and folded yourself into the space beside him, and he shifted automatically to make room, his arm coming around your shoulders the way it always did.
On screen, a journalist was speaking over shaky footage, a figure in red, moving fast across a rooftop, one hand pressed to his side.
"-the vigilante known as Red Hood, believed to have sustained injuries during an altercation in the East End earlier tonight-"
"That guy is dangerous," Luke said. He hadn't looked away from the screen. "People like him always end up hurting someone."
You watched the footage loop.
"He saved me," you said. "A few days ago. In an alley near my apartment."
Luke turned to look at you. His expression shifted, concern first, then something more complicated.
"He saved you because it suited him," he said, not unkindly. "That doesn't erase what he does. You're defending him because you're grateful. That's understandable. But gratitude isn't the same as-"
You didn't say anything else. Luke pulled you a little closer, and you let him, and you watched the footage until it cut to something else.
You didn't tell him that what you kept thinking about wasn't the violence.
It was the pause. The one second too long he'd looked at you before leaving.
You saw him again three weeks later.
Different alley, same city, same hour when Gotham couldn't decide between night and morning. You weren't in trouble this time, you were just walking, the way you did when sleep wouldn't come and the apartment felt too small.
He was crouched on a fire escape above you, and he dropped down without a sound, landing a few feet away like it was nothing.
"You following me ?" you asked.
"Careful," he said. "That almost sounded like you think you're interesting enough to follow."
A pause. Something shifted in his posture, barely perceptible.
"You remind me of someone," you said, before you'd decided to.
"Another incredibly handsome guy ?" The voice was light, deflecting, the tone of someone who had practice at it.
The kind that has weight. The kind that fills up all the available space in a Gotham alley at 2 a.m. and leaves no room for anything else.
He didn't move for a moment. Then,
He didn't sound sorry. He sounded like someone who had just been told something that hit too close to somewhere he didn't let people go.
You watched him disappear back into the dark and stood there for a long moment, telling yourself, again, that the feeling in your chest was something simple and explainable.
You were getting worse at believing it.
You had put it off for months.
Not because you were ashamed of Luke, you weren't. He was good and steady and real, and every time you looked at him you felt the specific guilt of someone who knows they are loved better than they deserve.
But bringing him to the manor meant something. It meant standing in those halls with someone who wasn't Jason, introducing him to people who had known Jason, watching Bruce shake his hand and Dick smile too wide the way he did when he was trying to make someone feel welcome.
You did it anyway, because Luke deserved that much, and because you were tired of punishing him for something that wasn't his fault.
The evening went well. Dick was charming. Tim hacked into Luke's LinkedIn within the first ten minutes, which you only knew because of the look on his face when Luke mentioned his job. Alfred made the kind of dinner that made people feel immediately at home, which was its own particular cruelty because home was a complicated word in that house.
Halfway through dessert, you excused yourself.
The garden was cold and quiet, the kind of quiet that Gotham never quite managed, as if the manor existed in a slightly different version of the city. You walked without thinking, the old habit, faster than you needed to-
"Walk too fast when you're stressed."
You turned around slowly. He was standing near the garden wall, helmet on, arms loose at his sides. Here, of all places.
"How do you know that?" Your voice came out steadier than you felt.
A sound, almost a laugh, not quite. "That's what you're worried about? Not the masked guy with guns in your garden ?"
"Still bossy." He tilted his head slightly. "Some things don't change."
He turned to leave. Just before he cleared the wall, he paused, his head angling back toward you, just slightly.
"Because you never learned how to hide what you're feeling."
And then he was gone, and you were standing alone in the garden with the lights of the manor behind you and the sound of Luke's laugh drifting through the window, and something in your chest that you couldn't name and couldn't put down.
You slowly descended the stairs leading to the Batcave.
The hum of computers echoed through the vast, dark room, steady and cold, as always. Bruce had his back to you, already dressed in his Batman suit, focused intently on the screens.
You were about to greet him when a line caught your eye.
POTENTIAL IDENTITY: JASON TODD
Your breath caught in your throat. A small, strangled sound escaped you.
"No…" Bruce turned around immediately.
You were already staring at the screen, pale as if something had just pierced your chest without warning.
"No," you repeated, your voice trembling. "Jason is dead… it's impossible."
The silence that followed was worse than any answer.
Because Bruce didn't deny it.
You finally looked away from the screen to see him.
"Explain it to me." “Bruce slowly removed the Batman mask before placing it on the console.
“Jason is dead,” he finally said.
You immediately shook your head.
“Then why is his name displayed on this screen?”
Bruce remained silent for a few seconds, as if searching for a less horrific way to tell the truth.
"No." Your voice rose a notch. "No, it doesn't make any sense. People don't come back from the dead, Bruce."
"I tried to help him. But Jason didn't want to be saved anymore." You stared at him. Something hardened in your eyes.
"How long have you known ?"
"Did you know from the beginning ?"
"No. No, I didn't know at first, I swear-"
"I don't care about your promises." A heavy, inescapable silence fell between you.
"Were you planning to tell me someday ?"
"Not now," Bruce said, more softly. “It was too soon. You’d just been happy again. I didn’t want to ruin it.” You looked at him for another second just one, then you stormed off, tears streaming down your face, without looking back.
In the days that followed, you vanished.
No Luke. No boys. No one heard from you for a long time, and those who knew you well understood it was best not to push things.
When you reappeared, it was at 3 a.m., alone in a Gotham alley.
You weren’t there by chance.
Four men emerged from the shadows almost simultaneously, with that calculated slowness that always precedes violence. You didn’t have time to get into position before Red Hood was already there. Without a word, and in a few seconds the alley was silent again.
He straightened up, dusted himself off, and turned toward you.
"Take off that damn helmet."
"Take off that damn mask, Jason."
"Why didn't you tell me?"
He didn't answer right away. When he spoke, his voice had lost something, that calculated roughness he wore like armor.
"To protect you." A pause. "Because when I came back… I wasn't the person you loved anymore."
You walked toward him slowly, as if each step weighed a little more than the last. Jason didn't move an inch, standing there on the Gotham rooftop like a shadow too real in a memory you thought you'd buried long ago.
The wind rushed between you, cold and sharp, but you barely felt it anymore, because all your attention was focused on that red helmet you were staring at as if it held all the answers you'd been denied for years.
Your fingers trembled slightly as you finally raised your hand to him. Jason gently grasped your wrist at the last moment. An automatic gesture to tell you to stop.
"This is going to complicate everything," he murmured, his voice low and broken.
You responded with a trembling breath that sounded more like a plea than an answer.
Then you took off the helmet.
The metal hit the ground with a sharp thud that echoed far too long in the sudden silence of Gotham.
Everything you had buried for years came rushing back at once, without warning, without gentleness, like a wave too violent to hold back. Your legs almost buckled under the weight of what you had just understood. You brought a hand to your mouth, but your eyes filled too quickly, and tears fell despite yourself, first in small amounts, then more and more uncontrollably, until your whole face contorted in a mixture of shock, pain, and disbelief.
Jason remained frozen for a full second, as if he didn't know if he was still allowed to move, then he slowly crouched down in front of you, with the strange caution of someone who had survived too much but not this. He opened his mouth, unable to find the words at first, and when he finally spoke, his voice was softer, more human, almost fragile despite himself.
"Why ?" Your voice broke halfway through. "Why would you do this to me ? Why.."
He had no answer to that.
Some questions don't have answers.
Getting home was even harder than the revelation itself.
Because now, there was no shock to hold you together, just emptiness, thoughts looping endlessly, and this enormous weight in your chest that you couldn't even properly explain.
When you pushed open the door, the light was on.
He looked up as soon as he heard you come in, and his expression changed immediately, no words were needed to understand that it wasn't just a bad day, that it was something deeper, more serious, something completely beyond his grasp.
His voice was soft, cautious, as if he were treading on shaky ground.
You stood motionless by the door. Unable to take another step. Unable to answer, because everything you'd held back until then threatened to burst forth, and you didn't know which way to throw it without breaking everything.
Jason didn't tell you anything.
And now Luke was there. In your living room. In your current reality. In this life you'd tried to build afterward.
You opened your mouth, but no sound came out. You felt your hands tremble slightly as you searched for something to say, something simple, something that wouldn't destroy everything immediately.
Luke took a step closer, gently, and placed a hand on your arm.
That gesture, instead of calming you, almost made you want to break down even more.
"Tell me what's happening," he repeated, even more softly.
At first, it was confusing, almost chaotic, the Batcave, Bruce, the screen, the name that appeared, Jason Todd, dead for years, impossible, absurd. Then the fall, the moment everything suddenly fell into place. You spoke of Red Hood, unable to truly separate him from Jason. You spoke of the alley, the voice, the helmet, the things he knew about you, the impossible details, and the further you went on, the more your voice broke slightly, as if telling the story made everything even more real.
Luke didn't interrupt you once.
But his expression was changing. Not abruptly. Not theatrically. Slowly, like someone assembling pieces and beginning to understand that the final picture is far more complex than he had imagined.
When you finished, there was silence.
A real silence. Not awkward. Not empty. A silence of understanding.
"Jason Todd…" he repeated finally, very softly, as if testing the name to make sure it was real.
Luke ran a hand over his face, sat down slowly, without leaving the emptiness before him.
"That's why you disappeared…"
You looked up at him, and that's when you realized something even worse: Luke didn't doubt what you were saying. He believed you.
He stood up, briefly placed a hand on your shoulder, not to hold you back, just to say, "I'm here, I understand, and I forgive you…"
"Take all the time you need…"
Jason remained high above, motionless, clinging to the edge of a rooftop as if the entire city were suddenly weighing on his shoulders.
Against his will, he had followed you after your argument. Only to make sure you were alright…
Through the lit windows, he had seen the gestures, the tension, the tears, the words spoken too quickly and incomprehensibly. He couldn't hear everything. But he didn't need to.
Luke didn't make you tremble.
Luke didn't summon ghosts.
Luke didn't cause damage simply by existing.
Jason inhaled slowly, but the air felt too heavy. He lowered his head slightly, noticing the way Luke had placed his hand on your shoulder.
Not a truly thought-out sentence. More like a brutal truth that imposed itself without permission.
He didn't deserve you anymore.
Perhaps he never truly deserved you.
His fingers tightened for a moment on the edge of the roof, then slowly relaxed, as if something had silently given way inside, just a profound weariness that filled everything.
He took a step back. Then another.
Without taking his eyes off the light in your apartment.
Because a part of him still wanted to stay.
But this time, he couldn't find a word to say against what had just been decided for him.
The door opened, but you didn't turn around.
You already knew who it was, those little footsteps that clicked too loudly on the floor, the way she ran as if every room was an emergency. Little arms wrapped around you, and you were grinning from ear to ear before you'd even seen her.
You turned and hugged her, which made her laugh, that loud, uncontrollable laughter of children who can't yet contain their joy. Her short hair, spiky at the tips. Her sparkling eyes. It was uncanny how much she resembled you, and how much she resembled him too. You twirled her around before holding her close.
You chuckled softly and gently pulled away, placing her on the floor beside you. At first glance, your daughter was the spitting image of Luke. But on closer inspection, you could clearly see something of you in the shape of her eyes, in the way they crinkled when she laughed. She was a beautiful blend of both of you. She existed because something between you was real, deeply real, and that, no one could take away.
You still thought about him sometimes. Not like before, no more of that dull ache that woke you at night, no more of that guilt that tainted every moment of happiness. Just... him. Jason, Jay...with everything he carried that you hadn't been able to see back then. The anger that was never really anger. The distance that was never really rejection. He had survived things that would have broken anyone, and he had done what he knew best, disappear before he could ruin everything. You didn't resent him anymore. You only hoped, in that quiet corner of yourself that you didn't show to anyone, that he had finally found something resembling peace.
Night fell sooner than expected.
You had fallen asleep on the sofa, your daughter nestled against you, and Luke had found you both like that, motionless, breathing in unison. He gently lifted you without waking you. Your shivers subsided as he led you to the bedroom. You snuggled against him in your sleep, a barely perceptible smile on your face, your cheeks flushed with that warmth you feel when you're safe without even thinking about it.
He looked at you for a second before turning off the light.
The corners of his lips turned up slightly.
In the living room, where the lights were still on, the television hummed to itself.
The journalist's voice broke the silence of the apartment, neutral and detached, as it always was when Gotham became too strange to discuss otherwise.
"…Witnesses claim to have recently seen the vigilante known as Red Hood outside Gotham… alongside a female fighter identified as Artemis…"
No one in the apartment heard.
The living room light remained on for a long time, casting a soft glow on the empty sofa, on the toys scattered on the floor, on this quiet, imperfect life that went on, simply, as lives go on.
Somewhere in Gotham, on a rooftop no one was looking at, a man in red didn't move.
And he wasn't looking toward that window anymore.
Taglist : @starrydustedwinter , @25252222
Thanks for reading my fic !
Sorry it took me a while to post the second part because I went back to classes! I hope you are not too disappointed with the ending. I hesitated a long time between the different possible endings but I ended up choosing this one! Because the reader is far too sad and helpless to realize Jason's sacrifices and pain. And now each of them lives a happy life separately because Jason and the reader were not meant to be together