How you feel about Simon having delusions and going through psychosis?? I’m writing something rn where that whole idea of Grace being worshipped by him is mostly just his brain taking his upbringings and literally meeting something other worldly and it’s breaking his non-religious brain into religious psychosis.
I like the idea in general of Simon dealing with this stuff, even outside bloodymary lenses.
Just curious what you think.
Simon & Psychosis ft. Bloodymary
If you are sensitive to talks of delusion or paranoia, do not read.
Asking a whump writer for abnormal mental health insights is a great idea if you want a wall of text's worth of information dumping, by the way! I'm laying down the "hurt" so you can lay down your "comfort"!
Simon going through psychosis after having his consciousness ripped out of his vaporized body, meeting The Red-Eyed God, hearing it call his name, enter some kind of ambiguous agreement with it, and then getting blipped back like nothing happened, having been (supposedly) kept in it's domain as a forlorn soul for days... is not a far leap to make at all. And that's not even including the rest of the shit he went through during his venture.
Big reason why I HC he'd be mute too. What the hell do you even say after something like that? It would be one sentence total per month, maybe, and it would be to warn people that God is Real, and He is Blood, or The Stars are in the Blood, and They Contain God. Some form of that.
Simon would be considered a nutcase to everyone around him. Especially the COI. Maybe not so much to Grace. I think Grace would see Simon as a very disturbed man, but there's just a scared softie under it all who needs someone to be patient with him. Grace is heavily an optimist. It would be healthy for Simon to not be seen as weak over something like this. Grace may not understand where Simon is coming from all the time, but he'd rather die than let this guy self-destruct on his watch.
Here's a scene that happens directly after Simon "wakes up" from witnessing the God. Homeboy was not okay. Reality wasn't very steady and it was clear he was going into some kind of fugue towards the end as he started to "teleport" around the SM-13 (as visualized by jump-cuts). Those kinds of "loss of time" moments, and Simon' world blurring together, would happen a lot.
Simon's mental state would be near-catatonic, if he survived. He'd suffer from Cotard's Delusion (the belief that he is dead, or a ghost). In neuropsychology, Cotard’s often stems from a disconnect between reality and emotional recognition. Simon wouldn't be able to reconcile the memory of total obliteration with the reality of being alive. I mean, you can hear how absolutely shattered he sounds trying to recount what happened to Ava.
Because of this, Simon would exhibit some strange behaviors:
Extreme nihilism (the "nothing matters" mindset; he'd be weirdly existential for a while after being pulled out of the submersible)
Would potentially hallucinate the smell of blood, or rotten flesh
Would struggle with self-neglect, like refusing food or water (why do self-care to a corpse?)
Simon would be incredibly convinced that his soul belongs to the Red-Eyed God, that it was stolen, or that the souls he damned as the Butcher are talking to him / plotting to "get him" (due to literally listening to them via the hive mind). He would be incredibly paranoid as a result. He would be perpetually waiting for the moment the God decides to drag him back to hell. A sense of being on borrowed time.
Anything regarding the Tree and Eden's doctrine lost all meaning to Simon after that happened. How do you imagine a tree and equate it to the same level as the sky cracking open to make way for a moon-sized eyeball? How do you compare the words of a man (the Father) to witnessing the Absolute? Simon's whole world view got thrown on its head because he saw something no human should have.
Simon was on his way to being an atheist after he left Eden, but then he met the Red-Eyed God. Simon's a "see it to believe it" kind of person after Eden. He definitely saw this.
Simon would full-stop have no idea how to rationalize being saved by Grace and Rocky, and would believe that nothing is real on the Hail Mary / Erid's biodome. Simon might be paranoid that he's suffocating and that it's all a dream. Grace would be dealing with a man who believes he is still in the ocean, and would probably have to try and break him out of PTSD flashback episodes every now and then.
Grace wouldn't mind a little "successfully navigating the tunnels together" roleplay if it helps Simon come out of it.
Simon would be terrified of the water. He'd rather die than go back anywhere near water. Showers are hard. Enclosed spaces are hard. Hearing any kind of mechanical radar blip, flickering light or mechanical voice (GOD FORBID "hull breach" or "BLIP DETECTED") would have him adrenaline dumping. Even if he doesn't mentally respond, the physiological impact of having something so dangerous be engraved into your brain's survival reflex would take a hot minute to kick.
Simon would be standing around like, "...huh. Why am I sweating so much?"
Simon would catch himself staring up into the corners of rooms aboard the Hail Mary, waiting for Grace's voice to come from an overhead speaker, even when Grace is standing right in front of him. He'd catch himself refusing water because there "isn't enough" even when there is. Grace would have to warn the Eridians to not gift Simon synthesized alcohol, even if he begs for it, or at least only offer it in moderation.
Simon would likely experience dissociative episodes where the linear progression of time stops making sense for him (again "time skipping" or feeling like he's teleporting.) He might sit entirely still for up to an hour like a statue, lost in his own head, or become a ghost in the night with his wanderings. He sees The Eye peering back at him every time he closes his own. Simon would be in terror without help. Rocky might be more attuned to watching Simon closely and keeping him safe during these episodes. I imagine Rocky casually staying nearby but not too close in case Simon spooks, likening it to the "paralyzed" state of Eridian sleep patterns.
Simon snapping out of it after a long while, just sort of blinking and noticing Rocky in the corner silently watching him, realizing he wasn't alone that entire time. Ugh. My soul.
To address Simon "worshiping" Grace, it just wouldn't happen. Do I think Simon would assume he's COI and beg for his life? Yes. Do I think Simon might confuse Grace with a hallucination? Also yes.
There may be times where Simon gets confused and believes Grace to be a front for the Red-Eyed God, but, begging and sucking-up to a god for freedom, for forgiveness, for mercy, to be unchained from the ocean, is not worship. Grace accepting any form of this so-called "praise" would be very out-of-character for him. It would be an immediate, "WOAH, buddy, hey let's reel that in for a minute and talk this out" sort of thing.
I hope this gives you some useful insight and painful whump ideas. Happy writing!