Time to Make the Comics, Part 16: Donât Pitch. Make.
This postâs creation was fueled by coffee donations from Super Duper Generous Peeps (Like yourself! Potentially!) through ko-fi.com/roselyon! Thanks, cool, cool people!!!
Good evening. Iâm Johnathon O. Rose-Lyon. You of course know me from my work on such literary classics as âCosmic-Fantasy Comic Pitch That Was Shot Down Because It Doesnât Mesh Well With Our Third-Quarter Line-Upâ, and âSci-Fi Comic Pitch That Didnât Get A Greenlight Because We Did That Other Sci-Fi Comic Three Years Agoâ, and the beloved âMurder Mystery Comic That We Actually Dug A Lot But You Donât Have Enough Twitter Followers, Soooooooâ.Â
Wait, huh, wha? You havenât read... like, any of those massive-critical-and-financial-and-cultural-I-am-assuming successes?! And only literally five people on the face of the literal planet have? Even though Iâve dumped also-very-literal months of hard work into them? And my whole life and all of my intellectual pursuits up to this point are doomed to become the historical equivalent of an Audible monthly subscription gifted unto post-hearing-loss Ludwig van Beethoven, you say??
Well, fuck. Okay.
Anyway, Iâm here today to talk to you about NEVER PITCHING ANYTHING EVER and Iâm certainly not going to go back on that at all and mean it very literally. (I donât.) (But itâs sorta true.) (Just keep reading, jeez.)
Here are some stats (thatâs Comic Industry Lingo for âstatisticsâ youâre welcome) for your consideration:
â˘Started this tumblr blog. Started talking âbout comic books and âbout making âem and junk. Got over 500 followers. Made some way-too-cool-for-me-tbh friends. Maybe helped some people out I donât know.
â˘Made Neon Noir with Michael Kennedy. Like... we just made it. Put that shit up online for free, straight commie-style. Got another good 500 followers from it. Sold a good chunk of comics, somehow. Got a few publishersâ attention. Made more seriously-way-too-cool-what-the-actual-fuck friends.
â˘Made Super Human with Stephen Morrow and boy Roland. Again, no permission. No greenlight. Just made. Tossed them shits on the internets, free-o-charge. Got 1k followers jesus christ. Sold a couple hundred copies (even though that was non-profit because Iâm a good person aka a little bit dumb). GOT ON FUCKING TELEVISION FROM IT. Received â and Iâm ballparking this somewhat â eight billion emails and messages about what that comic meant to people that all made me cry and I am now a fine, dehydrated dust pile. And now I have so many friends that, if I want to make a new friend, I must pick one of my older friends and abandon them forever to make room because I have hit the Legal Friend Maximum that is just how many friends I have now ¯\_(ă)_/ÂŻ
â˘Spent a total of 10 months(!) researching for and assembling 14 different pitches(!!) for 14 different projects(!!!). Some editors said they were cool or whatever. Maybe the next pitch will be the one. Thatâs it. The end.Â
Now Iâm no mathmagician, but...
Point is, itâs so, so easy to fall in a pitch hole. Especially if someone asks you to start pitching to them. Throwing two-page summary after two-page summary after 5 pages of lettered sample art after âItâs like Dragonball Z meets Star Trek!â at publishers. Your entire creative life submitting to that âsubmitâ button. Screaming into the void and waiting for the void to be all, âHey, I really pick up what youâre putting down, man, letâs make this thing.â And then the infinite void gives you a thumbs-up thatâs literally beyond the quantum descriptive capacity of any mortal language.
K, so hereâs where I totally go back on what I said before: Iâm not saying to never pitch. Iâm just saying Have something to show for it for the love of god.Â
Those are ten months Iâm not getting back. And weeks of hard-ass work my collaborators wonât get back, either. And all we have to show for it are half-stories and ending-less pages and sad-tears.
Heck, Iâm pitching a project right now. Thatâs right, Iâm a hypocritical, clickbait-y little shit, so what, fucking fight me. But the difference is Iâm making a finished product. And if the infinite void doesnât dig what weâre doing, then guess what? We now have a dope-ass comic to give to the masses directly. Whether itâs through kickstarter or self-publishing or, in classic commie-style fashion, just straight free-on-the-internet. The voidâs loss is the universeâs gain.
So what Iâm sayinâ is GO OUT THERE AND MAKE SOME COOL SHIT AND FINISH SAID COOL SHIT. JUST MAKE. And if no one wants to throw money at you for it (the odds of which are, Iâm v. sorry to say, up there), hey look! Non-publisher human beings still dig what youâre doing with your life and it might even make their life better and it turns out thatâs rewarding too even though you canât pay the rent with it or eat it or whatever!
And then you just join a site where people straight-up give you money cuz they think youâre dope and what you do is dope. Pro strats.Â
NOW GO ART ALREADY JEEZ.
















