'True Detective': Why It's Good, Why It's Bad, Where It's Going
True Detective began its season on Sunday night by taking its sluggish sweet time getting around to the case that will presumably drive the eight-episode drama. Creator Nic Pizzolatto burned through some of the good will he accumulated from True Detectiveâs much-praised first, Matthew McConaughey-Woody Harrelson season by languorously filling us in on a trio of new detectives: Colin Farrellâs police detective Ray Velcoro, Rachel McAdamsâs sheriffâs detective Ani Bezzerides, and Taylor Kitsch as California Highway patrolman Paul Woodrugh. Each of them had his or her reasons to be unhappy, and, God knows, unhappiness is certainly the oppressive prevailing mood in the new True Detective.
Warning: Spoilers follow for the season premiere of True Detective.Â
No one had so much as a crooked grin in the Sunday premiere on HBO. The first shot of Farrell talking in a car, courtesy of director Justin Lin (The Fast and the Furious), was a kind of mirthlessly jokey nod to the first season: After all those rambling car conversations between McConaughey and Harrelson, we expected Farrellâs passenger to be a fellow cop. Instead, it was Velcoroâs young son, duly required to look miserable on a ride to school, new sneakers on his feet and heaviness in his heart.Â
Velcoro drinks too much, has lost his moral compass, and acts out in part because of a horrific crime committed against his wife that he feels guilty he was unable to prevent. Bezzerides and Woodrugh have their own buried-history problems. A search for a missing woman led Bezzerides very conveniently to an âinstituteâ overseen by her father, who takes his fashion look from the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. He was played by David Morse with typical finesse, even though the script required him to be little more than a counterculture burn-out, a self-centered creep who would have repelled Don Draper if the once-and-future Coke ad man had stumbled into this helter-skelter commune to perform his meditations in an emergency. And based on True Detectiveâs previous season and this new first hour, I interpreted Morseâs smug dissection of his daughterâs hostility â âyouâre angry at the entire world and men in particularâ â as a gratuitous swipe none of the men have thus far endured, a suggestion that Pizzolatto is still working through the woman-character problem that many of his critics leveled at him for True Detectiveâs first season.
Woodrughâs problems are hazier â is he depressed because heâs impotent, or impotent because heâs depressed, and how much of that is just a Viagra-stoked metaphor for his powerlessness in the True Detective triangle? â but no less tedious. Sorry, you three, but the notion that youâve had a difficult childhood is no excuse to walk around with a hate-the-world glare 24/7 once you reach adulthood. I wanted to stand Velcoro, Bezzerides, and Woodrugh in a line and slap them sequentially, Three Stooges-style, to get them to snap out of their un-funky funks.Â
I also wonder how much the blood-spraying, brass-knuckle beating Velcoro delivered to the father of a boy who bullied the detectiveâs son alienated the character from the TV audience. Pizzolatto offered it up as an intentional jolt of action, of character-establishing, of tough-guys-will-be-tough-guys fare. But coming on the heels of the controversy the recently-departed Game of Thrones season sparked over HBO-sponsored violence, that brutality is culturally provocative.
Related:Â âTrue Detectiveâ Recap: Turn Those Frowns Upside Down, Guys!
By the end of the hour, the corpse with no eyes who had a Maltese-looking falcon as a backseat companion â city manager Ben Caspere (certainly one of the more thankless roles I can recall recently) â brought our three detectives together so they could glower at the body and each other. âCaspereâs death is a window into everything,â a police official told our antiheroes â thus emphasizing the ripe irony that Caspereâs own windows, his eyes, had been burned away by acid, destroyed along with more private parts in a torture-murder.Â
Caspere was the point-man for a big business deal whose success will make or break Vince Vaughnâs casino owner Frank Semyon (what, does Nic Pizzolatto not know anyone with a simple surname like âSmithâ or âPatelâ?). Frank has his hooks in Velcoro (the former helped the latter find the guy who raped Velcoroâs wife years ago), and heâs True Detectiveâs focal point in a major land-grab scheme that will bring money into the small, corrupt town of Vinci. Instead of diverting water â the California plot-device in an obvious True Detective precursor, Roman Polanski and Robert Towneâs 1973 Chinatown â the show has Frank fixating on a high-speed rail line thatâll divert traffic and bring âhundreds of millionsâ in federal grants to the vice-ridden, scummy town of Vinci.Â
Although True Detectiveâs title necessarily places its emphasis on the three cops, the second-billed Vaughn is just as important to the prolix proceedings. A self-made man out to make himself more wealthy and powerful, Vaughnâs Frank seems, this early on, one of Pizzolattoâs more sympathetic characters, haunted by a bad, poverty-ridden childhood that renders him something more than the violent thug the cop Velcoro can be.
Itâs one thing to take your time laying out the facts that will accumulate to achieve a crime-solver plot; itâs another to keep things moving. By chance, I re-watched Robert Altmanâs 1974 The Long Goodbye not long ago and was struck by the artfully aimless yet subtly purposeful path Altman guided Elliott Gouldâs Philip Marlowe toward his Raymond Chandler-Leigh Brackett-devised mystery. You could think that, given all the genre influences Pizzolatto plants in the new season â I detailed a lot of them here â perhaps we should also think of the pacing of this new True as an homage to the discursive style of so many filmmakers who did interesting work in the â70s. (In addition to Altman, I can imagine Pizzolatto being turned on by the loser-epics of writer-directors such as Bob Rafelson, Paul Schrader, Brian DePalma, Jean-Luc Godard, Arthur Penn, Monte Hellman, late-period Sam Peckinpah, and one-offs such as Ivan Passerâs 1971 George Segal junkie film-poem Born to Win.)Â
âI welcome judgment,â Velcoro said early on in Sundayâs premiere. OK, then, hereâs mine: Based on the three episodes made available to critics, Iâm all-in for this season, no matter how much I might groan about Pizzolattoâs gassily pretentious dialogue and philosophizing. While Iâm not a sucker for that stuff, or impressed in the way of this hilariously fawning Vanity Fair profile of Pizzolatto, I do have a big appetite for hard-boiled fiction of all sorts, and so Iâm willing to cut True Detective a lot of slack. Certainly the three episodes contain individual scenes of bone-dry wit and abrupt action that give it a bruising allure. The question is whether the good genre stuff will ultimately outweigh the portentous weight the shaky plot and characterization is forced to bear so far.
True Detective airs Sundays at 9 p.m. on HBO. Â