Still shaking off the rust, but in before canon tells me all of this is wrong? This was originally gonna be a drabble for the "Girl Gangs and Super Friends" collection, but it just kept going. Thanks to @svperbats for the extra set of eyes when I could not proofread anymore, and to the Tower gang for the encouragement. This can be read as shippy or platonic. Also posted here on ao3.
_________________________________________________
Her boots touch down in Gotham a little harder than she intends, leaving a crack in the stone of the Wayne Tower balcony. She barely registers it- will apologize later- but just now her heart is racing and she rushes inside so suddenly that Mary starts, spilling whatever it is she’s drinking over the carpet (she’ll apologize for that, too).
“Kara!”
“You found her? But I thought-”
“I know,” Mary breathes. “I- I feel like I’m gonna wake up and, and-”
“I know.” Kara answers, then goes to Mary and hugs her.
“She’s down in the Batcave with Luke and-...”
“Batwoman.” Kara finishes softly. She hasn’t met the new Batwoman yet, but she’s read all about her in the news and heard a story or two from Mary herself.
“I think she’s gonna introduce herself.” Mary says tentatively. Kara nods; her identity is hers to reveal, so Mary hasn’t shared it. “Come on,” She goes and opens the passage, and the two women descend, an anxious energy shared between them.
“She- she’s been through- I don’t even know what.” Mary drags a hand through her hair, then her breath catches and she brings both hands up to her face. “And after what happened with Bruce and Hush, I-...” Her voice trails off and she takes a breath. “It’s her. It’s her, it’s her- I know it’s her-”
Kara hears the tremor in her voice, reaches out and puts a hand on Mary’s shoulder. Kate is back and of course she is, because she’s Kate, yet it’s hard to believe, too. She can’t shake the sense that the world was spinning one way, then it thrust into reverse, only to suddenly be righted again; it’s hard to get her footing.
Mary lowers her hands and her eyes meet Kara’s. “She- she’s not the same.”
Something in Kara’s heart constricts just a little.
“Not just her face.” Mary whispers. “Whatever happened to her, they-...”
Something red hot twists inside Kara, angry- furious- for what Kate has been through. She sucks in a breath through her nose and tries to cool the sensation. Her fingers loosen slowly where they’ve curled into fists. The lift stops, and she follows Mary out.
Luke looks to them, approaches. “Supergirl.”
She reaches out, touches his shoulder briefly as they share a look, then her eyes fall upon the first face she doesn’t know.
Batwoman hesitates a moment, then takes off her cowl. “I’m Ryan.” She pauses, seems to be deciding what to make of Kara. Slowly, a little tentatively, she offers her hand. Kara musters as much of a smile as she can given the circumstances and shakes it.
“I’m really glad to meet you, Ryan.” She looks into the other woman’s eyes and hopes she knows she means it. “I’m Kara.”
“The Paragon of Hope.”
There is a pang in Kara’s heart as she looks past Ryan... The woman who stands there watching her has an unfamiliar face; she has an unfamiliar voice, too. There is a haunted sort of air about her, and an undercurrent of tension in the way she moves, ready for an attack even among friends. Kate Kane is different in every way but one, it seems... for all that is changed, Kara knows the heartbeat of the Paragon of Courage.
“Kate,” She breathes, then rushes forward and hugs her. Kate stiffens a moment, then slowly hugs back. “Thanks be to Rao,” Kara murmurs in her first language, finding comfort in the thrum of Kate’s pulse. More than questions, more than any words could, it is proof that Kate’s alive; she is here, and Kara is reluctant to let go. “Next time, I’m flying you.” She tries to quell the quaver in her own voice.
“It’s good to see you, too, Kara.” She wears what is barely the shadow of a smile, but for now it’s enough.
“Paragon of Hope?” Ryan is watching them curiously.
“Long story.” Kate sighs, maybe wishing it was the only thing she had to explain.
“We’ll fill you in on everything,” Mary puts a hand on Ryan’s shoulder and Kara can feel the weight of what she’s balancing: then and now, what was and what is, and all that’s happened in between.
"One story at a time.” Ryan smiles thinly, and Kara knows she feels it too: she does not share the history they have, but she is carving out history of her own.
“Right.” Kate looks down as everyone’s gazes return to her. “Right.”
“What happened?” Mary asks softly.
Luke is watching Kate like she might slip through the grated floor and vanish into the darkness. “Who did this? Were they waiting for you on the plane?”
“Maybe.” Kate answers.
Kara is heartsick. She can hear Luke let out a soft huff of air; wonders if he’s trying to evaluate where he could have done something different, just like she is.
“If I’d-”
“If you’d what? Put a tracker in me?” Kate cuts him off a little harshly, then seems to catch herself, shakes her head. “Don’t- don’t... dwell.”
“It’s a little late for that.” Luke’s shoulders sag, his lips curve upwards ruefully, but his eyes hold no mirth.
“They're called The False Face Society.” Kate avoids looking at any of their faces.
Ryan has gone very still, her lips pressed together.
“I have had about enough of false faces.” Mary’s jaw notches.
Kara’s heard about the things Alice does with skin. The fact that it seems to be a growing practice in Gotham makes her stomach churn. It isn’t just her: Luke looks somewhere between furious and sick, too.
“We’ll take them down.” Ryan looks to Mary and Luke, then to Kate. “We can take them down.”
“If I can do anything,” Kara offers. Anything to bring the people who did this to Kate to justice. There is a pit in her stomach though, because she knows she’s already too late. She might save others, but Kate... Kara wants to hug her again, but she’s not sure it would be welcomed just now.
Slowly, she tells them everything she can remember. Kara listens to the beat of her heart, for there is some solace in it... the changes run deeper than her face, but against all odds, Kate is alive... her heartbeat is the same.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Prompt - Alex learning that Kara isn't straight, and that Kara's dating Kate, at the same time, because she walked in on them about to have/having sex, on the couch in Kara's apartment, and the reactions to all this. Please, I'm willing to beg for this hilarious image to be written
“Oh my god. Oh my god.”
Kara squeals and almost falls off the couch. She’s only saved by the fact that Kate is on top of her, and Kate seems to be more composed than anyone else in the room.
Then again, given that Alex wants to die and Kara looks mortified, that’s not a high bar.
“Oh my god,” Alex says again, because there’s really nothing else she can say in this situation. “I- Oh god, I really should have knocked.”
“Yeah, probably,” Kate agrees, standing up and zipping up her jeans, which is a detail Alex could have lived her whole life without noticing. “Is something wrong?”
“I-” Alex stares at Kate, then looks at Kara. “Since when has this been a thing?”
Kate looks down at Kara. “You didn’t tell your sister about us?”
“I didn’t even know Kara was into girls!” Alex cries.
“Uh, well,” Kara says, sitting up and tugging her dress back into place, “I’m pan, and Kate and I have been dating for about two weeks.”
“You’ve been dating for two weeks, and you didn’t tell me?”
Kara blushes. “You’ve been busy! And it just... never came up.”
“If it makes you feel better, I haven’t told my family yet either,” Kate remarks, sitting down next to Kara and looking remarkably blasé for someone who was just interrupted when she was about to have sex with her girlfriend.
Alex takes a deep breath, holds it, and then lets it out. “Kara,” she says, “it’s your choice who you want to tell things, so I’m not angry that you didn’t tell me. And I should have knocked before I came in. But next time you two are planning on doing...” She waves a hand. “This, please lock the door.”
Blushing even darker, Kara nods. “I will.”
“Also, on the couch, really?” Alex asks. “I sit on that. We all sit on that. At least try to make to the bed, for god’s sake.”
“We’ll keep it in mind for next time,” Kate replies, which is probably the answer Alex should have expected but definitely not the one she wanted to hear.
She’s glad Kara is happy, and she’s glad Kara has finally broken her years-long dry spell, but she really, really, really didn’t need to see it.
I’M NOT READY TO TALK ABOUT CRISIS YET BUT GOOD GODS I AM LIVING FOR JUST HOW HAPPY KARA IS TO SEE HER GIRLFRIEND EXISTING IN THE SAME WORLD AS HER, I-- I LOVE THEM.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Things have not become any easier in this timeline.
Lena watches as Kara leans tiredly on the back of a chair, eyes closing briefly to steady herself, and everything inside her aches to reach over, to offer a hand, an arm, a heart.
Her ribcage is a cauldron of emotions, each rearing its head from time to time, wrestling for control, and Lena swallows thickly, waiting out the nostalgia to be replaced with a more familiar anger.
Before, though, while her eyes are still invariably focused on Kara, she sees Batwoman approach, a careful hand resting on Kara's shoulder as she leans down to speak quietly, her red hair falling like a curtain as if that would seclude them away from the world.
Jealousy flares hotter than anything else, tinting everything green, and Kara is now looking up to smile sweetly at whoever is behind that awful cowl, a smile so simple and honest– Lena wonders if Batwoman knows who Supergirl is, if Kara offered her the truth as easily as that smile, if she even waited a day before trusting this woman with her secret.
Batwoman is still talking too quiet for Lena to hear, but she can imagine what sort of nonsensical comforts she must be uttering, white lies, no less, to ease the heaviness off Kara's shoulders.
That used to be me, comes the thought, unbidden, and Lena is surprised by her own bitterness. It's not even true, in any case, Lena has never been the one comforting Kara, it has always been the other way around. Somehow, she still resents the intimacy, the closeness of the two.
"What is she doing here again?"
The voice is hers, Lena knows, noticing her own question in a detached sort of way. She hadn't meant to say any of that out loud.
What is done is done, nevertheless, and Kara startles badly as if she had, indeed, forgotten they had not been alone in the room. Batwoman, on the other hand, only turns to look coolly at Lena without backing off, one arm still around Kara's shoulder, no signs of ever having forgotten Lena.
She does look like the kind of person who never loses track of a threat.
"We talked about this," Kara clears her throat, and Lena doesn't miss the way she leans closer to the other woman, "with Leviathan, is all hands on deck. That includes, uh, Batwoman. You agreed to this before."
Right. The meeting two days earlier filled with so much tension and thinly-veiled threats it's a wonder they had agreed on something. Lena had not known then what all hands on deck had meant.
It should not matter.
Her feelings– whatever they might be at any given time– towards Kara or whoever she chooses to associate with, they cannot be taken into account, not when dealing with this.
Leviathan is too big a threat for that.
And yet, Lena finds herself disliking Batwoman anyway.
"Of course," she replies smoothly, "I just wonder because while you say all hands on deck, I can't help noticing she is the only one here."
Batwoman is holding herself very still, no doubt deferring to Kara in this situation– which means they talked about this, about Lena, gossiping like schoolgirls, giggling– and Kara frowns, her expression falling. "Oh, well," Lena sees the moment Kara's hand is covered by Batwoman's, a silent show of support that allows Kara to rally again, find her footing. Against Lena. "Flash, Vibe, and Frost are dealing with a situation in Central City, but they'll join us as soon as they can. Same with the Legends– something about souls being freed from Hell?" It's a half-question met with a shrug from Batwoman, and Kara shakes her head a little, "anyway. Black Lightning and Elongated Man are out following leads along with Black Canary."
Now, finally, Batwoman speaks. The turn of her lips gives off the impression of a proud smirk, "so, not just me, then."
Her voice has a metallic robotic sound to it. A modulator, most likely. Lena purses her lips. "I see," she hates the feeling of defeat that burns on her cheeks, cowering her into glancing away, down at the tablet in her hands, "you're not that special, then."
She hears a dry chuckle even as Kara sputters, probably gearing up to defend her friend's honor. "It's okay," Batwoman says, "I'm not here to make friends, I have my priorities straight."
Ignoring the remark, Lena keeps her gaze low, pretending to read some files and pointedly not raising to the bait. It had been a bad idea to bring this up, unsurprisingly. She half-expects Kara to start some can't we all just get along? spiel.
Instead, she hears the tail end of a conversation not meant for her. Batwoman is talking lowly, "I'm here because you called, Kara," so that answers a few questions, "and I rather the world didn't end, again."
"She'll come around, I'm sorry, you know how things are right now," Kara whispers back, and how inconspicuous do they think they are, whispering about like little children?
A bitter, mocking voice nags at the back of her mind, saying it's the honeymoon phase, they just can't get their hands off each other.
Lena ignores it, hating the sudden hollowness settling in.
Louder, she hears. "Anyway. We're going to get lunch."
No invitation. Obviously. It would have been turned down viciously if it had been asked, in any case.
"I'll have someone call you if we find anything," she dismisses them with a careless wave.
Footsteps. The door opening and closing. Finally, Lena is alone.
Closing her eyes and echoing shakily, she allows herself a brief moment of weakness. She breathes in, exhales.
Straightening, she clicks on a new file. There's much work to be done.
Kara and anyone you'd like: "you are the one you've been waiting for"
“Hey, Kate?”
Leave it to Kara to break the silence first after such a tense moment. Tense barely even described it, really- they were leaving Wayne Manor, Bruce’s house, after seeing Kate’s cousin die.
After Kate had killed him, no less.
(Was she, in her own time and dimension, killing his reputation? Would her performance as Batwoman reflect badly on him? If he were to return, whether because of her or not, would Gotham really miss her?)
She considered those things as she and Kara left, trying not to look too guilty as Luke tentatively said goodbye to them.
(and she had to make sure Kara’s staring at Luke wasn’t delaying them from returning. Because seriously, for a guy he was kind of cute. She wasn’t blind to that. But did Kara have to say it?)
“What is it, Kara?”
“You know; I was thinking about what the Monitor said. And… he never really told us that this Bruce was the Paragon of Courage, did he?”
“…Damn, you’re right.” Kate answered, after considering it. “Certainly doesn’t seem too courageous. Especially not after killing all those rogues of his.”
And killing your cousin, she thought, hand on the Kryptonite she’d secured from Bruce just in case. But judging by Kara’s face when Bruce had talked about that, and how she’d described seeing her cousin’s glasses in the trophy case, clouded over with dust and cracked… thinking about how he might’ve been taken out not while he was Superman, how Bruce considered Clark’s secret identity enemy-worthy… it was a sore subject for Kara, and Kate knew better than to mention it right then, when Kara had also just lost her family and her Earth.
(Kate thought of Beth, then- and Jacob, her own Luke, Mary, Sophie… how were they handling this Crisis? What was going to happen to them, once there were no other Earths to destroy but Earth-1?
What would they think of her, for leaving them right then of all times?)
“Yeah, that’s it.” Kara said. “And, if Bruce had been the Paragon, the Monitor probably would’ve shown up telling us that, all disappointed, telling us we doomed the Earths and all.”
Kate stifled a laugh, imagining the Monitor in position of her father, wearing a Crows uniform and ordering everyone around.
“You’re right. So, who do you think the real Paragon is?” Kate asked.
Kara gave her a gentle smile, and activated the interdimensional extrapolator, as they stepped in- just as the Earth-99 skies started to turn red.
And once they were back on the Waverider, she told her.
“It’s you, Kate.” She said. “You are the one you’ve been waiting for.”
“I am?”
“It’s the only thing that makes sense.” Kara answered. “Both now, and with your being Batwoman- the people of Gotham needed a symbol, and you stepped up and answered the call. You were what they waited for, those years Batman was gone, and you’re the Paragon everyone was waiting for now. You stood up to your cousin, demonstrated how much of a hero you are, and… I’m proud to call you my friend.”
“I’m happy to even be in your shadow, Paragon of Hope.” Kate said, lightly punching Kara’s arm. “Come on. Let’s tell everyone else the good news.”
“Gladly.” Kara said. “And then we’ll save the multiverse.”