Yâall really need to let Katara rule a nation
Hi, so I never use Tumblr but I have so many thoughts about this topic and itâs starting to get ridiculous and Iâve decided to solve my problem by ranting on the internet. Okay, so for some context on my point of view as a viewer, I am a multiracial woman. One side of my ancestors was from India and was colonized and brought to the Caribbean as indentured labourers by the British, my grandparents later immigrated to Canada. The other side of my family was settlers from Newfoundland that were forced to move after the mines closed. To sum that up, Iâm part white, part brown, with a shit load of colonization in my history.
With the context of that cultural lens, please understand how much strong badass characters like Katara mean to me. Not only does she have strong morals and is super courageous, BUT HOLY SHIT SHEâS BROWN???!!! AND HER FIGHT IS PUSHING AGAINST COLONIZATION AND IMPERIALISM???!!! Katara is very close to my heart as the woman of color representation Iâve always wanted to see (Which is why Iâm also pissed about what happened to her in LOK but letâs not worry about that right now).
I think that Katara can easily be generalized as âthe good girlâ in the ATLA fandom, especially in comparison to other female characters on the show like Toph, and Azula. Yes, she was extremely motherly, and taking care of others was her main goal, but Katara was never afraid to get into a fight. Letâs not forget, this is the girl that started an earth bender slave riot that ended in liberation, she stole an invaluable scroll from pirates, fought a Master water bender with limited training, fought both of the fire nation royal siblings, destroyed a fire nation factory in the name of environmental justice, mastered blood bending in one night, was part of the invasion during the eclipse, enacted revenge on her motherâs killer, and holy shit how do so many people forget that she defeated Princess Azula, to name a few examples. Katara is not a passive person, she is incredibly passionate regarding her beliefs and protecting her family. Â
Katara very clearly cares about protecting and honoring her culture. She is also not afraid to call out her culture on its own shortcomings, especially regarding sexism. But she also values and cares about protecting other cultures, which can be seen in how she starts earth bender riots and how she dresses as the painted lady to save a poor fire nation village.
I believe Katara would have been an incredible world leader and Itâs really disappointing to see that the rest of the Gaang was recognized after the war as great heroes and world leaders but Katara never got the recognition she deserved. (And donât give me that âitâs because sheâs still aliveâ bullshit cause guess what, so is Zuko and Toph so thatâs a really stupid excuse)
In my ideal world, Zuko and Katara would have been the most badass royal couple that works to create change throughout the four nations. This is another reason why Zutara would have been amazing. There is so much in the show that shows Zuko and Katara build an amazing relationship and I think them perusing a romance would not be OOC at all. But HOLY SHIT CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE POLITICAL RAMIFICATIONS OF THIS COUPLE???
Zuko becoming the Fire Lord means that any relationship he pursues is inevitably going to have some political consequences. Really, on top of the poorly executed relationship between Mai and Zuko, Mai being put in that role of power doesnât really make any huge changes, sheâs from nobility and the members of the Fire Nation that supported Ozai would most likely be in support of Zuko marrying Mai. Mai also never comes to the realization that what Fire Nation was doing was wrong. Yes, she did switch sides, but her only motivation for switching was her relationship with Zuko, not her own view shifting on what the Fire Nation was doing in the war. Throughout the show, Mai is shown to be passive, dismissive, and unfeeling. Her idea to cheer up Zuko is to order around servants and she doesnât show any signs of discomfort when Azula decides to stop negotiating for the return of her baby brother. I donât think that Mai is a bad person, I just donât think it would make sense for Zuko to want to put her in a position of power.
However, putting Katara in that place of power definitely is going to change some things. Over the past century, the Fire Nation had built an image of their superiority and right to rule, having Katara as part of their monarchy shatters this idea. Part of what Iroh teaches Zuko is that the four nations rely on each other in order to maintain balance, Zuko and Kataraâs relationship would be the embodiment of this idea. Both the Fire Nation and the Water Tribes have things they can learn from each other, the Fire Nation is far beyond the Water Tribes in terms of gender equality, with women even being in the army and nobody really has a problem with the idea of Azula becoming the Fire Lord. However, the Water Tribesâ sense of community and lack of a hierarchy is something that both the Fire Nation and the Earth Kingdom could implement more into how they run.
Also Zuko and Katara having mixed-race kids quite literally blends two nations together. One of the things that as a mixed person, I found strange in LOK was how Aang and Kataraâs kids didnât seem to have mixed identities, Tenzin fully embraced his Air Nomad identity while completely disregarding his Water Tribe heritage, Kya embraced her Water Tribe identity and tried to embrace being an Air Nomad but was looked over in favor of Tenzin and Bumi seems to have rejected his roots altogether. Personally, I didnât find it to be a great representation of multiracial people or the difficulty of trying to understand and embrace conflicting identities.
With the knowledge that Zuko is inevitably going to need an heir, itâs definitely going to raise some discussion on who is eligible to take the throne. I believe that Zuko and Katara would all raise their kids to value wisdom and knowledge from different sources because it would seem OOC for either of them not to. Imagine how others would react if they had a water-bending daughter, how would water-bending Fire Lord change the Fire Nationâs image?
I also want to make it clear that Katara and Zukoâs relationship only works because it depends on Katara having agency and independence in her decisions and Zuko striving for change and reparations. In TSR, when Zuko and Katara go to find her motherâs killer, you can see through Zukoâs expressions how he also is angry and disgusted by what the people of his nation have done, even holding on to a shot of him looking at Yon Rah with disgust after Katara has already turned away and left. Zuko striving to create an era of peace and hold the Fire Nation accountable can greatly be supported by Katara being involved. Also, Zuko and Katara getting married and running the Fire Nation is just a great big middle finger to everyone who wanted to keep Ozai in power.
In conclusion, Zuko and Katara being a couple would have an unbelievable impact on the world and the creators were too cowardly to give Katara power.