teaandcrafts replied to this post:
Can I just remind everyone reading this that the whole story is canonically told from the point of view of the ..... HOBBITS.
You don't need to, since it's not true. The POV in LOTR predominantly comes from the hobbits, but not exclusivelyâas with Ăowyn and Faramir's romance (the scenes this post is essentially about), which is told from the POV of, well, Ăowyn and Faramir. Faramir having to stoop down to kiss Ăowyn's forehead, say, is not Merry's POVâMerry isn't even there.
The hobbits are canonically the compilers of the tale (in-story), but that doesn't make theirs the only perspective. They definitely aren't supposed to have written everything in the Appendices, which a bunch of the quotes come from (e.g. "The Tale of Aragorn and Arwen" has a DĂșnadan author, in-universe).
A number of the quotes/references also come from outside LOTR/The Hobbit altogetherâfor instance, Tolkien's description of Aragorn as at least 6'6" and Boromir only slightly shorter, with reference to Isildur being seven feet tall, isn't presented as an artifact of the hobbit perspective, but is simply from Tolkien's own notes on the characters' appearances. Plenty of his notes don't participate in the documented-by-hobbits conceit as TH/LOTR.









