#thoelleton

Clay had just turned twenty a few days ago, he was sitting out on his family’s porch. A couple is moving in across the street. They just moved here from Canada, at least that's what his mother told him. He didn’t know what it was about this couple but the woman in the relationship seemed oddly familiar and the man was just… Oddly gorgeous. 

Clay has never been one to explore his sexuality, he was pretty confident that he loved women. He has had many girlfriends, not to brag or anything but he just mentioned how much he adores women. Ladies. The female gender identity. He loved them all. 

He hasn’t actually seen the woman over at the new neighbors house all that often, she came home at odd times but left at 8:30 am every morning. 

He definitely wasn’t watching them too much… right?

Watching this new mysterious man move boxes out of a Uhaul into the cozy little house just a few yards away. Clay was acting like he was on his phone so it wasn’t super weird for him to be outside all the time. It was summer in california now so it was hot, and the neighbor was sweating up a storm. 

Clay’s favorite time of day was when their shirt clinging to this handsome man's back came off. This guy had a choke hold on him. He was tall, at least a couple inches taller than Clay himself. His dark skin made the sun’s glow shine like metal. He was fit, his hair was tight coils on the top of his head with a fade on the sides and back. Every once in a while he would notice Clay staring and give him a small friendly wave. 

Those times would give him butterflies in his stomach. Clay wasn’t against trying something out with a man but he genuinely would have no idea what he was doing and that scared him. He liked to know what he was doing. 

Clay worked at a grocery store as a little time away from his parents, he loved them with all his heart. But getting away was pretty nice. He takes care of his dad when his mom is at work and vice versa. His father had an accident with a forklift when he was younger and now rides around on an electric scooter that he modified to go faster when he first got it. He wasn’t completely disabled but he is very absentminded and has a tendency to get himself into situations that he thinks he can handle on his own when he actually can’t. Therefore he needs someone to help him out from time to time. 

He stood at his cash register ringing up a sweet old woman who was buying eight pounds of jalapenos. When she left the next person in line stood in front of him while he put some hand sanitizer on. He looked up and almost passed out. His new neighbor was buying house essentials like paper towels and plates. The older man shoots him a smile and Clay can’t help but smile back. 

“You’re my new neighbor, right?” The older man's voice was silky smooth and just so pleasant to hear. 

“Yeah, I live across the street.” 

“I knew it! I’d recognize that face anywhere. I’m Thomas by the way.” Clay can feel his face heating up as he continues to scan the items and tell Thomas his name back quietly. “Your mom stopped by earlier and invited us to dinner tonight.” 

“Really? She loves inviting people over, so it doesn’t surprise me.” Clay tells him his prices and clicks the button to let Thomas’ use his card. 

“She’s incredibly sweet. Noelle and I said we would stop by around 6, will you be there?” 

“I- Yeah, I get off around three.” 

“I’ll see you then.” Thomas winks putting the sunglasses that sat on top of his head back over his eyes, Clay didn’t even notice them the entire time they were talking. The older man leaves and clay takes a breath. How was he supposed to last three more hours!

Clay rushed home after his shift, showering, changing and going back down the stairs to help his mother cook as fast as he could. He was giddy, hoping it wasn’t too noticeable. The couple show up just after six, having a gift of wine for them. This was the first time Clay has been able to get a good look at Noelle. 

She was fucking stunning, and so familiar but he could not put his finger on it. She was dressed in some baggy yet stylish jeans with a tight shirt on and from what he could tell, no bra. Her hair was beautifully curly in a naturally messy way. Her eyes were dark hazel but still shined bright through her dark eyelashes. Her tan skin and a couple small moles on her left cheek made her undeniably beautiful. On top of that, she was kind. She subtly helped his father by moving things on the table closer to him when he wasn’t paying attention. She raved about how good the food was, complimenting his mother constantly. 

“Actually it was my son Clay who cooked the meal tonight.” His mom sends him a wink which just makes him internally groan annoyed that she has put the spotlight on him. He just smiles and Noelle turns to him. Their seating somehow ended up with him sitting between the lovely couple. 

“Oh really? Well, you’re a very good cook. Driving all the way down here from Canada we lived off fast food. It’s great to have a homemade meal.” 

“Thank you, if you ever need another meal you can stop by anytime.” Clay felt something touch his leg on the other side of him, he looks down and realizes he’s being jumpy for no reason. Thomas was just sitting with his legs wide like most men do, Clay included. Their thighs were pressed against each other pretty firmly and Clay didn’t want to move at all. 

The rest of the evening was great! The conversations were fun and chill, Noelle would put a hand on his arm or bump him with her elbow while Thomas would poke fun at his overgrown hair. His parents were laughing and enjoying the interactions as well. At the end of the night they all went out to the porch to say a friendly goodbye.

His mother hugged the two and once again told them to stop by at any time, his father sat in the doorway and Noelle hugged him as well, Thomas just shook his hand. Eventually his parents went inside leaving the three on the porch together. Clay felt a bit awkward, rubbing his arm as he shifted from foot to foot. 

“Tonight was fun, if you need anything just let us know.” Noelle says and runs her hand down his arm that he was rubbing, stopping on his hand and squeezing it before taking her hand back. 

“Same goes for you.” 

“I could use some help moving our bigger furniture into the house this upcoming week. Noelle has to work and I can’t move it on my own.” 

“I have to work for the next few days but I’m off on wednesday. My dad has a doctor's appointment that my mom is taking him to so I won’t have anything to do.” Clay smiles at them and they send one back. 

“I’d really appreciate it.” 

Clay’s mind was clouded the next few days with so many different things that could happen. He tried to focus on work but could not for the life of him. Leading to a couple double scanned items. When Wednesday finally rolled around, he got up early and got ready just by dressing in shorts and a shirt, he didn’t want to be too crazy.  He ended up getting caught up in picking up around the house like he promised his parents. A couple hours went by and he finally left the house. He stands on his porch for a couple minutes just watching his sexy man move smaller boxes that he could handle himself. Thomas noticed him after taking off his shirt like he always does. 

He waved him over and Clay swallowed a lump of horny from his throat and walked across the street. 

“Ready to help me move?”

“Right now?”

“Why not? Are you busy?” 

“No but-” Thomas didn’t let him finish the sentence before putting a box in his hands.

“Here.” Clay could hear the smile in Thomas' voice. He heard some noise and then the other man started walking back to the house. Clay started following him, it wasn’t his house so he didn’t know where literally anything was supposed to go. 

“Yeah okay, I’ll just follow you.” Thomas laughs, telling Clay where to set his box down and squeezing his shoulder before walking back outside to get more. Thomas is pushing a couch in the uhaul towards the big open back and Clay walks over to help. 

“Let's take this in next, get it out of the way.” Clay and Thomas maneuver the couch out of the moving van and into the house, setting it down in the middle of what is most likely going to be the living room. “You’re so strong, Clay.” 

“Ah- Thanks!” Clay quickly spits out feeling his face heat up. 

They move more boxes all day and Thomas encourages Clay to take off his shirt too. Clay does feel shy at first but he and Thomas start joking around so he relaxes. Clay does catch Thomas doing that eye thing and looks him up and down. Clays’ heart flutters. 

Eventually Thomas says they can stop for the day and Clay goes to find his shirt.

 “Do you want to leave that bad?”

“Well I thought you’d want to be alone for when your wife comes home”

“Oh she won’t mind, want a beer?”

“Umm sure” They sit on the couch and Clay puts his shirt back on, opening and drinking the beer the older man gave him.

“She’s not my wife by the way. She's just my girlfriend. But I want her to be my wife someday”

“Oh I thought you are married already since you moved in together” Clay takes a giant drink and looks somewhere else “what does your girlfriend do for a job?” He hears Thomas let out one of those cocky little laughs 

“She does porn”  Clay chokes. 

“Oh?” 

“Yeah, maybe you’ve seen some of her work” Something clicks in Clay’s mind about why she looked so familiar… Holy fuck he has watched her before. “Do you want to see if you have one?” 

“I-Um yeah, sure.” Clay has no idea how to respond, he watches Thomas grab the remote to their tv that they have set up already. Thomas clicks around and pulls up a website. This tv must have been a smart one. Clay gulps down more of his beer. 

“Have you seen any?” 

“A couple.” 

“Want to watch one you haven’t seen?” Thomas’ arm rests on the back of the couch and Clay starts realizing just how close they are. 

“Yeah, I really would.” They scroll through Noelle’s profile to find one Clay hasn’t seen before and he gets embarrassed with just how many he has actually seen. They find one and Thomas puts it on. Clay is immediately zoned in on the video. Watching Noelle act completely different from how he has seen her. He didn’t even notice the hand being settle on his thigh. 

“Do you like it?” Thomas whispers in his ear and Clay shivers. 

He turns to look at Thomas and notices how close Thomas is and looks at his lips then back up to his eyes “Yeah…” Then next thing Clay knows is he’s being kissed. Kissing back, he puts a hand on the back of Thomas head and Thomas’ hand on his thigh slides farther up. 

“Thomas we should stop- what about Noelle” Clay pulls away to look the older man in the eyes. Thomas just smirks and kisses his cheek. 

“She wants you too, Clay” He gasps as Thomas kisses his neck and just the thought of both of his incredibly sexy neighbors wanting him. Fuck dude, he was in heaven. But he needed clarification. 

“What do you mean she wants me too?” Clay is confused and  his brain is getting fogged up as Thomas slides a hand up his shirt before yanking it off him, Thomas taking off his own as well. Tracing his fingers lightly over his chest and abs making Clay’s breath go all funny for a minute. 

“She likes you like I do. Dummy” 

“You like me?” Clay questions as he’s pushed on his back and Thomas kisses his neck once again. The question makes Thomas pull away to look him in the eyes. 

“Mhm. You’re so sexy.. and nice, and sweet” He says everything with a kiss on Clay's face ending it with a sweet one on his lips. Thomas starts kissing down Clay, to jaw, to neck, to collarbone, to his chest. Thomas licks over Clay’s nipple and he gasps

 “I’ve never been with a guy!” Clay blurts out, he was so out of his element. He fucking loved it. 

“Cute” Thomas says and continues messing with his chest making Clay squirm. 

The door opens, they hear footsteps and Clay can feel Thomas smiling on his skin. Noelle walks in and they hear the footsteps stop. 

“Well isn’t this nice to come home to.” Clay looks up to see her with her hair up and her hands on her hips smiling at them. 

Thomas chuckles as she rubs a hand up his back and he lifts his head to kiss her. Clay moans at the sight, thumping his head back on the cushions. 

“I see you showed him my portfolio” Noelle says, glancing at the tv. 

“It turns out he’s seen a lot of them.” Thomas says as he goes back to kissing all over Clay. 

“Noelle- do you like me? Like how Thomas does?” Clay catches her attention and Noelle just smiles, nodding and kisses him. Her kiss is so different from Thomas’. As expected it’s much more skilled but also incredibly soft. 

Clay groans and arches his back as Thomas palms him through his pants. Grabbing one of Noelles thighs since that’s what he’s level with he doesn’t want her to pull away. And she does, making him a bit sad for a second. 

“You’re so gorgeous” She says, petting his locs back from his face. 

“I want- please touch me!” He shifts his hips trying to make Thomas press on him more. Thomas and Noelle share a little look. 

“Hey clay” Thomas says and lifts himself up to be over Clay face to face. “How do you feel about being in the middle of us?”

“What do you mean?” He couldn’t think right and he’s never had a threesome before if that’s what they were offering. He would say yes in a heartbeat. 

“You fuck Noelle while I fuck you?”

“Please- fuck please please”

“I would suggest we go to the bedroom but a couch scene is always sexy” Noelle says and sucks a hickey behind Clay’s ear after she squats down next to them. 

“Bedroom-!“ He gasps and then next thing he knows Thomas is picking him up. He has never been picked up before so today is just full of firsts for him. The fact that Thomas can indeed lift him so easily made so many more scenarios run through his head. 

“Careful setting him down, Love. Our mattress is on the floor right now.” Noelle is leading the way to the upstairs bedroom and Clay feels like he’s about to fucking cum from just being picked up. 

Thomas can definitely tell how worked up he is. “Wow you’re gorgeous.” He mumbles to him and Clay straight up doesn’t know how to respond. Clay just sighs as Thomas lays him down.  

“Please finish taking my clothes off.” 

“So polite.” Noelle mumbles to Thomas and they pull off his shorts. Noelle starts taking off her own clothes and Clay can’t even believe this is even real. He watches Thomas stand on the mattress and shuck his own shorts and underwear off. Kneeling down again and kissing Noelle in a heated way. 

He is just panting and looking at them reaching down to squeeze himself and arching once again because that stretch of his muscles in his back makes everything feel better. Noelle and Thomas pull apart and look down at him both resting their hands on each other’s lower backs. 

“He seems like much more of a bottom… Should I just get my strap instead?” Noelle says so nonchalantly and Clay is lost. 

“I don’t know what any of those words mean.” Clay says just looking at them. What the hell is a bottom? Thomas just laughs at him and Noelle smiles, taking Clay’s hand off himself and holding it. 

“What if we took turns fucking you instead?”

“What? But-“

“I have a toy, Honey. It straps onto

My body”

“Ohh!” Clay gets it now, he's seen that before but only online never in person. 

“Is that okay? Doesn’t that sound fun?” 

“Can we do both things?” they started rubbing his inner thighs, Noelle took it upon herself to straddle Clay. Leaning down to kiss him again. 

“Well, let's save one for the next time. Okay?” Thomas says as he gets up to grab something.

“Let’s have him in the middle.” Noelle says when she pulls away and bites her lip just looking down at him. Thomas comes back with a small bottle on his hand and two condoms. 

“Is getting fucked scary?” He asks Noelle as she rolls him over with her so she is under him, cupping his face smiling brightly. 

“Maybe a little at first” she kisses him gently and moves one of her hands on the back of his neck. 

Thomas puts lube on his finger and slides into Clay slowly, being ready to pull out of it’s too much for him. Clay's face screws up and he pulls away from the kiss with Noelle, he feels his whole body tense up. 

Noelle holds his face shushing him soothingly, rubbing a thumb on his cheek. “Just relax Doll, Thomas will take care of you. If you want to stop, we can.”

“No, just give me a moment.” 

“Take all the time you need.” Thomas says, kissing his back. Clay takes a couple moments and starts relaxing. He just rests his face in Noelle’s chest. He fucking loves tits. 

Noelle laughs a little and pets his hair kissing the top of his head. Thomas slowly starts moving his finger. Clay surprises himself and moans, it’s a bit broken but it was definitely there. 

“There you go Baby.” Thomas whispers to him. Clay whines at the pet name and pushes up on his knees and hands hanging his head between his arms. Pressing back on Thomas' finger. 

“Want more?”

“Uh huh” Clay gasps as Thomas adds another finger and he sucks on one of Noelle's boobs. 

Noelle moans under him but it’s not one of those fake ones, it was so authentic and sexy that it drove him crazy. He just groans at her sound and Thomas speeds up his fingers making his arms give out so he is fully face in boobs. Noelle hugs his head and encourages him to touch her more. 

Clay is so hard and just rubbing up against Noelle’s navel making their breath is all funny. 

“Clay~” Noelle moans.  

“I’m gonna cum!” Clay warns and Thomas presses on his prostate which he hasn’t done yet. Clay just fucking goes into another universe, the wonderful feelings of pressure shooting through his body made him shake. He cums on Noelle, his moan is all broken and breathy, Thomas pulls his fingers out and massages his back. 

 “Do you want to keep going?” 

“Thomas he’s already getting hard again” Noelle says since she reached down to feel Clay who just groaned.  

“I want to keep going.” Clay says and lifts himself up a little to kiss Noelle. 

“Okay just let me know if you want to stop.”

“I’ve been dreaming about this since I first saw you. I want you to do whatever you want to me.”

Thomas hands a condom to Noelle who opens it behind Clay’s head so the crinkle is loud in his ear making him laugh a little into their kisses, which in turn makes Noelle laugh as well. Thomas rolls his on and Noelle reaches between her and Clay to roll one on Clay with expertise. 

Clay, who is basically liquid at this point, let’s Noelle take over as she helps him push into her. He is panting and groaning and just feeling so much all at once as Thomas slowly starts pushing into him with gentle ease. Clay doesn’t dare move a muscle wanting all of Thomas in him on the first try. He was determined. 

“So much-“ 

“Still wanna go?” Noelle says her voice all funny because as Thomas pushes into Clay he is in turn pushing more into her. 

“Please!”

Thomas holds Clay steady and picks a nice gentle rhythm to start both Clay and Noelle moan kissing each other and Clay grabbing one of her boobs squeezing lightly. 

And she’s being genuine, not like how she is in porn. It’s such a different experience that basically is getting Clay drunk off a sound. Thomas was breathing stuttery behind him and letting out soft moans of his own. Clay isn’t even moving! Thomas is doing all the work!

“You sound so different” Clay mumbles to Noelle who moans and then laughs wrapping her legs around both the boys as best as she can. 

“That’s because I like you.” She gasps a little as Clay starts moving his hips in circles a little making everyone feel amazing. 

“Clay, you're so good at that!” Noelle says arching her back and grabbing his back and Thomas’ shoulder. 

“So so good baby.” Thomas says as well, moaning. They are now moving in time somehow and Clay is already barely holding on. 

“Noelle! No-ELLE! THOMAS!” Clay moans into Noelle’s neck and sucks a dark hickey on it. Thomas leans forward to do the same to Clay which pushes them both in more abruptly. Clay cries out feeling so amazing. 

Thomas cums inside his condom, Noelle and Clay following suit. Clay melts into Noelle leaving small kisses on her shoulder as Thomas pants into his hair. They all just meld into one. Noelle and Thomas share a look over Clay's shoulder and just smile. 

“You’re so perfect.” Thomas mumbles, rubbing his hands up Clay’s sides. Clay just blushes. 

“That was the best experience of my life… nothing will ever top that!” Clay says and shivers when Thomas starts to pull out. Relaxing when he is fully out, feeling Thomas get off the mattress. 

“Maybe we’ll have to dp you sometime, that might top it.” Noelle whispers to him, still having her legs wrapped around him right now that she isn’t trying to hold both of them with her legs. Clay huffs his face still in Noelle’s neck and whines. 

 “Don’t tease me right nowwww!” Noelle just chuckles, rubbing her hands all over him. She just can’t get enough of him.

 “Okay Babydoll.”

“I like you guys.” Clay says and he’s getting loopy, smiling and snuggling Noelle tighter as Thomas comes back and sits next to them with a washcloth. 

“We like you too Baby.” Thomas says, brushing one of his locs back. 

“I like when you call me that… what time is it?” 

“Umm” Thomas looks at his phone “6 pm”

“Oh shit I need to go!” He says with urgency but Clay doesn’t move. He’s stuck. Way too tired. 

“Where do you have to be?” Thomas asks, kissing his temple. 

“I have to go make dinner for my parents.” He says as he slowly sits up and watches himself pull out of Noelle. He just moans as he stares and wants to slide back in to do it again. Thomas and Noelle can see him contemplating. “Maybe… I could stay a little longer?” He’s trying to convince himself to stay. 

“If you have stuff you have to do it’s okay, Clay.” Thomas says as he wipes off Noelle from Clay's first ejaculation. 

“I don’t want to leave… because then all of this is over.”

“It’s not over, if anything it’s just beginning.” Thomas says “Unless you want it to be over.”

“Definitely not” Clay lets out a wet laugh and Thomas holds his chin and kisses him softly. 

“How about we go on a lunch date tomorrow?”

“Can I come over and cook?” Clay smiles and kisses Thomas back. 

“We’d love that” Noelle says as she sits up smiling sweetly at the two of them. 

Clay is all happy and gets ready to leave. walking into his house and his mom says

“Someone got lucky!”

“What?!”

“You look like a mess, now come help me with these stuffed peppers.” Clay walks over still shocked. 

“Do I really look that bad?” Clay says and his mom laughs.  

“Honey, you have two giant love bites on your neck.” 

“I do?!”

“So who is she?”

“Um… it’s actually two people… and one of them is a guy? Please don’t be mad…”

“Oh baby, I’ve known you’ve been curious for a while. We’ve seen the way you watched the young man move in across the street.” 

“What do you think of the new neighbors?”

“I like them, very nice.”

“Well it’s them.” His mom is quiet for a second before going. 

“Your dad owes me ten bucks.”

“You’re joking!”

“You wish I was.” 

“Mom!!” 

“When are you going over again? I have some bread you can take.”

“Tomorrow…”

“Do you need condoms too?”

“NO!”

“You’re using protection though right? Until you’ve all been tested I think that’s best”

“Mooooommmmm!”

“What?! I don’t want my boy getting stds!”

“Yes I’m using protection! God this is so awkward.”

“It’s not, you’re just making it awkward.” 

“But you really don’t care that I slept with two people and one was a man?” 

“I don’t care what you do sexually as long as you are safe.”

“Okay… I just- I really like them.”

“I know hun. I see the way you look at them.”

“They want me to make them lunch tomorrow” Clay smiles so big it hurts his cheeks. 

“That’s sweet, do you know anything new about them? Like what they do for a living or if they have pets?”

“I- Noelle does porn for a living…!”

“Oh! An experienced girl!”

“… You don’t care?!”

“Nope, she’s definitely going to make you boys happy.” His mom winks which makes him laugh. 

“Jesus Christ that was a fucking rollercoaster.” His mom pats his back supportively. 

“Go wash up for dinner. The peppers will be done soon.”

“Okay.” He’s in the bathroom when he hears his dad say. 

“What?! I do?”

The next day, Clay is nervous for some reason with a bag in his hands as he knocks on his neighbor’s door. Could he still just label them as his neighbors?

The door opens and Noelle smiles, kissing him. 

“Hi!!” She enthused. 

“H-hi wow I wasn’t expecting that!” Noelle laughs and pulls him in the messy box filled house. 

“What did you bring us!” She sees the bad with bread and smiles all excited. 

“My mom made homemade bread.” Clay smiles shyly as they make it to the kitchen. 

“For us?”

“Yeah.” Clay smiles at her and he can physically feel how soppy it was. 

“Aww she’s so nice! I love your mom.” Clay dumps out the bag and a bunch of condoms fall out too. 

“Umm…” He gets so embarrassed so fast. 

“Oh?” Noelle raises a teasing brow and picks one up. 

“My mom must have put these in here. She gave me a whole lecture in safe sex.” 

“So she knew we fucked?” Noelle smirks.  

“I- well- there were bruises on my neck.”

“Still are Doll, and I can make more if you want.”