The Secret Dinner by Raphael Montes
A NetGalley Review
This is definitely on the sillier side of horror but I don't think that's a bad thing! In The Secret Dinner we follow four lifelong friends and roommates who are strapped for cash and need to pay SIX MONTHS OF BACKOWED RENT back ASAP and so they do something pretty unorthodox to make the money in time. Things spiral from there (as things often do) and take turn for the macabre. And these guys simply could not STOP themselves from making their situation worse and worse.
Something I really liked is how the main character, Dante, opened the book by telling his friends a riddle, a word puzzle. The puzzle was basically that a man went to a restaurant, ordered the seagull meat, then went home later and took his own life. Why? Then Dante can only answer yes, no, or irrelevant to his friend's questions until the puzzle is solved. I will not tell you the answer here but the way this riddle tied into EVERYTHING was exceptionally well done.
Also, as we know, I am PRO mixed media in books and I was pretty delighted to see one character wrote letters to his mother (more on that in the book and it's WILD), a recipe forâŚseagull meatâŚ, text threads, dinner invitations, emails, business cards, and a pretty funny picture drawn from when one of the characters was a kid. The chapters were also pretty short an bingeable so I felt like I was absolutely FLYING through this book. And I've been having a tough reading month so I really appreciated that.
There's also the conversation I feel some (if not most, if I'm honest) books regarding cannibalism have of "You eat meat from animals such as pigs, chickens, and cows and don't care about the treatment of those animals, so why is eating humans so taboo?" (This book is assuming people eat meat, if you don't then I love that for you, but clearly this book isn't talking about you. Please don't bean soup me in the comments. I am not currently mentally stable enough to handle it.) Also if anyone out there really wants to ruin their own day check out the episode on Tyson by the podcast Swindled. Anyways. I don't think the book was wrong to bring up this kind of morality issue, I just wish there was more of an original spin on it, I guess?
The only thing that stopped this from being a 5 star read for me is the language was outrageous! Cannibalism? Fine, do what you must. Calling one of the characters a whore and a hooker? Absolutely not! I mean, I guess I don't really know what I expected from four men but they were constantly demeaning one of the characters and talking about her like sex work isn't real work and it was genuinely ANNOYING. And I KNOW, ok, I know that it tied back to the themes of morality and what the characters considered to be right and wrong, when someone was considered human and when they weren't, I get it. But it bothered me regardless. And they also wouldn't stfu about one of the characters being fat. Again, I know, same argument, but we all have stuff that gets under our skin.
Overall, a pretty funny and amusing read and big shout out to the author for having this book translated into English for the first time (this book was originally published in 2016), that's awesome!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read an advance DRC and provide an honest review, all opinions are my own.











