The Beauty of the Husband: a fictional essay in 29 tangos by Anne Carson
VI. TO CLEAN YOUR HOOVES HERE IS A DANCE IN HONOR OF THE GRAPE WHICH THROUGHOUT HISTORY HAS BEEN A SYMBOL OF REVELRY AND JOY NOT TO SAY ANALOGY FOR THE BRIDE AS UNCUT BLOSSOM
Smell I will never forget. Out behind the vineyard. Stone place maybe a shed or an icehouse no longer in use. October, a little cold. Hay on the floor. We had gone to his grandfather's farm to help
crush the grapes for wine.
You cannot imagine the feeling if you have never done it— like hard bulbs of wet red satin exploding under your feet, between your toes and up your legs arms face splashing everywhere— It goes right through your clothes you know he said as we slogged up and down
in the vat. When you take them off you'll have juice all over. His eyes moved onto me then he said Let's check. Naked in the stone place it was true, sticky stains, skin, I lay on the hay
and he licked. Licked it off. Ran out and got more dregs in his hands and smeared it on my knees neck belly licking. Plucking. Diving. Tongue is the smell of October to me. I remember it as swimming in a fast river for 1 kept moving and it was hard to move
while all around me was moving too, that smell of turned earth and cold plants and night coming on and the old vat steaming slightly in the dusk out there and him,
raw juice on him. Stamens on him and as Kafka said in the end my swimming was of no use to me you know I cannot swim after all. Well it so happens more than 90% of all cultivated grapes are varieties of
Vitis vinifera the Old World or European grape, while native American grapes derive from certain wild species of Vitis and differ in their "foxy" odor as well as the fact that their skins slip so liquidly from the pulp.
An ideal wine grape is one that is easily crushed. Such things I learned from the grandfather when we sat in the kitchen late at night cracking chestnuts. Also that I should under no circumstances marry his grandson whom he called tragikos a country word meaning either tragic or goat.
***
XXII. HOMO LUDENS
Omens are for example hearing someone say victory as they pass you in the street or to be staring at the little sulfur lamps in the grass all around the edge of the hotel garden just as they come on. They come on at dusk.
What was he thinking to bring her here? Athens. Hotel Eremia. He knew very well. Détente and reconciliation, let's start again, thinking oysters and glace fruits, it needs a light touch, narrow keys not very deep. Hotel gardens at dusk are a place where the laws governing matter get pulled inside out, like the black keys and the white keys on Mozart's piano. It cheered him to remember Mozart borrowing money every night and smiling his tilted smile. Necessity is not real! after all. The husband swallows his ouzo and waits for its slow hot snow inside him. Mozart (so his wife told him at lunch) scored his Horn Concerto
in four different colors of ink: a man at play. A husband whose wife knows just enough history to keep him going. Cheer is rampant in the husband now. Infinite evening ahead. Its shoals appear to him and he navigates them one by one
slipping the dark blue keel ropes this way and that on a bosom of inconceivable silver—ah here she is. The husband can be seen to rise as his wife crosses the garden. Why so sad. No I'm not sad. Why in your eyes— What are you drinking. Ouzo. Can you get me a tea. Of course.
He goes out. She waits. Waiting, thoughts come, go. Flow. This flowing.
Why sadness? This flowing the world to its end. Why in your eyes—
It is a line of verse. Where has it stepped from. She searches herself, waiting. Waiting is searching. And the odd thing is, waiting, searching, the wife suddenly knows a fact about her husband. This fact for which she had not searched jerks itself into the light like a child from a closet. She knows why he is taking so long at the bar.
Over and over in later years when she told this story she marvelled at her husband's ability to place the world within brackets. A bracket's worth of mirage! all he ever needed.
A man who after three years of separation would take his wife to Athens— for adoration, for peace, then telephone New York every night from the bar and speak to a woman who thought he was over on 4th Street working late. And upstairs that night, which proved a long night, as he was dragging his wounded honor about the hotel room like a damaged queen of moths because she mentioned Houyhnhnms and he objected to being "written off as an object of satire," they moved several times through a cycle of remarks like—
What is this, what future is there I thought You said We never When exactly day year name anything who I was who I am who did you Did you or did you not Do you or do you not This excuse that excuse pleasure pain truth What truth is that All those kilometers Faith Letters You're right Never oh all right once—
which, like the chain of Parmenides well-rounded Truth you can follow around in a circle and always end up where you began, for "it is all one to me where I start—I arrive there again soon enough"
as Parmenides says. So the wife was thinking (about Parmenides) with part of her mind while throwing Ever Never Liar at her husband and he was holding Yes and No together with one hand while parrying the words of his wife when—
they stopped. Silence came. They stood aligned, he at the door with his back to it she at the bed with her back to it, in that posture which experts of conflict resolution tell us ensures impasse, and they looked at one another and there was nothing more to say.
Kissing her, I love you, joys and leaves of earlier times flowed through the husband and disappeared
Presence and absence twisted out of sight of one another inside the wife.
They stood. Sounds reach them, a truck, a snore, poor shrubs ticking on a tin wall.
His nose begins to bleed.
Then blood runs down over his upper lip, lower lip, chin. To his throat. Appears on the whiteness of his shirt. Dyes a mother-of-pearl button for good. Blacker than a mulberry. Don't think his heart had burst. He was no Tristan (though he would love to point out that in the common version Tristan is not false, it is the sail that kills) yet neither of them had a handkerchief and that is how she ends up staining her robe with his blood, his head in her lap and his virtue coursing through her
as if they were one flesh. Husband and wife may erase a boundary. Creating a white page.
But now the blood seems to be the only thing in the room.
If only one's whole life could consist in certain moments. There is no possibility of coming back from such a moment to simple hatred, black ink.
If a husband throws the dice of his beauty one last time, who is to blame?
Rich proposition, drastic economy, hours, beds, pronouns, no one. No one is to blame. Change the question. We are mortal, balanced on a day, now and then it makes sense to say Save what you can.
Wasn't it you who told me civilization is impossible in the absence of a spirit of play.
Anyway what would you have done— torn the phone off the wall? smothered him with a pillow? emptied his wallet and run? But you overlook an important cultural function of games. To test the will of the gods. Huizinga reminds us that war itself is a form of divination.
Husband and wife did not therefore engage in murder but continued their tour of the Peloponnese, spending eight more wary days}in temples and buses and vine-covered tavernas, eight days which had the internal texture of πετραδάκι (ancient πετρος) —that is "broken crushed stone, roadstone, gravel"— but which served a purpose within the mode of justice that was their marriage. Waiting for the future and for the gods,
husband and wife rested,
as players may rest against the rules of the game, if it is a game, if they know the rules, and it was and they did.
***
XXIX. IMPURE AS I AM FOODSTAINS AND SHAME AND ALL) SO TOO MY CONCLUSIONS WHICH AT THE DOOR SCENT YOU AND HESITATE
To get them out of her the wife tries making a list of words she never got to say. How have you been. Fancy seeing you here. I had given up hope I grew desperate why did you take so long. Bloodless monster! had I never seen or known your kindness what might | have been. But words
are a strange docile wheat are they not, they bend to the ground. Fact is,
no one was asking. Well Ray would have asked. So for Ray let's just finish it. Not because, like Persephone, I needed to cool my cheek on death. Not, with Keats, to buy time. Not, as the tango, out of sheer wantonness. But oh it seemed sweet.
To say Beauty is Truth and stop. Rather than to eat it. Rather than to want to eat it. This was my pure early thought.
I overlooked one thing. That the beautiful when I encountered it would turn out to be prior—inside my own heart, already eaten. Not out there with purposiveness, with temples, with God. Inside. He was already me. Condition of me. As if Kutuzov had found himself charging across the battlefield at Borodino toward—
not the emperor Napoleon but a certain old king Midas whose weapons touched half the Russian army into bitter boys of gold.
Words, wheat, conditions, gold, more than thirty years of it fizzing around in me— there I lay it to rest. You smile. I think you are going to mention again those illuminated manuscripts from medieval times where the scribe has made an error in copying so the illuminator encloses the error in a circlet of roses and flames
which a saucy little devil is trying to tug off the side of the page. After all the heart is not a small stone to be rolled this way and that. The mind is not a box to be shut fast.
And yet it is! It is!
Well life has some risks. Love is one. Terrible risks. Ray would have said Fate's my bait and bait's my fate. On a June evening. Here's my advice, hold.
Hold beauty.














