Trisect Teen and Up Audiences, No Warnings Apply, Gen, 1.5k
This is the one of the most bizarre things I think I've ever written. I didn't feel like it warranted an AO3 post, so I'm putting it here despite my reservations about it. It's inspired by the three Sams in 6x22. I think this is out of character, but I unfortunately do not have the mental fortitude to rectify it.
Warning for an instance of misogynistic language.
On the counter, Samâs phone buzzes. The vibrations ripple throughout the stained plywood, prompting his brandy to quiver in its glass pyxis and his body to shiver in turn. Something pushes towards the surface, pollution like ink spreading throughout water, and his legs bounce fervently for all of a second.
Get a grip, Softie, echoes off the walls of Samâs skull, and his body stiffens.
Stop calling me that, a brasher, indignant voice responds. Laughter follows in that same, chillingly cool inflection.
The bartender comes into view, peering cautiously into Samâs eyes. He must have been twitching again. The voice knows to fall silent, isnât a fool, and so the manâs suspicion drains away.
âRefill?â
Samâs eyes tick towards his mostly full glass. Assessing, the one they call âSoftâ takes the initiative and responds, âJust the tab.â
Nodding, the man steps away. Customers are waiting, a low hum dinning throughout the bar, but he goes to follow the request immediately. The cool voice murmurs something crass without much feeling, and the louder one clamours for quiet.
Counterproductive, the second voice remarks idly.
âShut up,â Sam mutters. A second later a shadow falls over him, his eyes lifting slowly to meet the bartenderâs. They remain locked for a pregnant moment, before the paper slips from between the manâs fingers and he leaves to attend to his patrons.
More words choke the back of Samâs throat, but abort themselves. Rising to his feet, Sam fishes a few notes from his pocket and lets them slip from between his fingers to land atop the bill. Hastily, but without enough vigour to draw attention, Sam stalks through the bar, eyes fixed squarely on the exit. Strains tugging them this way or that rise up, but a solid thump to the chest - causing a nearby woman to jump - settles the revolt with nothing more than an exhale.
The chill of the outside air, rushing in from all sides and slipping like breath down the back of Samâs neck, brings clarity. The entangled mass cools, igneous, and defines clearly the divide between three pieces; two near the front, one burrowing as far into the spine as possible.
The instant Samâs back meets cool brick, solidifying the buried piece until it ceases to pulse at all, Samâs mouth twists.
âWe agreed Iâd drive,â Soft snaps, stress turning to anger.
Samâs lips curl. âYou need to retake your test, buddy.â
Samâs fist thumps the hard wall, but he goes silent. Catastrophizing is loud, or so Soulless says, and the internal grumbling starts almost as soon as Soft falls into a rut of it.
âGod, loosen up. If youâre so worried about appearing normal, why donât you stop struggling and just hand me the reins?â
Sam laughs. So loudly that it echoes throughout the parking lot, drawing looks from bikers smoking at the mouths. Sam laughs again, a little crazed.
âRight. Youâll make us look normal, you fucking sociopath.â
âHey, Larry,â a voice comes. Foolishly, Samâs head turns to the source, locking eyes with a bearded man carrying a half-empty pint glass. âLook at this wacko over here.â
Larry pokes his head from inside the building, hot on his friendâs heels. He leers at him like a circus attraction, stripping Sam's body to the bone.
Assessing his reaction, the two begin a slow prowl forwards. Their boots crunch gravel, like jaws snapping bone, until finally they reach him, standing far enough away to avoid a swing. Testing him out.
âWho you talking to, boy?â Not Larry asks, a lopsided grin revealing two rotten teeth and a false one. Heâs shorter than his companion, but he closes in more quickly. Leaning in too close for comfort, the stench of beer launching a preemptive assault. âThe voices in your head? The ghosts only you can see?â
First option, Soulless replies, but Soft swallows it down. He opts instead to stare silently as they close in, one on either side of him with his back against a wall, where the third fragment burrows more deeply.
Not Larry reaches out a hand, waving it in front of his face and drawing out a few rapid blinks. An ugly laugh bubbles up in the manâs throat, thick with intoxication. âHow do you know that weâre real?â
That draws a drunken giggle from Larry, who grows emboldened. He reaches out, flicking his forehead with his forefinger. A pressure begins to rise like a tide, inevitable. As they burst into sniggers, Soft falters for a moment regarding whether he even wants to hold it back, and in that split second the hands grab him, shove him down, and his head spins as he goes underwater.
He can still see, but the images are blurred. In the moonlight, everything looks black and blue, so no splashes of new colour can aid him. He can still just barely hear beyond screeching tinnitus, which worsens the more he fights for air. He scrambles, drowning, while commands ripple through the muscles of his vessel, sparking along his synapses and shocking him into submission.
His head spins, and spins. Until two hands grasp him, and pull him to the surface.
Gasping, Soft reorients himself. Sam is marching toward the outdoor bathroom block, liquid dripping from his knuckles where they swing at his sides. Delayed adrenaline rushes the more he regains his footing, and he can hear Soulless sniggering.
âWhy the hell did you do that?â Soft squeaks rather than snarls, so loudly that it comes out of Samâs mouth. He pauses, holding Samâs breath, but theyâre alone under the wan ceiling light.
Soft sees Samâs mouth twist in the mirror before he feels it. Disoriented, he canât prevent the march forward, where Samâs hand twists the faucet before diving under the spray, running red down the undulations of his knuckles.
âCome on, Softie,â Soulless murmurs. âWe both know you wouldâve let them step all over us. You wanna be treated like a circus freak by two drunk cunts in Fuckville, Nowhere?â
Samâs mouth twists with distaste. âI donât give a shit how two drunk cunts in Fuckville, Nowhere look at me. I care that you havenât stopped fucking doing that even though I told you not to!â
Soulless laughs. A sinister sound, colder than the cheap sink where he rests Samâs hands on it. âYouâre not the only one in here.â
âYeah, but Iâm the default one, Iâm fucking in charge, and when you try to take control you only fuck things up!â
Softâs head is back beneath the water before he even realises heâs lost control. He squirms, gasping for air, finds himself let up for a second only to be shoved back down. Soulless is waterboarding him.
By the time his head is spinning and their vessel is about to lose consciousness, Soulless lets his head break into the air. Soft is afforded a few seconds to gasp before Samâs eyes are wrangled to stare deeply into his reflection. A blank expression, relaxed and tense at once.
âListen,â Sam murmurs, close enough to the mirror that it fogs up, though his eyes remain sharp like cut crystals. âYou get to steer most of the time. Thatâs fine. I let you. Youâre right; youâre the default. But youâre also a fucking sissy whoâll let anyone walk all over you because youâre scared of everything. Of Samâs mind shattering into tinier pieces, of Dean seeing you like th-â Soulless pauses to wrangle Soft down, silencing his protest. Heâs still so dizzy that he canât fight it. âOne of us has to take the initiative sometimes, and Iâm stepping up to the mark.â Sam leans in closer, his breath rebounding off the glass and washing warm over his face. âIs that so wrong?â
Soft falls silent. Soullessâs eyes bore into his through the mirror, and he turns away to avoid them. He looks back, where the curled mass shivers and shivers, silent and impartial. The shattered piece doesnât remember what morals are, doesnât talk, doesnât move unless to shudder. He wonât side with him, and he wonât keep him company. Soulless is the only one he has in here.
He turns back around to find Soulless curling Samâs mouth at the edges. âItâs not just us; weâve got the one back there to think about. Weâve gotta show him that people canât just trample all over us; maybe weâll even be able to get him to talk.â They both fall utterly silent. No sign of a response, or that the subdued one even heard them.
Sighing, Soulless straightens Sam up, finally loosening his grip on Soft. He lets him have control, but slowly trails a hand across Samâs sensitive throat. Soft shudders.
âWeâre fragile. If you donât want to crawl back to that brother of Samâs, thatâs your prerogative; that just means weâve gotta look out for our own. Alright?â
Samâs hand brushes back and forth across the vulnerable skin of his neck, distracting. Dizzy, Soft nods.
âGood,â Soulless murmurs, a perversion of a genuine smile creeping onto Samâs lips. âLetâs get out of Fuckville, Nowhere.â















