Here's how we know Sansa isn't intentionally poisoning her cousin: we're in her head.
When she gives him the medicine, she thinks of how it will help him.
When she helps him down the mountain, she thinks of his safety.
If she wanted him dead she wouldn't be thinking that. Her internal thoughts have always reflected her true feelings, she had no issue wishing death on Joffrey. Even though she repeatedly wished and prayed for it, she was horrified at his actual death.
Seeing that happen, and then choosing to use poison again to kill one of her only remaining family members? Not happening.
Her thoughts of Sweetrobin are that he's annoying and immature. Not that she hates him and is looking forward to him being gone. She doesn't even seem to think about him being gone as a possibility. Instead, she thinks about how his wife will love his hair. She thinks about him ruling and wonders how he'll handle it.
She knows that Ned, Cat, and Robb are dead. She thinks that Bran and Rickon are dead. She thinks that Arya is dead. Her aunt is dead. Her grandfather is dead. Her uncle is hostage. Her last living family member is NOT dying at her hand.
Personally, I think he'll live. It ruins Baelish's plans and I want that to happen. He keeps underestimating his "pawns" and I want that to be another nail in his coffin.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
why did Jon Arryn choose stannis to take care of his son sweetrobert when that meant he’d be raised with shireen on dragstone by seylse as stannis is always in KL with Lysa and Jon are? Wouldn’t it have been better to have sent him to be a ward or page to his grandfather and a uncle the tullys where he’d be away but with present family and men?
Unfortunately, the primary objective of these arrangements isn't necessarily what's best for the kid's development. This isn't just like picking a school - Jon Arryn's trying to make political connections now and make political connections for Sweetrobin in the future as well. Plus he just wants his son away from Lysa, end of story.
In the near term and the medium term, choosing Stannis as a guardian for Sweetrobin shows Jon Arryn's trust in Stannis. It's a sign of commitment. The two of them are in this together: now, for the next few years, hopefully well into the future, their interests are intertwined.
In the longer term, think of what the end game of Jon Arryn and Stannis' investigation into the parentage of Cersei's children might be. Jon Arryn is sending his son to the next legitimate heir. The next legitimate heir, who has a daughter close to Sweetrobin's age, and no sons. If things go like Jon Arryn's foreseeing them, at minimum Sweetrobin's part of the heir's household. At best, there are a lot of other avenues for advancement.
Would Sweetrobin get a better education at Riverrun? Maybe, maybe not. Would he get better socialisation at Riverrun? Almost certainly. Would Jon Arryn perceive sending Sweetrobin to Riverrun as more likely to be amenable to Lysa, easier on her to deal with? Quite possibly (he'd be wrong if he did).
But he's not after the best education and best social development for Sweetrobin, nor what's best for his family's emotional life. He's after the best all-round deal, which he appears to believe is removing Sweetrobin from his mother and getting him in good with the powerful lord Jon Arryn believes to be Robert's current legitimate heir.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
I think that taking the mockingbird as his personal sigil when he’s actually a Titan is soo indicative of Baelish’s character. it’s a clear act of deception, trying to present himself as a harmless little mockingbird who takes on other birds’ fledglings into his nest (Sansa and Robert) — only he’s about as close as you can get to an actual human brood parasite who infiltrated the Tully/Arryn and Stark “nests” and forced THEM to incubate HIS schemes
— ASOS, Sansa VI
which makes me think on his relationship with Robert Arryn, who I think Baelish is very clearly poisoning with sweetsleep. to him, Sweetrobin isn’t a child to protect, rather he is a finite resource being spent buying time until his Harry and Alayne’s engagement scheme is set in stone
it’s a Greek tragedy in a way; the only way Littlefinger can keep his influence over the Vale is if Sweetrobin dies. but since he is a Titan and the boy’s surrogate father (or perhaps his biological father if you subscribe to that theory), this is very much like Cronus eating his children out of paranoid self-preservation… a mad scramble for power that will ultimately become a self fulfilling prophecy leading to his downfall
[enter sansa]
whose relationship with Baelish also offers some really interesting connections…
of course a big one is Thomas Cromwell, who himself had a son who died young from the sweating sickness (Sweetrobin parallel?) and an illegitimate daughter called Jane (Alayne) whose early life is a total mystery. much like Baelish, Cromwell built himself from nothing and rose to become one of the king’s chief ministers. like Baelish, Cromwell played a prominent role in the downfall of someone very close to the king (yes, Ned Stark is Anne Boleyn). so it’s kind of like asking “what if Cromwell took Elizabeth I under his wing by hiding her as his bastard daughter?”
but one can’t help but also think of Nabokov’s Lolita, in which Humbert Humbert marries Dolores’ mother, Charlotte, solely to gain unchecked proximity to her. with Catelyn dead (Lady Stoneheart notwithstanding), Lysa is the closest thing to a mother that Sansa has… and just like Humbert, Baelish is responsible for the mother’s death and takes advantage of it to groom the child — which is why I have him refer to Alayne as the “light of his life” in my fics
if it feels incestuous it’s because it most certainly is. not only is Baelish pretending to be Sansa’s father, he’s also legally her uncle, which is why the pomegranate scene is so apt too… as it invokes the image of Hades tricking Persephone (his niece) into eating the fruit of the underworld after kidnapping her
but unlike Persephone, Sansa does not eat any seeds. she will NOT remain in the underworld with Baelish. in fact, she will kill him
“I dreamt a wolf howling in the rain, but no one heard his grief,” the dwarf woman was saying. “I dreamt such a clangor I thought my head might burst, drums and horns and pipes and screams, but the saddest sound was the little bells. I dreamt of a maid at a feast with purple serpents in her hair, venom dripping from their fangs. And later I dreamt that maid again, slaying a savage giant in a castle built of snow.”
— ASOS, Arya VIII
Baelish, whose real sigil is the colossal Titan head, IS the savage giant in question. and Sansa, whose purple hairnet was used to poison Joffrey, is the Medusa-like figure who will slay Baelish in a castle built of snow (I think Winterfell but could be the Eyrie)
either way, Sansa symbolises life and spring. like with Persephone herself, Sansa’s return home will signify the coming of spring… the notion that Petyr Baelish’s hold on his “children” is absolute is his own delusion. unfortunately I do think that Sweetrobin is a goner, but Sansa is the wolf in a mockingbird’s nest. eventually it will bite back
TL;DR: Littlefinger is a father to no one, a parasite to all, and a man doomed to be destroyed by the children he sought to exploit…