I really miss a lot of characters from the first two seasons. Of course there are the Dimases (that’s the plural of Dimas right? Lol), I’ve definitely heard people talking about how much they miss them. Mostly Theo, and hey me too. I do think there’s lots to revisit with these two. But also I ADORE Lucy! I would love to see more of Lucy. Her relationship with Charles is so unique and sweet. She sounds gen z without actually sounding like she was written by a boomer and I love her for it. She’s adorable and excitable and such a good addition to the show. I miss Will too. It’s strange how we barely got to see him in season three especially with Oliver’s medical issues. Oliver is a father and grandfather, but we barely hear him talk about them. What about Mabel’s mom? How is she doing?

I miss the other Arconia residents too. How is Nina doing with her baby and being the Arconia’s board president? How is Charles’ neighbor, Arnav Kapoor? He seemed nice and I wanted to get to know him more. What about Ndidi Idoko and Dr Grover Stanley? I mean that therapist was funny I’m sure you could do something with him.

I also wanna know about Mabel’s relationship with Oscar post season one. They were gonna be just friends but are they friends? Do they still talk? Did they have a falling out? How is he after everything?

How’s Detective William’s wife Kiara and son Keith?

Nathan Lane said he'll be in episode 10 of season 5, so it is possible.

More screen time for Teddy

More screen time for Theo

More character development for Theo - specifically a final severing of his complicated and toxic relationship with his father

Obviously there's the Theobel potential, but even if they decided not to go that direction, this plotline--"my new best friend (who killed my old best friend) is a suspect in the killing of his criminal father and I have to deal with it"-- would give Mabel more to do emotionally then figuring out what she wants to do with her life for yet another season

We'd get to learn more about Teddy and his affairs, both sexual and business - maybe we'd even meet his ex-wife

Unlike Mabel and Charles, Oliver has never had someone he's close with get murdered; it would be an interesting thing to explore, and there isn't really another character they could kill off to make that happen (killing Loretta or Will or Dickie would be too sad for this show and the only other characters Oliver has been shown to be close with are Charles and Mabel)

It would be an opportunity to give Will's character some depth and development - does he care that his biological father is dead? does that reminder of the fragility of life make him want to have a relationship with Theo before it's too late? how did Oliver's heart attack affect him? what about his relationship with Dickie and Loretta? what would it be like for him to finally get sucked out of normalcy and into a case?

Oh! And Will! Will must be there as well, by Oliver's side!

Aaahh I can't wait!