a little thing on robert's scheming and where it could go.
listen i know people are fed up with home farm because of the whites and robert's lunatic schemes back then, but i truly believe that, aside from aaron, home farm will always be robert's endgame bc in the grand scheme of things he needs to break the cycle of father/son trauma jack started and, for that to happen, robert has to deal with the father/son trauma he has with his own son, seb.
i mean, the mill was liv's house, first and foremost. they got it for her, so she could have a home. it was the embodiment of roblivion and, after robert went to prison, aaron and liv's dysfunctional relationship. to be quite honest with you, i'm done with the mill. it has served its purpose. i think it would be much more interesting character-wise to have robert eventually scheme whoever it is out of home farm so he can finally become the mr. emmerdale he always saw his father as and prove he can be the better man (plus robert will never be a farmer like jack but at home farm he could keep the theme and remain the white collar demon he is, bc lets be real robert will never be one of the silly villagers pulling pints or serving coffee for a living, like no disrespect, but that's just how it is)
then the sugden father/son trauma cycle could restart (bonus points if robert and aaron have an adopted kid by then for the andy/robert parallels) and that would give robert plenty of opportunities to right the wrongs of his father (which he will both succeed and fail at, just like jack did, because the whole point of their trauma cycle is for robert to understand that no, he isn't destined to become his father, but to understand that jack was just as fallible as he is and that maybe someday robert can find it in himself to forgive him) not to mention, a big home farm era would ensure ryan renewed his contract every year for the foreseeable because he would have to stay for divorce 4.0 and wedding 5.0 and reunion 9.0 and all future murder attempts.
and what murder attempts are those, you ask? well if andy returns we can put at least 2 in there for fun, and bc robert will be vying for something that has tate heritage attached to it (home farm and maybe the haulage too) caleb, kim and joe (if he stays that long) will also try to eliminate him, so we can put another 5 attempts in there. next, if the writers grow some balls and unearth the guy who robert had his bisexual awakening with when he was young (maybe he shows up at home farm again and now robert is the one in charge hehe), we will have aaron trying to kill both of them because cunty and possessive is my favorite aaron flavor, so there goes another one. then when seb is old enough, he will try to kill robert at least a couple of times bc that's how sugdens roll, they gotta have a little tension in the family innit.
and at this point you will say, wow rena you must be a terrible human being, just total irredeemable trash, because how could you wish this on robert and aaron after everything they went through, don't you want them to heal and live happily ever after with their kid(s)? and my answer will be yes, i want that so much, but i also need the toxic Juice⢠to keep me going bc in 2018 they tried to tone them down after reunion 2.0 and my interest plummeted instantly. i will beg, cry and scream for them to never be boring again. i don't care how bad it gets, it's not like i will ever receive any financial compensation from itv to pay for my therapy bills, so fuck it.
they can pepper in a few comedic, light-hearted plots once in a while for dryan to clean house, have seb and eve parent-trap them 48374 times, robert lose it over aaron's cancer gene thing (the sleeper-cell plot that is going to kill us all), or finally give them (and by them i mean aaron) a dog. i want it all, but please never let them become boring again! don't leave me juiceless! if they take away robert's scheming and aaron's paranoia we wil be left with b-plots forever e.g. the big IVF bore, random illnesses, car accidents, rogue farm animals, or, god forbid, a surprise long-lost child from some random woman. the show is good now bc having robert back after so long allows them to weave a lot of intricate plots together and hold over us the will-they-won't-they robron carrot for as long as they want to, but i want to remind you that it can all get really bleak, really fast when the show shifts its main focus away from our favs.
so bring on the mess! bring on the drama! don't be afraid of bad robert and his stupid schemes. let us feast! we know robert can be good and honorable when he wants to, but he wouldn't be robert if he wasn't a chaos entity half the time. he needs enrichment (being a devil) to thrive (repent and grow). so don't let the home farm trauma of times past prevent you from enjoying the song of our people -> robron being messed up FOREVER.
like, not to get all poetic and shit, but robert was made to be icarus always reaching for the impossible (jack's approval), and aaron to be the sea that robert plunges back into (the unconditional love that makes robert sacrifice himself for). even after they reunite, robert won't stop being the scheming cunt he is. that's how he survived all those years after jack sent him away. scheming is his coping mechanism, and isn't it beautiful how aaron is the only one who can reason with him, the perfect opposite of jack, the one who always forgives him, the one who fills the sarah-shaped void in robert's heart [robert was and still is the only thing that ever mattered to aaron, HELLOOOO??! this is a direct quote from the man himself]. anw i just think seeing robert back in home farm would be a great opportunity to delve into his character and wipe the slate clean from all the white drama that happened there, also it wouldn't need to be forever?? the weirdest thing would be watching aaron living posh, but if dawn and billy got used to it, why not aaron? at least he would have enough space for his dog and the 192363638 kids he always wanted.
and it's not that i think robert would never find the motivation to scheme charity out of the pub, or jimmy/caleb from the haulage, or even eric from the store or whatever. it's just that, barring boring plots and a big rehaul of that village, i just don't see robert staying put, living in that ugly flat with aaron and having a social awareness storyline about his prison ptsd. he has too much potential for all that. why would we settle for broken meek robert when he can be all that while juggling at least five different scams at the same time so aaron can yell at him and they can fight and fuck about it?
im sorry i lost the plot halfway thru all this, but im always thinking about long-term robron now that ryan is back indefinitely, so my brain works in very aaronesque ways, hoping that robert will stay until they are 80 or something, and yeah i feel like im in the minority here, wishing every tragic crazy soap'y thing to be thrown at them, but it's only bc i know that at the end of the day it will always be aaron and robert against the world.
btw don't @ me if u don't enjoy mess. i will swallow boring naff robron if i have to because i love them any way, but this is soap man. if robert and aaron don't take turns on the crazy brain cell what's the point?