Sam is online, looking for cases when he stumbles across a big conspiracy about the men in black. That they’re real and people have talked/interacted with them before. They come poking around asking if they’ve ‘seen anything weird’ or ‘strange’ especially after murders. Then they just up and disappear, taking whatever creepy thing that was happing in their town with them. They’re used to be two, but nowadays people report one more! A creepy one. The other two where normal guys— big guys sure— but normal guys. The new one is.. weird. Otherworldly. Freaky!
Anyway it takes a few more google searches before Sam and Dean realize they are the men in black everybody’s talking about.















