Confidence and Masculinity
I've been having a lot of shower thoughts lately. Most recently about masculinity and previously about confidence.
Firstly, I had the thought, "Can one lose confidence once they've had it?" and, on a micro level, of course, I was once confident in my ability to do certain physical tasks that I am no longer confident at achieving because of a lack of practice. But 'confidence' as a trait, as a quality of oneself, on a macro level, can one lose that confidence?
It got me thinking about the flow of my life, and how, at one point in my life, I had a real bad case of what I now call "The cis het white mans". That is to say, the unearned confidence that cis het white men have because their privilege doesn't allow them to receive humbling experiences the same way as other demographics might. That is something I will be wrestling with indefinitely, but I feel confident saying that I have grown past (at least) a part of that.
I've always been the "SJW" of my friend groups. When that phrase first entered the common vernacular when I was in high school I was often called that, alongside "hipster" and other similar monikers. For the most part I was happy to be called those things and, looking back, am thankful for it because, ultimately, they chipped away at that cis het white man armor that I had. They softened me and made me open to the concept of other peoples suffering. This came to head in my early 20's when I dated a women who was blessed with a lot of sexual liberation when she entered college. It put a lot of pressure on me to be receptive and understanding to things I had never considered up until that point in my life. Further chipping away at that armor. Furthermore, this all came to a breaking point in my mid 20's when I lived with another very strong women who felt no fear calling me out on my shit.
Neither her nor I were ever perfect and I inherited a lot of bad habits and mindsets, as well as good ones, during that experience, but at the end of it all I am very thankful for all of it. To put it frankly, my cis het white man armor was finally broken, or at least I realized just how fragile it was, how it didn't really protect me from anything and that I needed to start from scratch building up who I thought I was.
So to bring it all back around, can you lose confidence on a macro level? Yes and no? I had confidence on a macro level, but it was false confidence. It was unearned confidence. Confidence I had because I had never had to face myself in all of my darkness, faults, and insecurities. Confidence I had put up as a shield to protect myself from the traumas of my childhood that I can't even remember now. So, if you were to ask me right now, was I truly confident? No. True confidence, the unshakeable confidence that one cannot lose. The macro confidence that comes from your chest. That confidence is only earned once one realizes that their worth comes from their own existence. I think the most unshakeable confidence one can have in themselves is when we finally realize that we are worthwhile, deserving, and purposeful in and of ourselves. Regardless of anything else. Everyone deserves to feel worthy simply because they exist.
So that's the confidence point. Frankly, I can't remember how this tied in to the point I wanted to make about masculinity but i'm sure it will come back to me as I ramble.
So, on to masculinity. I've been thinking a lot about masculinity and my manhood lately. I teeter back and forth as to whether or not I identify with manhood and masculinity. And frankly, I don't have a theoretical understanding of gender studies to feel like I can say anything about it confidently. but here are my thoughts as I understand them now.
I often FEEL like a man. And occasionally DON'T feel like I identify with masculinity. but is that because western masculinity has been so poisoned that it's hard to separate healthy masculinity from the mess that is outside of that? When i DON'T feel like i identify with it, is it because i'm realizing that I don't identify with the qualities of toxic masculinity presented to me? If that is the case, then what are the secure masculinity traits that I do identify with?
Recently I mentioned in a different post that I might feel non-binary at times. But, really, i don't think i do. I think i'm just struggling to separate the masculinity that I do feel versus that masculinity that I no longer identify with. And wrapped all up in that is learning to accept the feminine traits that are a part of me as well.
I guess what i'm trying to say is that gender as a whole concept feels really ambiguous and pointless to me. It really seems like it would be better if we all existed on a spectrum and didn't bother with gendered terms or ideas because it's all based on arbitrary cultural understandings of something that was arbitrarily made up by culture in the first place.