Now~ my dear students, before I begin I would like to clarify that you are all free to disagree with what I am about to say. However, if you have a problem holding onto rp partners you may want to lend me your ear and perhaps consider what I have to say. Any information I am about to share with you is information I have gathered from many years as an rper myself. These are things I have noticed along my travels that seem to be a common problem for OCs and OCCs and a reason some rpers of canon characters may be weary to rp with them.
When making an OC it is important to keep your story straight. Writing up a bio before you begin to rp is always a good thing. I personally will not follow an OC that does not have a bio. Why? Because it's like jumping on a bus without knowing where it's going.
Now don't start thinking it's just me~ I have a great deal of friends that are also like this and know many other people that will simply refuse to so much as talk to an OC without a bio. It's not just OCs either I know a lot of people who want nothing to do with canon characters without a bio as well.
Bios give us rpers something to work with. It gives us an idea of what your character is capable of and what we can expect while writing with them. Bios are your friend. Do not fear the bios.
"Ah! But Mr. Faust my character is supposed to be a mystery and one should get to know them by talking to them~ :D"
Bullshit. That is little more than a cop out. However if you don't want to write a bio it is, at the end of the day, up to you. Just don't complain when no one wants to rp with you.
So you have decided to write a bio~? Fantastic! But what are you going to say? Well a good place to start is where we all start. The past or their background. Tell us a little about their child hood.
"Orphaned as a child. Watched parents die. Is half angel, half demon, half elf. Holder of the long lost eighth millennium item."
Whoa! Hold on now. If I may~
Orphaned has been done. Now there is nothing wrong with having an orphaned character but do keep in mind it is somewhat cliche at this point. If that is going to be part of the background for your character try to spice it up a little. Perhaps not make the rest of their past as tragic. I can not tell you how many OCs I have seen with the same exact tragic background.
As for the half half half please see below~
Now. There was something about jumbling up a bunch of things onto one, yes? Ah~ Well. You see... that too has been quite over done. Now! There is nothing wrong with having a hybrid character but... do at least pick a hybrid that makes sense... If you can not rationalize why a demon and an angel got it on and made a baby don't do it! Being a demon myself I can already tell you it is quite unlikely for an angel and demon to, erm.... do the do. Human and demons are a fine hybrid though this has also been done a lot both canon and OC but it makes sense!
I think the biggest problem people have with hybrids is they try to give them all the powers of both parents and that simply does not work. A few powers from each parent would be more appropriate. Also do not make a hybrid more powerful than the strongest pure bread and do not give them full control of their powers right off the bat. Power is obtained through years of training and hard work. There is nothing more annoying than a character with every power. -cough-Ichigo-cough-bleach-cough- Excuse me.
Just like with backgrounds try to avoid cliches. If you have seen it done a million times perhaps it is wise you try something else.
Don't do it. DON'T DO IT. Unless it is AU and all parties are in agreement DO NOT CONTRADICT WHAT IS IN CANON.
For example: There are seven millennium items canon in Yu-Gi-Oh! Duelist. Do not make a character with the eighth millennium item. ... er... well... you can.... but prepared. Some people may be fine with it and that is all well and good, however, some might not be so open to the idea. From what I have seen many rpers don't like it when you contradict canon.
Another example is there are Eight demon kings in Ao no Exorcist it is probably best not to make a ninth, tenth, or three hundredth king. Sure you can, but idon't expect everyone in the fandom to like or accept it. there are some people who like things to remain as close to canon as possible. Do NOT send them hate about it. Just as you are free to do as you please they are free to rp with who they want.
"Free? You just listed a bunch of things not to do!"
Ah~ that I did. But these are mere guidelines. Whether or not you chose to follow them is strictly up to you. We are all free do do as we wish in this wonderful world of roleplay~ but do not expect everyone to agree with your character or want to roleplay with your character. The above are simply common complaints I have seen.
Now before you get the wrong idea I have had my fair share of OCs and OCCs in my many years of roleplay. Some people didn't like them and some people did. In fact one of my most popular ones was a rather over powered character but his power was balanced by weaknesses.
Balance in a character is important. Perhaps your character can control time and space, for example of course, but that character feels no desire to use such power. That is balance. Maybe your character is unable to die, but he can be incapacitated. That is balance. You can have vastly overpowered characters but give them a reason not to use their power or give them something that counteracts that power a little. Give then a restraint.
One final point I would like to make is BE CONSISTENT. Now what does dear old Johann mean by that~? Well let me explain~
Keep your characters abilities, bios, backgrounds, and power consistent! It isn't fair to those you rp with to constantly be changing what your character is and isn't capable of when/if it suits you. Now development is one thing. To have a character gradually learn a new power is fine but it should be foreshadowed and put somewhere in that handy little bio of yours so other rpers can expect it. However, if just suddenly POOF your character has a new power out of no where there is a good chance people are going to call bullshit.
You can't just change your character out of the blue and expect everyone to be okay with that. It isn't fair. Before you make any changes make sure your rp partners know about it before hand. Rp is about communication after all.
"But this is what I want! It's my OC! I can do what I want, you elitist prick!"
Is this what you are thinking~? Well before you hit that anon button and type me up a rude, grammatically incorrect, strongly worded ask allow me to explain~
Whether or not you take my advice is up to you. I can not actually hold your hand and tell you how to write for your OC. Clear~? I am simply sharing things I have learned along the way to make your rp lives a bit more enjoyable and to, hopefully, help you avoid ooc drama with other rpers.
It is true that you are the only one who can write your OC but I have seen so many people complain about canon characters not rping with OCs that I wanted to highlight a few common complaints I have seen about OCs.
In all honesty I am sick of seeing OCs acting like martyrs. OCs have been given a bad reputation because often they are abused. They are given too many powers and they change their abilities left and right and they all have the same cliche tragic background.
I personally like OCs but only when they are done well and not forced down my throat.
Remember, I also have run OC blogs so don't think I haven't been there, because I have. I am not picking on OCs I am just trying to give guidance on how to make your rp time more enjoyable and what canon rpers look for in OCs in case you are interested in rping with canon characters.
I have seen many successful OCs and there are many OCs I and many others enjoy rping with.
There are OCs I like and some I don't but there are also canon characters I like and some I don't. It's simply a mater of taste.