1998 | The Spinanes - “Greetings from the Sugar Lick”
Back in the day, you couldn’t just stream new music on the internet or download mp3s. If you wanted to get into some new shit that was good, you had to read reviews (in mainstream or underground press), or listen to college radio, or sample new records at local record shops. New CDs were nominally priced at $12 to $18, same as now, but it was a lot more expensive back then.
I was always keen to find a label compilation where you could sample a bunch of upcoming releases for a low promotional price. To announce their 1998 slate of fall releases, SubPop put out Sound:CHECK, a double disc collection featuring two songs from each artist. I can’t remember what I paid, but it was for sure less than $10, and I might have gotten it for free.
As a Screaming Trees fan, I was mostly interested in hearing the new Mark Lanegan tracks. But I ended up falling in love with songs from Pernice Brothers and The Spinanes instead. The Spinanes’ Arches and Aisles and the Pernice Brothers' Overcome By Happiness would become two of my all time favorite albums. It also has standout songs from Damon and Naomi ("The Turn of the Century”), Elevator to Hell (“To Breath”), and one of my favorites from The Jesus and Mary Chain ("Degenerate”).
The Pernice Brothers is the second band from Joe Pernice following his earlier alt-country group, Scud Mountain Boys. They’ve put out a ton of good records since, but this first album is still their best. It’s maudlin and overwrought in a few spots, but when their orchestral pop isn’t being whiny and slow, it’s a graceful Elvis Costello-ish pop wonder, and it’s one of the great albums about transitioning into adulthood. My favorite Tracks: “Overcome By Happiness,” “Clear Spot,” “Monkey Suit” and “Shoes and Clothes.”
The Spinanes began as a duo featuring songwriter and singer Rebecca Gates and drummer Scott Plouf, and put out well-received records in 1993 and 1996. But Plouf left the band in 1997 to play full time with his other band, Built to Spill. Gates then recruited Joanna Bolme (Quasi, Stephen Malkmus and the Jicks) and Jerry Busher (future Fugazi roadie and percussionist) to play on a new record produced by John McEntire and recorded at Easley Studios in Memphis, where Pavement's Wowee Zowee was recorded (see my 1995 essay about Pavement, "Father to a Sister of a Thought”).
The Spinanes’ Arches and Aisles came out in September 1998, and it is the last and best of the band’s three albums. Plouf's departure freed up Gates to build a richer, more melodic and textured record than had been possible as a duo. It's the spiritual sequel to Liz Phair's Exile in Guyville that we never really got from Phair herself. It's more grown up and musically sophisticated, with post-college lyrics about office politics, business casual sex, and men who fail upward and are failing as lovers. As a dude, it can sometimes sound like you're eavesdropping and overhearing things you'd rather not hear.
But you can’t stop listening. These songs are so great. “Greetings From the Sugar Lick” is a towering, woozy hangover that culminates in pity sex, withering insults, and two brief, fuzzed out guitar solos that somehow say more than the words do. My other favorite songs: “72-74,” “Love, the Lazee,” “Reach V. Speed,” and “Den Trawler.”
Side Note 1: John McEntire’s work on this last Spinanes record was my gateway into the producer’s other musics and bands, including Tortoise, Sea and Cake, and Gastr del Sol. I would then go further down the post-rock rabbit hole with Bedhead, Jessamine, and Mogwai.
Side Note 2: My rock band was able to open for Pernice Brothers twice when they came through Houston. Nearly got to open a third show, but city officials showed up and locked the venue down before we could play because Walter’s on Washington allegedly hadn’t paid their taxes. I’m probably leaving out part of that story (correct me in the comments). We also got to do a show with Rebecca Gates once at Rudyard’s. Fewer than 10 people were at that show, and Gates didn’t seem at all happy to be there either. But some shows are like that.
Favorite lyrics:
You say she needs it, do you think she needs it? The trouble with you is you just can't see the truth We'll meet at your house, have it all out Pull your clothes off, let's get this over with
Compilation Blues:
I wanted to finish by listing some of my favorite label comps and the bands/songs I got into because of them:
Heck on Wheels Volume 3: This Warner Brothers comp featured Belly’s “Gepetto” and The Flaming Lips "She Don't Use Jelly,” but I remember it because this is how I first heard Uncle Tupelo. Their classic single “New Madrid" from Anodyne is on here.
DGC Rarities, Vol 1: This compilation had a bunch of throw away songs from a bunch of awesome 90s bands who were otherwise (with the exception of Nirvana—Kurt Cobain had just died) at the very tops of their games in July of 1994. Most of these songs are middling to terrible afterthoughts. But the Counting Crows must have misunderstood the assignment, because their included song is the career highlight and fan favorite “Einstein on the Beach (For an Eggman).” Trivia: both the Nirvana and Beck tracks begin with the lines “Monkey See…” Curiously, there never was a Volume 2. Not surprisingly, given the overall quality, there never was a Volume 2.
What’s Up Matador?: This 1997 comp was kind of a greatest hits for Matador Records, which had become the most visible and critically successful indie rock label of the 90s. For me anyway, if a record came out on Matador I knew it was gonna be good. I felt the same way about Merge and K Records too. Favorite tracks included Silkworm's “Couldn't You Wait?” and Tobin Sprout's "Small Parade,” which is easily my favorite song from Robert Pollard's early Guided By Voices sidekick.
Gimme Indie Rock, Volume 1: This 2000 compilation came from K-Tel records, which you may know as the ultra-cheesy, as-seen-on-TV purveyors of “major hits from the original artists!” K-Tel were the “Now that’s What I Call Music” of the 60s/70s/80s. The surprise is that this compilation is actually a decent survey of 80s college rock. It's missing giants like Sonic Youth and Camper van Beethoven. The comp is named after a Sebadoh song, and Sebadoh isn't here either. But it does include a lot of bands I'd not heard of at the time I bought it. It’s the first place I heard the Mekons’ sublime “Ghosts of American Astronauts.” There never was a Volume 2 for this comp either.
Exposed Roots - The Best of Alt.Country: Also from K-Tel, this 1999 comp tackled alternative country music or, “No Depression.” As with Gimme Indie Rock, K-Tel weren't able to license the most obvious champion and namesake, Uncle Tupelo. But the collection includes almost everyone else who mattered at the time. This comp introduced me to the Handsome Family, a band I am eternally falling for.
Playlist · 24 Songs


















