Rosewood's A.D.

I was a pre teen when I started watching the original PLL and I was obsessed with it back then, PLLOS has made its way into my adult life and now i’m obsessed with theorizing everything again so let’s go

At that beach scene Imogen is still wearing the clothes from Karen’s party which makes me think baby was conceived that night, so something happened either at the party or on the way home.

Tabby was SA’d that’s why she keeps the camera at the boy’s locker room, she’s probably trying to discover who was it and tbh I have a feeling it might be Noa’s boyfriend. The opening has a lot of futebol references

One of them is for sure helping A, that text message? “Reveal your true self, 1 bully down 5 to go” was shady asf

Minnie is off but I don’t think she has anything to do with A but something equally sinister has happened to her

Karen really died, Kelly planned her death. There was a lot of swapping that day but i’m sure Kelly is the evil twin, the way she told the ‘truth’ after her dad gave a speech about how he would end those girls life? self preservation, she needed him to stop digging further into her sisters death

The sheriff definitely has an affair with the principal. I said what I said

Angela was being followed by someone/threatened the night of the party

Also, that wasn’t a party. No one calling the cops or 911? no way, literally no way. I’m pretty sure it was just the moms and Angela that night, as Tabby’s mom said “they know what everyone thinks is the truth” there’s more to it.

Masked man and A are different people but work together

Now this is just a random thought, NO ONE NOTICE THE JANITOR IS GONE????

I need Imogen to be gay that’s it. that’s the comment.

There’s a teddy bear close to Angela’s memorial (?) below the scarlet letter book, masked man carries the same bear in the series intro

Chandler Kinney as Tabby Haworthe

Pretty obvious, but Kelly was the one who died, not Karen. They foreshadowed the switch when Kelly went to school as Karen + Imogen wouldn't mistake them. Also PLL loooves twin switches and shenanigans so I'm not surprised lol

There's obviously way more to the mothers and Angela Waters than we know. Also I 100% think Imogen's mother was murdered by A

I know 2/3 main As appeared since the 1st ep of the season (Mona & Cece), but I'm honestly not sure we have already met A. If A is a single person (which might not be the case), everyone who saw the masked killer or was somewhere else when they pushed Karen/Kelly can't be A, which immediately excludes the 5 main girls (should we call them liars too? lol) and the remaining Beasley twin (also Faran's mother, who was in Pittsburgh during the first couple episodes). It could be one of the parents or a random relative of Angela who we don't know is related to her yet. If I had to bet on one of the current characters, it would be Shawn (A has always been around the same age as the liars, he could have a random connection to Angela or the Y2K party we still don't know about, and I don't think we was confirmed to be with the crowd when the Beasley fell. Plus idk he felt off to me)

Also, A had access to the school building, so they're probably either a student or a member of the faculty

Imogen is hiding something. I don't know what it is, I don't necessarily think it is related to A, but yeah. She's suspicious

Watching Original Sin in 2022: