Girlfriend Without The Benefits (Bucky Barnes x Reader)
Summary: You and Bucky are just friends, albeit very close ones. Your friends don't believe you, speculating that you two are a couple. When one of them tells you that you're basically his girlfriend without the benefits, you start noticing that you do act like his partner. It gets you wondering whether or not you actually have feelings for him. (Female Reader) Word Count: 7,727 Contents: Mildly Suggestive Content. Concussions (Bucky). Pining. Massages. Realisations of Feelings. Love Confessions. Accidental Couple's Costumes. No Y/N, Petnames (Doll) Notes: This is a companion piece to "Boyfriend Without The Benefits" from Bucky's Perspective. So, check that out, too! The two fics start with the same scene, then go on to different scenarios in which you and Bucky realise you are acting like partners during the respective fics. The last scene is the same, but from different perspectives. This took me MONTHS to complete, and it feels like a magnum opus right now. I really hope you all enjoy it ^^ Crossposted on AO3: https://archiveofourown.org/works/89673146/chapters/238209911
---
“You two are such liars.”
“Why are we liars?”
“You are obviously a couple and you’re just lying to mess with us.”
“What makes you think we’re a couple?”
Natasha gave you two a look, like she was asking whether you two were being serious, while Sam started to gesture widely at you and Bucky. You looked down at the position you two were in and had to admit that you somehow got why your friends would have misunderstood your relationship. You were practically in his lap, your legs swung over his and your shoulder leaning against Bucky’s chest while one of his arms rested behind you on the back of the sofa.
But then you remembered how often you two had fended off your friends’ prying and told them you were just friends, so you just crossed your arms over your chest and shook your head in amusement. Meanwhile, Bucky lifted his arm from behind you to support his head on his hand and rolled his eyes at your friends.
“We are not a couple. We’re just friends.”
“Yes, Bucky’s right.” You nodded wisely but didn’t move away from him and he couldn’t help but cherish the comforting weight of your body against his. “Can’t two friends cuddle with each other from time to time?”
“They can.” Joaquin piped up from next to Sam but then a grin spread across his face and he shook his head. “I mean, sometimes I cuddle my friends, too. But you two are practically attached at the hip.”
You just shook your head at all their speculations. “Bucky and I are not a couple.”
“If you say so.”
“Don’t you all have something else to talk about?” Bucky interjected as he brought his other hand down to rest atop of your leg, fingers absentmindedly running over your shin, making goosebumps rise on your skin and a smile appear on your face. “This can’t possibly be the most interesting thing to talk about.”
Sam narrowed his eyes at the movement of Bucky’s hand before he shrugged. “Fine, have it your way. Anyways, did you guys hear about the new exhibition at the Museum of Natural History? It’s about space travel and all the planets that we’ve made contact with in the last decades. I thought of going there to see how many of those planets I know through fighting with their people against Thanos.”
“You’ve probably heard about it before, Doll. You love space.”
“I did hear about it.” You nodded with a smile, the warmth now spreading up your chest at how well he knew you. As you began to talk about it, you leaned a little more into Bucky. “But you love science and space, too. We should go see it together.”
Bucky smiled at your words and you wondered if he was also happy to be known so well. You knew that he’d loved science ever since he’d been a child and you were getting excited to learn more about it with him. “I’d love nothing more than that.”
“So, you two are basically going on a cute museum date.” Joaquin piped up, grinning widely at the two of you. “And we’re supposed to believe you when you say you’re not dating?”
You couldn’t help but roll your eyes at Joaquin’s words before you gave him an amused look. “Because friends can’t spend time together, I guess.”
“Come on guys, they don’t want us to talk about this.” Natasha piped up and you turned to her in surprise that she was willing to drop the subject. But when a big grin spread on your face you knew you’d rejoiced too soon. “I mean, if they want to keep their obvious relationship a secret, let them.”
“We are not in a relationship.” You groaned out before pushing yourself up off Bucky’s lap, wanting to escape this conversation. As you separated from him you couldn’t help mourning the loss of his body heat but chalked it up to simply enjoying the presence of him as a friend. “That is my cue to get myself something to drink. Does anybody want anything from the kitchen?”
“I’ll come with you. I want to see if you guys have any interesting snacks.”
You nodded at Joaquin’s words and the two of you left for the kitchen, leaving Bucky with Sam and Natasha. While you busied yourself with grabbing something to drink from the fridge, Joaquin started rummaging through the cupboards and once more you dared to hope that this whole discussion was over. But then Joaquin spoke up.
“Are you two really not a couple? I mean, if you’re pretending not to be to mess with Sam Nat and everyone else, then I have to say it’s pretty funny, but at least clue me in here. We’re best friends and I could help you mess with them some more!”
A small chuckle escaped you at his reasoning but you shook your head. “Joaquin, for the last time, Bucky and I are not a couple. We’re just friends – close friends, yes, but friends.”
“I really thought you two were dating.” Joaquin mused as he gathered some snacks into his arms and turned to you. “I mean, you’re basically his girlfriend without the benefits.”
That got your attention and you turned around with a shocked expression. “I’m his what?”
“You know, the opposite of a friend with benefits. You’re like his girlfriend but without the kissing, hugging, going on actual dates, and stuff. So, a girlfriend without the benefits.”
“That’s ridiculous!”
“Are you getting so defensive because I’m right?”
If you were to be honest, you really didn’t know why you were getting so defensive and why his words made a strange emotion grow in your chest. Bucky had been your best friend for years and you two had always been adamant about not being a couple, no matter how close you were, so you were left wondering what that emotion you were feeling was. Nonetheless, you shook your head at Joaquin.
“We are not a couple and I’m not his girlfriend without the benefits.”
“Just think about what I said.”
---
And think about it you did. It really irritated you because now you were second-guessing every interaction you and Bucky had, from cuddling during movies, over cooking for each other, all the way to simply seeking out each other’s presence. For a few days, it was all you could think about and that strange new emotion that you had yet to identify didn’t make things easier for you. But then a mission came along, almost like a welcome distraction from your feelings.
Unfortunately, it ended with injuries. While you had all successfully taken down the criminal organisation after months of surveillance, it wasn’t without consequences. Natasha had been shot twice and had to be taken to the hospital to have the bullets still lodged in her shoulder extracted. You were luckier and after getting your stab wounds stitched up, you got to go home without any surgeries.
It was Bucky that worried you the most because he’d been hit in the head and the doctors had said he had a concussion. While you knew that with the serum, he’d be fine by tomorrow, at the moment he was in pain and lying on his back on the sofa, eyes closed and a cold wet towel on his forehead. The moment you walked into the living room, however, he tried to sit up and check on you, only for Sam to force him to lie down again.
“Take it easy, Bucky. She’s alright.”
“I am.” You quickly reassured Bucky as you hurried over to help Sam ease your friend back into a more comfortable position. “They stitched me up and I’ll be fine. Please, don’t get up, Bucky. How is your head?”
“It fucking hurts.” Bucky grumbled out, eyes still closed and blindly reaching out for your hand. “That damn security personnel hit me hard.”
Sam nodded his head along to Bucky’s words. “The doctors said with the serum he’d be fine by tomorrow and gave him painkillers, but they haven’t kicked in yet. He’s also not allowed to move around too much, read or look at screens.”
“I’ll keep all that in mind. When did you take the painkillers, Bucky?”
“When Sam and I got home.”
“Twenty minutes ago. They’ll take a few more minutes to kick in.” Sam said before he straightened up again. “Listen, Natasha called me just before you came in and asked me to pick her up. I told her I would come as soon as you got here, so you can keep an eye on Bucky.”
Bucky’s hand squeezed around yours. “Keep an eye on me? I’ll be fine.”
“I need her to make sure you don’t do anything stupid, like trying to get up and walking around.” Sam teased back before looking at you. “Can you do that, please?”
“Of course. You go get Nat.”
“Thanks!”
With that, Sam grabbed his things and left, leaving you and Bucky alone in the living room. Bucky turned his head just slightly, eyebrows drawing together in pain, before he cracked one eye open to look at you.
“Be honest with me, Doll, are you alright?”
“It hurts when I move too much but I’ll be fine. I’m more worried about you.”
“I’ll be alright.” He promised, giving you a tight, almost forced smile. “It just sucks that all I can do is lie around and wait. I can’t even read anything because that’s too hard on the brain, so-- so I can’t distract myself from the pain.”
You thought for a second before you had an idea. “I could read to you.”
“You don’t have to. You should-- You should rest.”
“Nonsense. If you let me sit down on the couch, so I won’t have to stand, I can totally read to you. And the book I’ve been reading is right here. It’s really not that strenuous.”
Bucky was quiet for a few seconds before his eyes focused on you. “Can I lay my head into your lap, please?”
“Of course.”
Gingerly, so as not to cause him any pain, you manoeuvred around until you were sitting on the couch, back against the armrest with Bucky’s head in your lap. The smile that spread on his face, all relieved and content, made your insides twist up again and once more you wondered why you felt this way around Bucky. But you couldn’t think about that now because he was injured and you wanted to help. So, you reached for your book and started reading to him.
While you did so, your hands began to gently card through his hair and you felt him relax into your touch. Despite you two being injured, it was strangely peaceful, but then again you always felt at peace around Bucky. Had you two not been injured and had you not been so focused on easing Bucky’s pain you would have given that a second thought. But for now, you were glad to be able to help.
You stayed like that for almost an hour until Sam and Natasha got back, the latter supporting her weight on her friend as he helped her inside. Joaquin was trailing behind them with some bags of take-out balanced in his arms. When they all saw you, Natasha had to cover her mouth with her hand to keep herself from making any loud noises and Sam had to elbow Joaquin in the side to keep him quiet.
“Not a word.” You hissed softly, careful not to disturb Bucky. “Don’t you dare wake him back up. He’s in pain and he needs rest.”
“We’ll be quiet. But we got you some food.” Joaquin whispered back before placing a box of take-out on the coffee table. “What are you reading?”
“Project Hail Mary. Well, I’m re-reading it but that’s actually perfect because both Bucky and I know the book, so he won’t have to concentrate on listening.” It was when you leaned forward to place the book on the coffee table that you noticed that Bucky’s right hand was tightly wrapped around your free wrist. The strange sense of warmth once more began spreading in your chest at him subconsciously holding onto. “I wanted to distract him from the pain. I guess reading to him did the trick.”
“It probably also helped that you were petting his hair.” Sam joked, earning himself a glare from you, to which he simply smiled. “I’m serious right now. I think Bucky really likes it when you play with his hair. He always relaxes when you do.”
Joaquin motioned for your occupied hand. “It’ll probably be a bit hard to eat like that, though. Do you need any help?”
“No thanks, I don’t need you feeding me.” You joked before shaking your head and cosying down on the couch. “It’s fine, I’m not that hungry anyway. I’ll eat something later when Bucky releases his death grip on my arm.”
“We’ll be in the kitchen so we don’t disturb you two love birds.” Natasha said softly, ignoring your glare. “If you need anything, call us.”
---
It really surprised you how much time you spent thinking about Joaquin’s words and how they made you question how you two behaved around each other. His words still had you wondering about why you liked having Bucky close, why you always felt a pleasant warmth when he was around and why your heart skipped a beat any time he touched you. In the back of your mind, you already knew the answer because you weren’t stupid by any means. But despite all your intelligence, you were also very stubborn.
These thoughts kept running through your head at all times, even now as you sat in the kitchen, eating your breakfast. You only stopped thinking about this when Bucky walked in. You gave him a bright smile, as always happy to see him, but when you saw that he was avoiding eye contact and hadn’t yet reattached his arm, which he usually only took off during sleep or when his shoulder hurt, your face fell into a frown. He gave you a nod of acknowledgement before going to the counter to pick up an orange.
“Bucky, are you alright?”
“I’ll be fine, Doll. Just had a nightmare.”
“That means you’re not fine now.” You got up from your chair and walked over to place a gentle hand on his back. “Do you want to talk about it?”
“’Can’t.”
“Alright, that’s fine. You don’t have to. Do you need anything?” You leaned forward to get a look at his face, drawn together into a deep frown. “Do you want me to distract you? Or do you want me to hold you? I could also make you something for breakfast like I always do. Maybe you’ll feel better once you’ve eaten.”
Bucky finally looked up at that, eyes locking with yours and you felt some tension leave your shoulders because you knew that if he wasn’t making eye contact, things were bad. “Thanks, but there’s not much you can do about it now. I just want to forget about it for now. Can I join you for breakfast?”
“Of course, James.” You smiled softly and rubbed his back a little before you two made your way back to the table to sit down. “Do you want me to make you something to eat, though? I mean, I’m just having muesli but I can make you a sandwich or some eggs or whatever you want.”
“I’ll stick with my orange for now. I’ll eat something more later.”
You looked at him for a second, taking in his frown and how his right hand shook ever so slightly on the orange as he tried to peel it. Before even thinking about it you reached out to take the orange from him and Bucky gave you a confused look, but when you started peeling it, his frown melted into a smile.
“Thank you so much, Doll.”
Warmth spread through your chest at his words but you ignored it in favour of helping Bucky. After giving him a gentle smile, you hooked the nail of your thumb into the skin of the orange to break it open and you began to slowly peel it. You were interrupted when you heard footsteps approaching and soon after, Yelena walked in, accompanied by Natasha. The two of them were talking amongst themselves, only stopping once to greet you and Bucky. As you continued to peel his orange, Yelena went to the fridge and Natasha looked through the fruit bowl before frowning.
“Damn it, there aren’t any oranges left.” She complained before her eyes locked on you. “Can I have half of yours?”
“You have to ask Bucky. It’s his orange. I’m just peeling it for him.”
Natasha turned to ask Bucky but before she could get a word out, Yelena gave a loud squeal that made all of you flinch. While her sister looked at her in amusement, you threw Yelena a confused look to which she just pointed at the half-peeled orange in your hands. Your gaze flickered down toward it but you really didn’t know what Yelena was talking about, so you looked back up at her in question.
“Come on, have you never heard of the orange peel theory?”
“I don’t think I have.” You mumbled, looking back at the orange in your hands. “Is this like an internet theory or a real one?”
“It’s an internet theory, yes, but I think there’s some truth to it.” Yelena began, raising a wise finger. “It’s a viral social media concept that says a partner’s willingness to perform small, unasked, and seemingly trivial acts of service -- like peeling an orange for you -- is a meaningful indicator of care, attentiveness, and love.”
Natasha snorted a little at her sister’s words. “You recited that so well; you get ten points for that.”
“Come on, Nat, don’t tell me you don’t think there’s some truth to it. She is peeling an orange for him and it seems meaningless but she’s doing it because-- Why are you peeling Bucky’s orange for him again?”
“He had a nightmare and still seemed shaken by it, so since I make breakfast for him all the time anyway, I wanted to peel it for him.” You mumbled, trying to ignore the way your stomach fluttered at Yelena’s words, at how this theory actually made some sense. “It’s an orange; it’s not that special.”
Yelena shook her head at that. “No, you’re doing it because Bucky is feeling down and you want to be there for him. You’re peeling an orange for your boyfriend to make life a little easier for him and that shows care, attentiveness and love, even if it doesn’t seem like a big deal to you.”
“Actually, that does sound about right. I mean, people always say that it’s the little things that show us that someone loves us.” Natasha agreed with Yelena, crossing her eyes and smiling at you and Bucky. “Look at you, acting like a couple again.”
“While denying that you are one.”
While Bucky jokingly rolled his eyes at their antics, you shook your head in amusement and placed a hand on his back almost on instinct. “I was just trying to be nice and help Bucky out.”
“Keep denying it if that’s what floats your boat.” Natasha joked before leaning closer to you and giving you a big grin. “But did you notice that you never called Yelena out on her referring to Bucky as your boyfriend?”
---
Natasha’s question kept running through your head for days afterwards and you couldn’t help but wonder whether or not there was some truth to it. The thought of Bucky being your boyfriend wasn’t bad at all but you two had always been adamant about just being friends, so you were certain his feelings for you were only platonic. You were also sure that your confusing thoughts and feelings would go away on their own in no time.
But even as you were lying on your stomach, reading your book you couldn’t completely shake them off. Not until Bucky entered your room without even knocking, used to letting himself in as you did with his room. You merely peeked up from your book at first but when you saw him, you couldn’t help but frown. His eyebrows were pinched in a pained expression and his right hand was massaging his left shoulder which was missing his Vibranium arm.
“Hey, Buck, are you alright? Why did you take your arm off?”
“My shoulder really hurts today.” Bucky shrugged and let himself flop onto your bed before turning his head to you. “You said you wanted to show me something earlier, right? So, what is it?”
“Nothing that important.” You said off-handedly and got onto your knees on the bed, looking down at him as you placed your hands onto your thighs. “Where does it hurt? The shoulder blade? The neck?”
Bucky pushed himself up a little bit. “It’s more the top of the shoulder and up to the neck.”
“Turn onto your stomach and take off your shirt.”
“Why?”
“I’ll give you a massage.” You shrugged, looking at him expectantly and when he slowly began to shrug off his shirt, you smiled in satisfaction. “I’m no physical therapist but I’m sure I can get some of the tension out of your neck. Turn around now.”
Without a hint of hesitation, Bucky turned onto his stomach. He trusted you completely and you smiled to yourself as you crawled halfway on top of him, sitting down on his butt but keeping most of your weight on your legs. Then you leaned forward and got to work, focusing on his shoulders first and using your thumbs to work out the tight knots there.
Whenever he hissed in pain, you shushed him gently and used the balls of your hand to smooth out his muscles before continuing to ease the tension in his muscles with your thumbs. Slowly but surely, his hisses of pain turned into sighs of relief and pleasure at having your nimble fingers work at his neck.
“I swear your hands are magical, Doll.”
You just chuckled at his words, leaning forward a little to put more weight onto your hands and work out a particularly stubborn knot. All the while, you tried to ignore the way your stomach lurched at the position you two were in. The way he sighed underneath you and the heat of his body made it really hard to ignore these strange feelings. But Bucky was in pain, so you just focused on massaging him and stubbornly shoved your thoughts way.
That worked until the door swung open and none other than Joaquin marched in, talking away about how you’d stood him up for the training session you two had planned with Sam, but he stopped when he saw you and Bucky. His eyes grew wild and he began to point back and forth between the two of you.
“Sam is never going to believe this!”
“Never going to believe what? Did you figure out why she’s late?” Came Sam’s voice from the hallway because you could truly never catch a break and when he came into view, his mouth fell open. “I knew it!”
“This isn’t what it looks like!” You exclaimed as you got off Bucky and he sat up next to you, shaking your head. “I swear!”
Joaquin snorted at that. “I don’t even know what it looks like.”
“Foreplay.” Sam commented and then had to dodge the pillow Bucky threw at his face. “Hey, I’m just kidding! It’s obviously a massage but come on, man, you can’t be in that position with her and then got off at us for thinking you’re more than friends!”
“We are friends, Samuel.” You hissed and he turned to you at the use of his full first name. “Bucky’s shoulder hurt, so I gave him a massage. Don’t be nasty!”
Joaquin snorted from next to Sam. “And you expect us to believe that?”
“Alright, you know what? You wanted a training session? You’re getting one because I’m going to kick your butt.” You threatened jokingly as you got off your bed, your face still hot with embarrassment and questions over questions running through your head. “Meet me down at the gym in ten minutes. I’ll just run a bath for Bucky and then I’ll be there.”
“That is the least threatening thing you could have ended with.” Joaquin grinned and raised his voice to imitate you. “Let me just run a bath for my boyfriend and then I’ll come and kick your butt!”
Your eyes narrowed at Joaquin mocking you but before you could answer, Bucky did, getting up from the bed and raising his hand in an appeasing gesture. “Once again, in case you two douchebags have forgotten it, we’re not a couple. And I bet you two are just jealous you don’t have a wonderful friend who massages your sore shoulders and draws you a bath.”
“Exactly.” You grinned from next to Bucky, heart leaping at him immediately backing you up. “Now get ready for our training sessions. I’ll be with you shortly.”
“I cannot believe I got called a douchebag and Joaquin got threatened to get his butt kicked.” Sam exclaimed in mock betrayal and dramatically threw his hands to his forehead. “You two are so cruel to poor Joaquin and I, you’re perfect for each other!”
Bucky’s laughter rang out from next to you, light and carefree, while you felt anything but. From the way your heart leapt at his laughter to the way your stomach fluttered at Sam’s words, you knew you couldn’t deny it anymore. You were in love with Bucky.
---
For the next few days, all you could think about was how you were in love with your best friend and whenever the two of you interacted, you had to actively reel yourself back in to not act upon your feelings. You were at a loss of what to do and if you should tell him about how you felt, because you were so uncertain of whether or not he saw you as more than a friend. Thankfully, the Halloween party hosted at the Watchtower was a welcome distraction from your pining and thanks to the costume you’d worked so hard on for months and its helmet you could hide from Bucky while you pondered what to do.
You couldn’t hide from your feelings, unfortunately, because you’d spotted Bucky the second he’d walked in and when you’d clocked that he was dressed as Han Solo while you were dressed as Leia pretending to be Boushh in ‘Return of the Jedi’ you felt your heart leap into your throat. It made you think of the words she told him during the scene where she rescues him and how they kiss afterwards. The thought of kissing Bucky made your face heat up and your stomach flutter. Groaning quietly, you resigned yourself to the fate of being helplessly in love with your best friend.
“You look miserable, girl.”
“I’m wearing a helmet, Yelena. How could you possibly tell?”
“Your shoulders are ever so slightly slumped, your listlessly lingering around the edge of the dance floor while fiddling with the straps of your costume and all the while, you keep staring at Bucky.”
“What is that supposed to mea—” You started but then you cut yourself off because there was truly no lying about your feelings anymore and perhaps talking to your friend would make you feel a bit better. “Lena, I don’t know what to do about this!”
“About what?” Yelena narrowed her eyes, making her look straight out of the hallway scene in ‘The Shining’ that her double costume with Natasha was inspired by. But then she seemed to get what you were saying and her whole face lit up. “Are you in love with Bucky?”
“Not so loud.” You hissed at her before shaking your head miserably. “I kept questioning why I didn’t correct you when you said he was my boyfriend during that whole orange thing a week ago. Then I gave him a message and Sam and Joaquin walked in on us. They teased us and when we started joking around with them, Sam said Bucky and I are perfect for each other. And then Bucky was laughing and I got butterflies in my stomach and—”
Yelena raised her hands to calm you down. “Slow down there and take a deep breath. Now I get why you’ve been hiding under that helmet for the whole party. First of all, I’m glad you finally came to terms with your feelings and second of all, what are you going to do about them?”
“I just told you that I don’t know!” You exclaimed in exasperation. “I don’t know if he feels the same and I don’t want to ruin our friendship. Romantic feelings aside, I care so much about him and I don’t want to lose him.”
“That’s rough.” Yelena nodded along while you sighed deeply. “But I have an idea. You two are dressed as Han and Leia, right? And in that movie she tells him she loves him, right? So just do it and see how he reacts. You can play it off as a joke, but if he gets bashful or blushes or acts nervous, then that might mean he feels the same.”
“You’re a genius, Lena!”
“I know, I know.” She joked and reached out to pat herself on the shoulder. “And if I run into you two again, I can definitely drop some hints, make some allusions to you two acting like a couple all the time. You know, like I usually do.”
“Are you sure it will work?”
“No, but it’s worth a shot, right? You are in love with him, so it’s worth it.”
“I sure am in love with him.”
You took a deep breath and turned to look for Bucky, spotting him at the buffet table. It seemed that Sam had spotted him and had stirred Redwing, who he’d dressed as a ghost with a white sheet draped over it, toward Bucky to bother him. Bucky was swatting at the drone while Sam cackled in the background not far away. You quickly took the chance and walked over, getting between Bucky and the drone to shoo it away. Sam eventually steered it into the other direction and you flipped him off, earning yourself more laughter from him.
“Thanks for shooing the ghost of Redwing away.” Bucky chuckled softly, making your heart leap into your throat again before eyeing your costume. “Who are you?”
Taking a deep breath, you took your helmet off and grinned up at Bucky with a proud expression. “Someone who loves you.”
Bucky stilled for a second and you quickly scanned his face for any hint of emotion. His eyes flickered away from you at your words and he licked his lips like he did when he was nervous. Part of your brain was screaming at you about how this meant that he liked you as more than a friend. But the more logical side of it reminded you that he might be nervous because he didn’t have feelings for you and your words had made him uncomfortable. The thought made your heart sink but you had to ask if he was alright.
“You good there, Bucky?”
“Your costume’s amazing, Doll. I get why you wanted it to be a surprise. And before I forget, Joaquin wants to see your costume, so you should show it to him later.” He said and your smile grew at his signature nickname for you. “I bet you’re so happy you got to use that quote.”
“I totally am! I love that we’re both dressed as Star Wars characters.”
“You two are Han and Leia!”
Both of you turned to find Bob approaching, dressed as a vampire and with a giddy smile on his lips. Behind him followed Yelena and Natasha, who were dressed as the other twin from The Shining. As they came over, Yelena gave Bucky a wide grin.
“You two go to a Halloween party dressed in a couple’s costume and then wonder why people think you are a couple.”
“I swear, it wasn’t on purpose. You know I was planning my costume in secret, Yelena.” You said in fake amusement. On the one hand, you were thankful for Yelena’s attempt to get you two together by making comments about you acting like a couple as she’d promised. But on the other hand, the part of your brain that was trying to convince you that Bucky didn’t feel the same way about you was winning and you didn’t want to make him even more uncomfortable, so you tried to play it off. “It was a coincidence.”
“Coincidence or fate?” Came Natasha’s voice as she also decided to join the conversation, standing right next to Yelena which made them look straight out of the movie scene. “I mean, if you two really didn’t plan this, which I am not totally convinced of, then isn’t it a sign from the universe that you two just happened to show up in a couple’s costume?”
Next to you, Bucky shook his head at their words, making your heart sink even further. “How many times do we have to tell you guys that we’re just friends? We are not a couple, no matter what we do or say or dress up as.”
This was it, the last nail in the coffin. His words proved that he had no romantic feelings for you. Now you had the confirmation that he’d just been uncomfortable because of your words, not because he was secretly also in love with you. Tears sprang to your eyes but you blinked rapidly against them. He couldn’t know how you felt because that would definitely ruin your friendship and that was the worst thing that could happen. You had to say something to get out of this situation before you ruined everything even more, so you took a deep breath to gather yourself.
“Exactly.” You tried hard to keep the sadness out of your voice but you knew you sounded dejected, although you were still smiling at your friends. “Now stop harassing us. I got to go find Joaquin and show him my costume now anyway.”
“I just found you.” Bucky protested weakly and when you looked up at him he looked almost sad but you couldn’t understand why. He’d been so adamant about not being your partner, so him looking so upset confused you. “Let’s get something to eat.”
“I see Joaquin just over there. Let me talk to him really quick and then I’ll be right back.” Everything was so confusing and you just had to get out of this situation, if only for a few minutes. You patted Bucky’s chest and promised to be back. “Just give me a few minutes.”
With that, you hurried off, leaving Bucky with Yelena, Natasha and Bob while you made your way toward Joaquin. When he saw your heartbroken expression, he gave you a concerned look.
“You look like you were just told your husband died at sea.” He was trying to make you laugh and you felt terrible for not doing so. “What happened?”
“I’m in love with Bucky.” You confessed. “I started thinking about what you said about me already acting like his girlfriend and then Yelena explained the orange peel theory while I was peeling an orange for him, saying he was my boyfriend and I didn’t correct her. It made me realise that I would really like Bucky to be my boyfriend.”
“I knew it.” Joaquin said under his breath before his face fell into a confused expression. “Wait, why do you look so sad? Have you told him? Has he rejected you?”
“Basically.”
“Basically? So, you haven’t really told him and he hasn’t really rejected you, right?”
“I mean, I told him I’m someone who loves him, like Leia does in the movie—”
“Because you’re a nerd, got it.”
You tried to glare at him but his words got a little chuckle out of you before you shook your head again. “Anyways, I wanted to see if he would act bashful about that or blush or something because Yelena thought it would show me if he feels the same. But he looked nervous, instead. Then Yelena, Natasha and Bob came over, and they talked about us being dressed in a couple’s costume and all that.”
“And he said he doesn’t like you like that?”
“I mean, he didn’t say that exactly.” You explained, trying to make sense of it all despite your confusion. “I said it was a coincidence and that we’re not a couple.”
Joaquin’s mouth fell open. “Why would you say that?”
“Because it’s true and he looked so nervous which means he was uncomfortable with me saying I love him as a joke, so he must not like me like that.”
“Are you a psychic or why do you know why he acted nervous?”
“It was pretty obvious, Joaquin!”
“No, it wasn’t! He could have been nervous for a thousand different reasons. Like, maybe it was too loud for him or maybe he really needed to pee or, I don’t know, maybe he is also in love with you and that’s why he was nervous.”
“He isn’t in love with me. He said we’re not a couple, no matter what we do or what we dress up as, so there.”
“You know you’re one of my best friends and I love you, right?”
“Yes, what does that have to do with anything?”
“Are you stupid?”
“Rude.”
“He said that because you said it was a coincidence and that you weren’t a couple. Bucky probably thinks you don’t like him and that’s why he doubled down on you two not being together, so he won’t make you uncomfortable.”
Your head turned around to where Bucky was still standing and by the looks of it, he was having a heated discussion with his friends, looking absolutely miserable. Maybe Joaquin was right and he was truly in love with you, too. That would also explain his nervousness. And it would explain why he looked so heartbroken right now.
“I just agreed with him and ran off, saying I needed to talk to you.” You whispered, bringing a hand up to cover your mouth. “Bucky tried to get me to stay and I just left. I am such an idiot and I was so afraid of ruining our friendship, that I just ruined any chance we had for ever getting together.”
Joaquin opened his mouth to speak to you but then his eyes drifted from your face to something behind you. “I don’t think you’ve ruined things just yet.”
“What do you mean?”
“Bucky is coming over.”
Your eyes grew wide in panic. “What do I do, Joaquin?”
“Talk to him.” Joaquin said, trying to soothe your fears. You were so scared of ruining everything and he could tell, so he gave you an encouraging smile. “Tell him everything you told me, about how you’re so in love with him, how you want him to be your boyfriend and how you only said those things because you were afraid he didn’t feel the same way.”
Before you could say another word Bucky was right behind you. “Hey, Doll.”
“Hey, Bucky, I’m sorry I kept you waiting for so long. Joaquin wanted to know how I made the chest straps and--” You explained while you turned around but when you saw his expression, your face fell. “What’s wrong, James? Are you alright?”
“Can I talk to you for a second? Just the two of us? We could go onto the balcony. No one’s there.”
“Sure.” You nodded quickly before giving Joaquin a nervous smile. “I’ll talk to you later.”
Joaquin eyed Bucky for a second and then gave you a look that you knew was supposed to be encouraging. “I’m sure this is more important than your costume. I’ll see you later!”
The walk to the balcony was nothing short of nerve-wracking. No matter the outcome of this conversation, you two needed to talk about how you felt and should he not feel the same after all, find a way to navigate your friendship despite your feelings. You could feel your friends all watching you from across the room. When Bucky opened the glass door leading to the balcony, holding it open for you, his hand shook on the glass and you wondered if he was just as terrified as you were. Once outside, you turned to him with a concerned expression before reaching out to take his flesh hand and give it a tight squeeze, trying to ground yourself as well as him.
“You look scared. Do we need to leave?” You asked but Bucky didn’t answer, making you feel even more uneasy. “James, talk to me, please”
“I have something to say.” He blurted out and you blinked in surprise. “You know how everyone always assumes we’re a couple but we tell them we’re not? Well, a few weeks ago Natasha said something about that, telling me I was basically your boyfriend without the benefits and-- and it got me thinking. I’ve been thinking about it for weeks now.”
Your eyes grew wide at his words, at how Natasha had basically told him the same thing Joaquin had said to you, and you could feel your hands shaking as you looked up at him. “My boyfriend without the benefits?”
“It made me realise that we already pretty much act like a couple and I don’t want that to change but I realised that I want the benefits, too.”
You were taken aback by his choice of words. “The benefits? Like getting it on or--”
“No! I mean, if you want to! I mean, I-- Fuck, I used to be so good at this. I’m sorry, let me try again.” Bucky grumbled and squeezed his eyes shut, giving you a second to draw in a steadying breath before he continued to speak. “Natasha’s words and all the teasing from our friends made me think. I want to be with you, hear you say you love me without it being a joke about our costumes and when I didn’t correct that man who called me your boyfriend, I realised I would really like being your boyfriend. And I’m in love with you, Doll.”
You felt like time had stopped. Bucky was in love with you. He felt the same way about you that you felt about him. All this time of fretting over your feelings, of worrying that you’d ruin your friendship, was all swept away in an instant and you felt so relieved that you almost forgot to answer. But then you caught his concerned, almost dejected expression, and despite your heart racing you managed to stammer out and answer.
“You’re in love with me? You want to be my boyfriend?”
“More than anything in the world. Being your boyfriend would be the benefit. I’m so in love with you, Doll.” Bucky confessed before averting his eyes. “I had to be honest with you but if you don’t feel the same, then--”
That wouldn’t do. Bucky thought you didn’t feel the same, already resigning himself to the fate of what he thought was unrequited love for his best friend. But you felt the same for him. You were hopelessly in love with him and because you didn’t trust yourself to speak anymore, you did the only thing you could think of. Before Bucky could get another word out, you placed your hands on his cheeks and pulled him into a fierce kiss.
The feeling of his lips against yours, your bodies pressing close together and his soft cheeks cradled in your hands had your eyes slipping close in almost perfect unison with his own. His arms wrapped around your waist to hold you close, making your stomach flutter. Emboldened by his actions you deepened the kiss, sighing contentedly against his lips as you poured all your yearning for him into this moment. But sadly, you eventually had to separate to catch your breath. Bucky seemingly didn’t want your kiss to end and followed your head to keep his lips against yours for as long as possible. It made a smile spread on your lips.
“I feel the same way, James. I’m so in love with you it’s unbelievable. I’d be so happy if I could be your girlfriend.” You confessed before he could get another word out while keeping yourself close to him and placing your hands on his shoulders as you pursed your lips in amusement. “You know, Joaquin actually called me your girlfriend without the benefits and it got me thinking. I realised I’m in love with you, too. I’m so glad you feel the same.”
“Does that mean we can tell our friends that we really are a couple now?”
“Absolutely.” For a second, your eyes flickered back to the doors to the balcony where you spotted all of your friends watching from inside the Watchtower. Then you let your gaze drop to his lips again. “I really want to kiss you again but all of our friends have gathered behind that glass door to watch us and it’s quite frankly a little uncomfortable.”
It seemed that Bucky hadn’t even realised that you had an audience and a quiet chuckle escaped his lips as he turned to look at the glass door, too. You followed his gaze and it made your heart leap into your throat when he let out a full-on laugh upon seeing most of your friends quickly scatter to pretend that they hadn’t been spying on you two. The exceptions were Natasha who clapped her hands with an excited smile and Sam next to her who gave Bucky a thumbs up.
“Maybe we can continue this later on.”
“I’ll hold you to that.” You sighed softly, leaning your head against his chest and squeezing him tightly. “I’m so happy you’re my boyfriend.”
“And I’m glad you’re my girlfriend.”



















