Collin and Penelope Fics Pt 2
Last Updated 5/3/26
Ran out of room on my last list so I'm starting a new one here! I do not own any of these fics these are just recs. Some summaries have been shortened to save space.
Knock First by Lilyofthevolume
Penelope and Colin are tired of being interrupted by his catty secretary, Marina. What happens when they stop caring about getting caught?
for you are my fate by maxmayfield
After dancing with Penelope at a society ball for the first time, Colin begins to see his friend in a new ligh
I Wanna Be Yours (Polin Prompts) by Lovelymagnolia
just a bunch of polin prompts
The One With Colin's Flemish Kiss by bridgertonbabe
Colin's secret relationship with Penelope is nearly rumbled when he slips up and kisses his girlfriend in front of his sisters-in-law. In order to cover up his blunder he makes a bold impulsive choice to provide Kate and Sophie with a distraction - but it's a choice which his brothers don't take kindly to in the slightest. Friends AU
and it was all yellow by ninjamanda
Canon divergent AU one-shot where Colin and Pen actually "communicate" and talk through their issues on their wedding night!
all the strings attached by penelopecolin (sexymonk)
Penelope struggles to draw boundaries with her new roommate - and when Colin starts behaving peculiarly towards her, she finds herself headed for a downward spiral.
The Honeymoon Period by Rachel_writes_plays
A little story about one specific day between the ending of episode 8 and the events of the epilogue.
blue dress on a boat by missparker
Penelope's efforts to find herself a husband on the marriage mart are going poorly. Benedict Bridgerton needs a wife they strike a deal to marry. Colin comes home from his travels to discover the engagement, he handles it poorly, to say the least.
Broken Glass by Radomizedusername
When a happily married Colin and Penelope briefly move back into the Bridgerton house during the late stages of Penelope's pregnancy, Anthony finds his temper rising. He expected that he would hardly notice their presence back in his home. Little did he realize he would hardly notice anything else.
Six Pomergrante Seeds by jerrymander
Colin's heartbreaking words to Penelope lead her to make different choices just days away from their wedding.
Friends, Foes, and Fernes by Mariequitecontrarie
When Colin and Penelope run into Lord Debling as a couple for the first time, their awkward conversation unearths lingering doubts and insecurities.
Matchmaker by Readingchef45
how Eloise ensures that Penelope will be her sister from the ages of 9 to 25.
wherever you will go by nojamhands
Penelope's job requires her to finally settle in London, while Colin's asks him to take on one last trek to the Pacific. When Penelope doesn't hear from him for nearly two weeks, she starts to panic, then gets a phone call that changes the course of her life forever
still i can't get enough. by stolemystark17
Anthony is looking for his Viscountess and Penelope made the list. Colin does not care for this development. (But not because he's courting her).
The Family Life by alexxou_stories24
One-shots about married/parents Polin (Regency/Modern/Fluff/Smut).
you got me overnight (just let me be close to you) by marriedpolin (bisexualoliviab)
Or, a 5+1 fic about respecting the sanctity of a shared bedchamber.
EpiPen by everlarktoast
Five times Bridgertons decide to stop eating nuts, and the time Colin realizes he’d given them up a long time ago.
When Lady Whistledown has a hangover by Luna1994
Penelope looked at the paper confused, it was the newspaper of Lady Whistledown.
"I would like to end this edition with probably the most scandalous thing that happened in last night’s ball, Penelope Featherington had a change on her appearance, I would not blame you dear reader for not noticing it, this author often forgets her existence, however Colin Bridgerton apparently did notice it, the two of them were seen in a dark corner
Juvenile Assumptions by NLovett
The one where Hyacinth runs away from home...yeah, all the way to Colin & Penelope's house across the square.
To London on Brooding Wings by FrenEdits95
As her world slowly devolves into a haze of lust, blood, and what can only be described as madness, she finds herself wondering if she should let her friends help her or if she should try and save them from herself.
The Love of Older siblings by Remus2039
This is a version of how Kanthony reacts to the lovers quarrel of Polin. And Kanthony's affection for Pen.
All Will Be Well by BritishGirl93
Polin AU - Medieval times
Promise Me by Jennnnyyyy
Penelope is nearing child birth and is worried that Colin might have to make a difficult choice, she has Benedict promise to be there and decide instead.
The First Draft by kws136
Colin is privy to the first drafts of the letters Pen wrote to his mother. He doesn't handle it well. Then again, maybe he does.
Twelve Days of Polin Christmas by 12daysofPolinChristmas
Thirteen authors, thirteen fics, and a LOT of birds ...
Echoes of You by Penny_Feathers_Bright
A fluffy oneshot where Edmund meets Penelope before the events of the main series.
Sugar by lixabix, wantisamlindyla
In which Colin slowly, inadvertently, and inevitably becomes Penelope’s sugar daddy.
Romancing ever after by georgialee006
Colin Bridgerton had been a fool to not realise what had been before him all that time. He loved his wife more than anything, and the life they had built. Yet often he wondered why he hadn’t known sooner that she was the one.
There Goes My Life by Jennnnyyyy
Agatha Bridgerton has an admirer and a crush - Colin goes a little haywire with the help of Anthony.
Fighting Over Miss Featherington by Mariequitecontrarie
Tired of Colin pouting and Penelope deflecting, Eloise decides to take matters into her own hands.
Hearts and Flowers Ball by Cassandra_of_Troy
I saw someone saying it was a crime for Colin not to see Penelope in the pink dress at the Aubrey Hall ball and this story was born.
You Are Mine by Littlepearlfairy
What if instead of Marina finding herself pregnant and unwed at the beginning of the season, it's Penelope?
A Picture of You by Mariequitecontrarie
Colin Bridgerton has a secret. He’s in love with his best friend, Penelope Featherington, and no one knows. Fine, one person knows, but he’s been threatened with fratricide if he breathes a word. Time and the courage to confess his feelings to Penelope are all Colin needs.
romancing miss featherington by penelopecolin (sexy monk)
After a mortifying conversation forces Penelope to publish Colin Bridgerton's embarrassingly loud declaration that he would never marry her in her column. Penelope resigns herself to spinsterhood, eager to seek solace in the safety of the shadows. If only the third-born Bridgerton would stop trying to apologize.
12 Days of Chrismas Cookies by Readingchef45
Colin and Penelope have an annual tradition: they meet up every other day in December to bake 12 different Christmas cookies.But on the 12th year two things are different.
1. Penelope has a boyfriend: Alfred Debling, a vegan who doesn't appreciate a good, buttery Christmas cookie. 2. Colin is, in fact, desperately in love with his redheaded best friend.
Through Scarlet Stains (You Found Us) by ArtistiqueReader12
5 times Colin got away with murder and the one time Pen caught him.
I Scream at You in Poetry by indiaalphawhiskey
or, Penelope is a storm Colin is determined to weather. A different take on the entrapment of it all.
My Only Wish by Poleverse
Penelope Featherington gets invited to stay 22nd-25th for the Bridgerton's Christmas Party. What she wasn't expecting is her long time crush, Colin Bridgerton to be back so soon from traveling abroad.
you're the measure of my dreams by theartistprince
After Penelope leaves the Bridgerton House to celebrate Christmas with her own family, Eloise is determined that by next Christmas, Penelope will be on her way to becoming a Bridgerton. She sets Penelope up with her single siblings, excluding Colin.
Field of Dandelions by Minathewise
Soulmate AU - soulmates occasionally tastes what the other is eating aka Colin tastes Pens tears.
Thank you Tiny Basset by Solaria_Flare
Important realizations are had, as Colin watches Penelope interact with his nephew.
Time Traveling Lord by Remus2039
Polin. Time travelling. Mystery. Canon Divergence. More fluff, less angst.
Add Soul as Needed by Auburnwolf
They haven't spoken since their wedding day and this distance is starting to take its toll on them both emotionally and physically, until Penelope has an idea. What could possibly attract Colin Bridgerton besides herself? Food
It Was All Yellow by urkrainianironbelly
Colin Bridgerton is about to become a father, and he’s absolutely certain that his future child’s nursery should be decorated in the happiest colour known to mankind - yellow. There’s just one tiny problem.
Rewriting Fate by WinterWidow
In an alternate universe of the Bridgerton world, Penelope Featherington marries Mr. Douglas Walker at the outset of her first season in society, leaving her dreams of becoming Lady Whistledown behind. When she returns to London to support her sister-in-law Felicity’s debut, she unexpectedly reunites with Colin Bridgerton,
Upon Further Consideration of Penelope Featherington by CosmicMuncher69
An annulment, an unexpected pregnancy and one hasty decison finds Penelope sequestered away to a cozy cottage atop a hill in hopes of setting those she holds most dear free from the consequences of her pen, though they don't intend to be freed from her so easily. Least of all Colin.
I Would Give You The Moon by nogonnagothere
The one where Pen takes a lover and Colin handles it about as well as anyone could expect (gets down on his knees and begs her to fuck him instead)
I'll Hold You, I'll Know You by Lovelymagnolia
In which, Colin reads Penelope's journal, and learns what was going through her head during their fallout.
The Fresh Air of the Countryside by tartheyes
After the end of the 1815 social season, Colin and Penelope decide to spend the off-season at Audrey Hall. Meanwhile, the rest of the Bridgerton family, including the newly arrived Viscount and Viscountess, reunite with Pen for the 1st time since the news of who is LW. A fun story of happily married Polin, spending time with the family, and falling into the usual Bridgerton chaos we know and love.
the blacken soulmark by penelopecolin (sexymonk)
Penelope Featherington's soulmark is black.And it's all his fault
A Brotherly Conversation by goyaliz49
Anthony and Benedict notice their brother’s exhausted and sleep deprived state. So they take him to White’s shortly after he returns from his honeymoon. The third born son appears to be morose and listless. What could possibly be troubling him?
Hide, Seek, Confess Et All by emikowrites
When a game of hide and seek at a Bridgerton birthday party turns into a chaotic chase, Penelope Featherington finds herself constantly cornered by the one person she’s trying to avoid—Colin Bridgerton.
mirrorball by headphonesbaby
Or the one where Colin starts to dress and act like his good friend Penelope's newest boyfriend.
Meant to be by Booklover1217
Penelope had no last name. Left in the woods at only four years old to die, a now twenty-two year old Penelope has been travelling the continent as a healer, with no memory of her past. That is until she meets a handsome nobleman in the markets and her entire world changes, and all the secrets that she had thought lost to the past are slowly revealed.
falling backwards in time, leaping downward to the altar by pain_somnia
“Did I really used to wear my hair like this?” Colin muttered, twirling a curl between two fingers as examined his reflection. A thought came to him and he tugged on a single strand until he yanked it out, feeling the sting on his scalp. “Shit!”
Don't want no other shade of blue but you by CVHsQuill
Colin’s unhinged ways get in the way of their happy ending.
Snow for Christmas by AmyB_Writes
Penelope has spent half of her life alone in love with Colin Bridgerton. In an unexpected development, she finds herself falling into a friends with benefits relationship with his brother, Benedict.
Pick a Card by Fifi2930
"Why did you invite me here?"
"Penelope."
"Don't Penelope me. What do you want from me?"
"Why have you been ignoring me for two weeks?"
Because of Aunt Bille by Honeycat80
Colin slightly despondent the day after the Hearts and Flowers ball goes for a walk and has a conversation that helps to slightly change his perspective.
Losing Count by Brave3001
Penelope knows how many times she has shared tea with Colin. She knows the number of times they have danced, knows how many times he touched her before they were engaged, how many letters they have written, how many crystal goblets they received as wedding gifts. She did not know he knew how many sugars she takes in her tea. That is something for which she did not account.
The Devil (Didn't make me do it) by StrawberryWhorecake
Penelope has accidentally joined a cult. A hapless, bumbling family cult that has her tied up as a “virgin” sacrifice to a demon. Never mind that she’s neither a virgin nor remotely devout: they insist she’s the chosen one. But the real surprise isn’t the ritual; it’s Colin, a shy, awkward demon who might be the least terrifying thing about this whole fiasco.
everything a heart could hold by everyusernameistakensoidk
After seven months of gruelling pregnancy, Penelope is finally about to give birth to their first child. There's only one problem: her husband, Colin, is nowhere to be found.
How About Forever by Holiday_Hustle
After the Butterfly Ball, Colin assumed that his marital troubles with Penelope were behind them. He assumed incorrectly.
Closeted by chickcentra1
Its the Bridgerton Sisters monthly night out. What happens if Penelope decides she doesn't want to go and the girls (mostly Eloise) don't know how to take no for an answer? Well you just show up at her flat unannounced and attempt to drag her out, naturally. So how did all seven sisters get trapped in this coat closet anyhow?
Rock a Bow Baby by chickcentra1
What happens when a brothers fishing trip to celebrate Anthony Bridgerton's new bass boat is hijacked by a VERY pregnant Penelope Bridgerton? Brothers, banter and..... Bedlam befitting the best of Bridgerton births.
Moments by somethingfunnybubbly
How one week at Aubrey Hall over the holidays changes Penelope's brain chemistry (and heart).
the only girl in the world by DollyPop
Colin leaves a night out with his brother confused, displeased- Other. To take a mistress- what could possibly be the appeal? How could he even think to stay there a moment longer, when the very thought made him sick? And recalls her, Penelope, the love of his life, fresh from reaching her pinnacle at his hand, staring at the clean palm he outstretched to her with eyes wide as a lamb's, asking him But won't your family see me?
the life behind by abvj
Colin comes home to his wife, clearly bothered, after his night out at White's. A quiet, honest conversation ensues. And then some.
Highwayman on the Hill by queenofthecon
Penelope Featherington is many things. A wallflower. A third daughter. A spinster. But when she is taken for ransom by a band of fascinating highwaymen, a man alone among them will make sure she will never again be the one thing she always thought she was. Unwanted.
they don't write a handbook for this by abvj
The plan is this: come home, get a real job, stop running away from the only woman he has ever truly wanted, and make Penelope Featherington see him as something other than her goofy, perpetually wandering best friend.
a very good man, indeed by grapefruitblues
Colin leaves his night out with his brothers and friends feeling unsettled after their talk about mistresses, and rushes home to tell Penelope everything.
The Scheduled Affair by betweendrafts
When Penelope finds out her husband is cheating on her, she wants to leave the marriage. Unfortunately for her husband the timing could not be worse. They come up with a compromise.
Closeted by chickcentra1
Its the Bridgerton Sisters monthly night out. What happens if Penelope decides she doesn't want to go and the girls (mostly Eloise) don't know how to take no for an answer?
Rock a Bow Baby by chickcentra1
What happens when a brothers fishing trip to celebrate Anthony Bridgerton's new bass boat is hijacked by a VERY pregnant Penelope Bridgerton?
I Choose Us Every Time by Zalovelymagnolia
What if Colin and Penelope reconciled a little earlier in episode 8?
Love Is Make-Believe by preferringsleep(mellarkey)
Penelope isn’t a high-priced escort like her friend, Genevieve. But when presented with an opportunity to earn some money just to keep a client’s friend entertained, she thought, “Why not live a little?” Genevieve promised Penelope that it was just dinner and drinks for her, no sex. So what happens when she meets her date and discovers that he is sweet, gorgeous, and wants her for the night?
The Ballad of the Singing Wind by ffygresw
What if, one day, a princess did not fall for a fearless knight or a charming prince? What if, instead, she gave her heart to a dragon—no less mesmerizing, yet far more untamed?
there you are by abvj
Colin and Penelope navigate the aftermath of 4x07.
Stay (For as Long as You Can)
Penelope is shaken by the quiet suddenness of John's death and becomes terrified that she might wake one day to find Colin gone the same way. Her fear keeps her watching him through the night until Colin confronts her, reminding her that love cannot be protected by vigilance.
Sleeping Where I Might Find You by KatofKanals
Or, the one where Colin is a sleepwalker and his sleepwalking plays a very important role in Polin finding their happily ever after.
cent'anni by applepuffsilver
the night before they elope, Colin comes to visit Penelope in her bedroom 1950s Mafia AU
See Me In Hindsight by Holiday_Hustle
Penelope is certain that Colin, who has been her friend with benefits for the last two years, is on a date.
So what is he doing waiting for her at Bridgerton House?
we are alone with our changing minds by uneventfulhouse
the one where colin get's pen's name tattooed and realizes he's in love with her.
Healing Process by catandcandle
Penelope is hurt in an accident. Colin takes care of her.
Persistent Babe by NLovett
Penelope Bridgerton had been told that childbirth for the second time could be slightly easier than the first, but holy moly she did not expect to wake up with their babe this persistent to come into the world!
Codine Confession by MistressofNone3645
Penelope flirts too hard and ends up in the emergency room. Pain killers and a long-standing crush on her good friend make it an interesting night.





















