Iβve recently gotten into Golden Kamuy (literally days ago) and I love your analysis on the manga! I havenβt gotten very far into the series but I love it so far!
I was curious to know what your opinions are on the live action, anime and the manga overall if you are okay with sharing!
Live Action Movie: If you've not read the series, it's unwatchable.
If you HAVE read the series.... it's still unwatchable.
Live Action Series: I've not seen it.....dissappointed by movie
Live Action Movie Unwatchable Reasons:
Asirpa and Sugimoto look the same age.
Sugimoto is way younger than he needs to be and Asirpa is way older.
The result is that these two main characters are both in their early twenties. And so entire tone of the movie takes on a pocahontas-like story with a young Japanese man meeting a young indigenous women and her showing him her world.
Nowhere is it made clear that they are supposed to be vastly different in age.
In the scene where Sugimoto visits Asirpa's village for the first time, Kuci asks Sugimoto to marry her and it looks natural and reasonable because she looks like the age where she needs to be married.
This is terrible. And the kicker is, that in a flashback with Asirpa and Retar, they actually have a young child after who is about 12 years old acting as Asirpa. So why couldn't they keep that actress instead? She is clearly a young child where's the regular actress is clearly a woman.
All of this sets up a clear Sugimoto x Asirpa angle that is.....not what was originally intended.
The camera work is up terrible.
It's really not on par with what you'd expect from even TV series, or even tiktok videos. Most parts of this movie look like amateurish home video or a cosplay skit shot by fans
The movie is dominated by tons of fight scenes that were either extremely lengthened or not even in the original.
The fighting is pointless, feels tedious and also badly shot.
For example, in this scene where sugimoto escapes on the sled, he fights Tsukishima for around 5 minutes on the back of the moving sled in a martial arts style fight, and then Tsukishima falls off and Nikado hops on and Sugimoto fights Nikaido for another 10 minutes on the sled.
So you're just sitting there for 15 minutes of a badly shot fight that does nothing for the story. There are fights like these all over the movie and this time could have been used to introduce or develop characters.
Characters are just randomly introduced with no context.
Hijikata shows up on a horse. His name flashes on screen.
Who the fuck is he? We don't know.
Ushiyama shows up. It's never mentioned or even hinted at that he's good at Judo. The pacing is really fast and disjointed. None of the characters backgrounds are gone into or even introduced.
Tsurumi isn't menacing or creepy, he's goofy....
What makes his character so interesting is that he is brilliant, strategist but also has these bizarre unhinged moments that puts the normal person off. So the out of left field behaviors unsettle the viewer.
But in the movie the serious moments are not very serious so he comes across as goofy and incompetent. Reminiscent of Dr Robotnik in Sonic the hedgehog. Like a campy villain rather than a brilliant one.
I watched this movie with my family.
I thought it might have been a good oppurtunity to get them into GK, as we are military history enthusiasts, and have a pre-existing interest in the Russo-Japanese war and this period of history in general.
The movie was terrible and after watching the fam was convinced that:
1. Shiraishi is the main antagonist.
2. Asirpa and Sugimoto will become a couple.
3. Looking for the gold is the directive of the entire Japanese military and government, beccause the separation of Tsurumi from the Imperial army itself was not clear. So this was a rage against the machine kind of story.
4. Sugimoto's motivations were unclear. Toraji was so briefly introduced that we don't really know what the relationship between Sugi, Toraji and Umeko even are and how they feel about each other.